Re-reading automobile politics as cultural text


This is an inter-blog rescue of sorts I wrote reflecting on two posts by Steen Christiansen, a contributing writer at America Adrift. An assistant professor of English at Aalborg University and one of only two Danish libertarians (that I know of), he describes his research as, "working mainly on cultural transformations between high and low culture, investigating how these entities intersect and inform each other. Continuing within a cultural materialist methodology, I’m particularly interested in cultural resistance and how narratives help shape these variant forms of resistance." I'm not in the habit of cross posting work here but I thought this short piece, along with the links to Steen's very interesting and entertaining two articles would be appreciated here at the Agonist, particularly in light of yesterday's news about Chrysler's "financial re-organization."

Yesterday evening (gmt + 1) Danish teevee news live fed President Obama’s announcement that Chrysler will head into bankruptcy protection. Can anyone tell me if the CNNization of Danish news along with its increased obsession focus on live "breaking" coverage of D.C. political intrigue is merely a figment of my imagination?

A few weeks ago, thinking about the ubiquitous global financial “crisis,” particularly the massive gap between how the Establishment framed Detroit and Wall Street, I asked Steen if he’d write a follow up to his excellent post, “The Big Three Killed My Baby.” In light of yesterday's news I wanted to re post that piece, along with his recent article, "Motor City is Burning," which he graciously agreed to produce for us.

In both articles Steen explores musical arrangements as social criticism aimed at the American automobile industry, namely management of the top three automobile manufactures. The first looks at the song, "The Big Three Killed My Baby," from Detroit band The White Stripes' 1999 debut album. His recent post, examines MC5’s 1968/69 cover of John Lee Hooker's 1943 song “Motor City Is Burning."

Taken together these pieces, fascinating on their own, represent an important and critical dimension of a very real crisis in Detroit and across America. They reflect upon deep cultural attachments not only to the automobile, but to the politics and economics of the automobile industry. Steen summed up what's at stake thus, "So, once again, the fate of Detroit is closely tied to the industry and there is reason to believe that The Big Three will drag Detroit (and other cities) down with them."

Obama's address, though riddled with some progressive ideas, calls to protect the working middle class, and a green energy future, also revealed a regressive business as usual approach to handling Detroit. Consumerism as well continues to hold a central position within D.C. thinking, articulated by Obama in his address. Michael Shaw certainly didn't miss the consumption narrative's redeployment yet again with this terrific catch from a NY Times slide show. I also appreciated the way images 10 and 11 are sequenced. To continue picking on the Times, I personally felt that this image, leading the article, "Chrysler Files to Seek Bankruptcy Protection," serves as the quintessential visual narrative of how the establishment frames our automotive socio-economic discourse. Pretty clever dontcha think?

Paul Sancya/Associated Press

So what is likely to be the outcome of the current auto bail-out for Detroit, America, and the rest of the world? I trust historian David Nye will again have something important to say. But the latest headlines taken with Obama's statements lead me to imagine a continued stream of great Motor City music for Steen to analyze. Unfortunately for average Americans it will sound like more blues.

"Employees and customers watching President Obama’s announcement at Lochmoor Chrysler Jeep in Detroit. In bankruptcy, Chrysler will be able to cancel some of its dealership franchises."

(image: Paul Sancya/Associated Press, NYT)


stuart noble May 2, 2009 - 6:52am
( categories: Music )

for Detroit.
but y'all are gonna kill rock and roll dissecting it like that.
we used to think this song was hilarious when it came out, seeing as my old man was a security guard at the Cadillac plant, we'd picture ole Johnny sneakin past him. actually, my brother and me are kinda like that 49-71 Cadillac, since the Clark St plant was where our hillbilly roots met our Polack parts.

dk May 1, 2009 - 8:22am

Stuart, I hope you don't get Americanized in Denmark.

Bucksouth May 1, 2009 - 10:33pm

slow reply.

And thanks for sharing that with us dk. I once dated girl in South Texas with "hillbilly roots and Polack parts." I don't think there's any cure for that malady.

Bucksouth. The Americanization of Danish media, in my mind, has definitely contributed to altering cultural norms towards more neo-liberal and individualistic world views here. You see it in many places. See three consecutive neo-liberal/conservative governments for example. Denmark's welfare state, while I'd still take it any day over most, is certainly not what it used to be. I recently saw a "serious" program discussing whether or not the welfare state had a future in Denmark. But that's how media hegemony works don't it. I've retreated to my colony garden, where at least I find some salvation from the relentless American corporate propaganda machine. No electricity up there means NO Teevee!

stuart noble May 4, 2009 - 1:23am

living in that shithole apartment on Harrison Ave. Talk about way back machine.

Fuck it man, I'd wade through a river of shit ten times to see this place. ~ On Istanbul, April 2009

Sean Paul Kelley May 4, 2009 - 2:58am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.