Then the Financial Tsunami Hit ... Frontline report


This is a front line report on the class war. Edwin Girdle (The Colonel) had an excellent business going until he needed a loan after the shock of 2008. The banks that got billions weren't lending and there was no help anywhere else in the "safety net." His story is compelling and clear. Noted at Jerome Doolittle's blog at SmirkingChimp.com who first posted this and reprinted with Mr. Girdle's permission. Michael Collins

For three years I owned and operated a mini-market/gas station in a Cincinnati, Ohio suburb. I bought an already existing store using all the assets I had, including my 401K funds, after being down-sized from my middle-management career of 22 years (in one of the many industries which the U.S. can no longer keep onshore).

Things went along fairly well and the business grew as I acquired a large clientele of regular customers from the local construction companies, other business owners, and the Ford plant. My girlfriend and I worked 90+ hour workweeks and, along with help from a few part-time employees, we operated 16 hours a day, 7 days a week, 365 days a year. In other words, I was a real practitioner of the kind of free-enterprise capitalism that our windbag politicians and business leaders praise to the heavens while making sure it doesn’t apply to them.

In the spring of 2008, I went to the county “economic development board” asking for advice about expanding my business. And because his office is in the same shopping center as my store, I walked over to Representative John Boehner’s (remember him? the Republican House Majority, now Minority, Leader?) office to ask for help. I asked the bureaucrats whether grants or tax breaks were available to help me hire employees, buy equipment, etc. No, no such thing available. Their only advice was to go to the Small Business Administration.

So I called the SBA. I won’t go into details other than that they sent out someone to take a look at my store and see if he had any words of wisdom. He was the former head of Ford’s truck and ambulance division and knew nothing I could discern about small businesses in general nor especially the retail store business.

So back I went to the county development board. After a few lengthy consultations, I was steered to a Vice President of Lending at a local branch of one of our nation’s larger banks (I won’t tell you which one, but their initials are PNC). In cooperation with that very nice VP, my girlfriend and I hashed out a business plan and jumped through a multitude of hoops necessary to secure a relatively paltry SBA loan of $75,000.

Meanwhile, I realize now that throughout the spring & summer business had started to go sour. We were close enough to our customers that many of them confided their troubles: they were losing their jobs, they were losing their homes, their own small businesses were taking on water like Katrina. We finished up our paperwork with the bank and awaited an answer.The V.P. anticipated no problem as I had A-1 credit, very little debt, and a good plan for growing the business.

Then the financial tsunami hit. Suddenly, Americans were informed the banks were bust and Wall Street toppled! Fed chief Ben Bernanke and his bankster buddies told us it was our money or our lives: we could either pony up nearly a trillion dollars or our economy would eat lead.

My business flow slowed to a trickle; people who are terrified don’t go out shopping. In the midst of all this it was announced that the bank I had asked for money was using its government bailout to buy the bank where I had my business accounts (National City). I didn’t think badly about that arrangement, until during that same time my business loan was turned down. The nice V.P. confided that “we just aren’t loaning to anyone right now. Come back in the spring and you can probably get it then.”

We hung on for five months after that. The store died a slow death. People without jobs to go to don’t buy near as much gasoline and candy. I let the employees go after the New Year holiday. In late February, I contacted the bank V.P. but was turned-down again. I heard on the news that the credit markets were still frozen.

A few weeks later, I put up the sign that said “Out of Business.” I didn’t get much out of the used equipment because so many businesses have gone belly-up that there’s a glut on the market (part of that real free-enterprise again).

I’m not embarrassed about my story because now most everyone is either financially ruined or close to it. And our so-called “leaders” don’t really seem to know or care about fixing it because the Dow Jones Average is going up again. I’m unemployed, broke, and waiting/praying/working for the revolution that seems inevitable.

(Editor’s note: Earlier today the colonel commented on Chuck Dupree’s posting, Thirty Million More Criminals. Since it follows naturally on the preceding account, I reprint it below. Jerome Doolittle)

As one of America’s many financially-ruined citizens I have first-hand frustrating experience with applying to the government for assistance. To cite two examples: 1) so that my working, divorced daughter could go to college, she needed financial help with my granddaughter’s daycare. That took seven weeks of almost daily calling the social workers and, finally, in desperation a call to our state governor’s office hotline to get results. 2) I applied for heating energy assistance for this winter, which involves getting up about 3 am in order to stand in line in the freezing cold outside the application office to get one of 25 entrance tickets at about 8 am.

I was 17th in line, because some people camp out there all night. There were about 50 people in line, which means a lot of people turned away each day. My point is that there will be a lot of poor people spending a lot of their time going begging “hat in hand” to the bureaucrats in order to buy insurance.

I was once solidly middle-class and paid taxes for 37 years before being destroyed in the Great Recession. I was surprised at how confusing, uncaring, and inadequate our social safety net is. Pray that you don’t have to find out also.

END

Permission to repring requested and granted by the author.


Michael Collins December 22, 2009 - 1:24am
( categories: Global Financial Crisis )

Permission requested and granted

ColonelGirdles Blog (About)

Edwin Girdle is a veteran of America’s class and cultural wars, peruser of generally anomalous thoughts, purveyor of widely unpopular opinions, and owner of sometimes odd experiences. He lives with his soul-mate, Myrtle, in the ruins of what was once one of the nation’s premier industrial cities.

The Colonel & Myrtle run a non-profit charity that helps those in need of food, clothing, and other necessities. Please visit their website at www.AVoiceForTheCommonwealth.org

One Response to “Edwin Girdle (The Colonel)”

Edwin Girdle Says:
December 22, 2009 at 2:23 am

Yes, please do post my essay(s) if they are of interest, and thank you for your kind remarks. I read your “Triumph of the Money Party” and thought, “Ain’t it the truth!”

Michael Collins December 22, 2009 - 1:28am

Restore the safety net. This should have been his priority from day one. Instead he wasted over a trillion dollars on banks which should have been shut down. The bankers could have turned to the soup kitchens and used food stamps like everyone else if the administration had devoted government resources to helping people, not megabanks, pharmaceuticals, and health insurance companies.

Colonel Girdle's story tells of a small business collapse that is feeding on itself, dragging down gas stations, beauty salons, accountants, restaurants, clothing stores, lawyers, building contractors, even ministers and their churches. The comments to his article on The Smirking Chimp tell the same story again and again by different people.

I certainly don't read this story in the business press. On Wall Street, everything is good news. Jobs are about to be created according to Bondad (this month or next for sure), industrial production is up, the housing market has bottomed, prices are stable along with wages, exports are booming, the recession ended months ago. Big businesses are doing splendidly because they were able to cut costs savagely to survive, and they can rely on cheap overseas workers.

We seem to have parallel universes and realities underway in our economy. Wall Street and the government are confident boom times are just around the corner. It sure doesn't sound like it, though, reading about small businesses collapsing and so many individuals flirting with bankruptcy and desperation.

Numerian December 22, 2009 - 2:10am

The Wall Street wrecking crew had three priorities after the crash: preserve their jobs, wealth, and bonuses. In reward for the smashing job they did, they've achieved all three. Mr. Girdle, on the other hand, began a charity to feed and otherwise assist those out of work. The president won't ever read this story, nor will any of his advisers, particularly Secretary Geithner and guru Larry Summers. They'll all just move along at their gloriously indifferent pace as the world collapses for the people that presidents are fond of saying are the backbone of the economy.

I agree completely on the president's priorities. The citizens of this country are upset about something, looking at the public opinion polls on presidential performance. The question is, will the White House respond. If the government won't, then it is time to simply clean house. This type of situation is totally unacceptable.

Michael Collins December 22, 2009 - 2:30am

and even in all of the posters miseries there is still hope for each other. I agree with the guy to put your money in the community(local banks and credit unions) - lets starve the big banks

Tina December 22, 2009 - 3:52am


"We're all of us children in a vast kindergarten trying to spell God's name with the wrong alphabet blocks." ~ Edwin Arlington Robinson

Celsius 233 December 22, 2009 - 8:22am

... but knowing first hand how badly affected Ohio is I doubt that a $75,000 loan could have saved his business. I think chances are that it simply would have prolonged the inevitable and saddled him with additional debt.

quax December 22, 2009 - 3:58am

You are right. Ohio has been very hard hit, particularly Cuyahoga County and the cities in the north. The government there is of no help. But SW Ohio, Cincinnati, etc. has done better than the rest of the state and I'd trust the writers judgment. The other point is, why aren't we seeing this type of business journalism. Numerians points were well taken. Small business is like education for our politicians, they love to praise it but they never really do much to help it.

Michael Collins December 22, 2009 - 4:06am

Quite simply, when I began looking into the loan it wasn't meant to save the business, it was meant to help me expand. But by the time I got the business plan written and all my other ducks in a row, the economy and my customer's lives had fallen off a cliff. You many be right that it would have only prolonged the death spiral.

colonelgirdle December 24, 2009 - 12:42am

Thanks!!! for coming online to respond and elaborate on your article. This is an excellent place to exchange ideas and the atmosphere is very civil with a little humor now and then.

Michael Collins December 24, 2009 - 5:06am

latimes.com

With credit tight and consumers still pinching their pennies, many business owners find they can't go on.
By Nathan Olivarez-Giles

December 22, 2009

The Obama administration's new plan to give a boost to small businesses reflects continued trouble in that sector, which is facing new failures even as much of the nation's economy is stabilizing.

As credit lines have shrunk and consumers have cut back on spending, thousands of small businesses have closed their doors over the last year. The plight of struggling firms has been aggravated by the reluctance of banks to lend money, said Brian Headd, an economist at the Small Business Administration's office of advocacy.

"While bankruptcies are up, overall, small-business closures are up even more," Headd said.

California has been particularly hard hit. The latest data show small-business bankruptcies up 81% in the state for the 12 months ended Sept. 30, compared with the previous year. Filings nationwide were up 44%, according to the credit analysis firm Equifax Inc.

The actual number of small businesses in trouble is probably higher, experts said, because many owners file for personal bankruptcy rather than seek protection for the business.

Dennis McGoldrick, a bankruptcy lawyer in Torrance, said his clients are all stuck in similar situations -- capital is hard to come by, customers are tough to attract and debt is piling up.

"We can't keep up," McGoldrick said. "There's more people that want to come in every day than I can see."

Cecily McAlpine, who filed for bankruptcy protection for her Cold Stone Creamery franchise this spring, said the experience was humiliating but she had no choice.

Receipts at the fledgling Compton ice cream shop plunged dramatically during the recession, and by late 2008 she was paying her employees out of her pocket.

"When the refrigerator died, that was it; I'd just had it," McAlpine said. "That was the day I broke. I just started throwing stuff away."

McAlpine recently withdrew her bankruptcy filing after selling all the store equipment and paying off her creditors. She is slowly paying off some back-rent and utility debt, and will officially dissolve her business in the next couple of weeks, she said.

"I still feel scarred and like a loser," she said. "Even though I'm not in it anymore, it's still there."

Recognizing the problems of business owners like McAlpine, the Obama administration has proposed using federal stimulus money to help funnel more loans to small businesses. The White House has also asked Congress to eliminate capital gains taxes for one year on new investments in small-business stock, and called for a new tax incentive to encourage small businesses to hire more employees.

On Dec. 14, Obama called a meeting of executives of Wells Fargo & Co., Citigroup Inc., Bank of America Corp. and nine other large banks, and told them that they owed it to the nation to make more loans to small businesses and help rebuild the economy.

In California, the need is great.

Over the last year, the Los Angeles, Riverside/San Bernardino and Sacramento metropolitan areas have led the nation in small-business bankruptcy filings, said Tim Klein, a spokesman for Equifax.

About 19,000 small businesses filed for bankruptcy in California during the 12 months ended Sept. 2009, up from 10,500 the previous year.

During September alone, 2,229 small businesses filed for protection, up from 1,503 filings in September 2008, the firm reported.

Kathleen March, a bankruptcy lawyer in Los Angeles, said she often pushes her clients to file for personal bankruptcy instead of a business filing because it's easier.

Many people also close down their businesses thinking that will solve their problems, only to find their companies' debt lives on, March said.

"The norm is if you're running a small business, you will have to either cosign or personally guarantee the significant debts," she said. "The business itself can shut down, but the people cosigned all the debts. So, the individuals are then saddled with these huge debts."

A client who owned a surf shop was paying for business expenses from the client's own funds long before filing for personal bankruptcy, she said.

"In this economy, anything that isn't a necessity is a tough business to be in," March said. "And the majority of my clients have waited too long to file for bankruptcy and in the process made things worse on themselves financially as a result."

Tina December 22, 2009 - 4:51am

latimes - Facing a budget deficit of more than $20 billion, Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger is expected to call for deep reductions in already suffering local mass transit programs, renew his push to expand oil drilling off the Santa Barbara coast and appeal to Washington for billions of dollars in federal help, according to state officials and lobbyists familiar with the plan.

If Washington does not provide roughly $8 billion in new aid for the state, the governor threatens to severely cut back -- if not eliminate -- CalWORKS, the state's main welfare program; the In-Home Health Care Services program for the disabled and elderly poor, and two tax breaks for large corporations recently approved by the Legislature, the officials said.

Schwarzenegger also will propose extending a cut in the state payroll that is scheduled to expire this summer. That cut has translated into 200,000 state workers being furloughed three days a month, the equivalent of a 14% pay cut. Lawmakers would have the option of extending the furloughs, imposing layoffs or some combination of the two.

graham December 23, 2009 - 9:40pm

All participating agents should realize that they can be financially ruined at any time. One problem is that the culture reflected by shows such as "The Apprentice" pushes people to believe that if they REALLY give it all they can make it. Of course, for each one who "makes it" there are many many "losers", those who "did not have what it takes". But those are the unavoidable casualties of "free market competition", so that the "cream can rise to the top".

creativelcro December 22, 2009 - 12:50pm

... to the too big to fail commercial entities who have the whole of the treasury as safety net. Goes without saying.

quax December 22, 2009 - 4:17pm

Like in "free market".

creativelcro December 22, 2009 - 6:18pm

That about sums it up. And when you get to the top, what a reward that is. According to Neal Barofsky, Special IG for TARP, the "top" has $27.3 trillion dollars of credit available from the various federal banking entities. Sweet deal!

Michael Collins December 23, 2009 - 8:36pm

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.