Bob Barr changes the game


I am telling people, and I hope they listen, two things:

1. Don't read polls for the Presidency at this point.
2. Don't listen to anything the candidates have to say from this point on.

Because I remember 1988, that's why.

Many of you don't remember 1988. It was the year that wasn't. We could have put a stake in many of the worst social elements of Reagan, and dealt with the S&L bail out in a better way had Dukakis won that year. Let me paste a few paragraphs from E.J. Dionne penned in May, 1988:

LEAD: Michael S. Dukakis is capitalizing on deep public doubts about Vice President Bush and the Reagan Administration's handling of key issues and has emerged as the early favorite for the Presidential election in November, according to the latest New York Times/CBS News Poll.

Mr. Dukakis, the probable Democratic nominee, ran ahead of Mr. Bush, the almost certain Republican candidate, by 49 percent to 39 percent among 1,056 registered voters.

That's right, Dukakis was up 10 points in May 1988. 10. Ten. 10. Ten. Up against a fumble mouthed loser whose best quote was gutting the very policies he was running on: "Voodoo Economics". Those were heady days.

The final result? 53-45 Bush, an 18 point reversal.

What happened?

"Great, we just went to working for the next President of the United States, to working for Snoopy the Wonder Beagle."

And then the verb Horton entered the language.

And then the death penalty - remember that? - in the debate.

So what am I watching? News like this: Bob Barr wins the Libertarian nod. Barr doesn't have to do much, just 1% nationally, to tilt the field substantially.

The dominance of the right as the ideology of the United States has produced two sizeable third party runs. The first was the division of liberalism, where liberal Republicans bolted for Jon Anderson, rather than back Carter. The second was the run of Perot. Bob Barr could become the third, and the game changer for Obama in the general election. His impact is going to be marginal, but it puts a head wind in the upper mid-west, where McCain must challenge to put Obama on the defensive. McCain's offense list includes New Jersey, New Hampshire, Pennsylvania, Michigan, Wisconsin, and Minnesota. Barr hurts him in all of these states by enough. It moves New Jersey back into the wishful thinking category, it robs him of the gun votes in New Hampshire and Pennsylvania. It takes the tax haters away across the boards. It brings no new voters.

It also opens the south to offense. Florida most importantly, but also Arkansas, Virginia, North Carolina. It means that McCain must now not only play defense with social conservatives, but with people who should be McCain's without effort: the guns and gumption crowd.

Barr is going to be the home of Republicans against losing wars. He stands in favor of the most important Libertarian principle there is: getting paid lots of money working defense jobs and living off of government subsidies that other people pay taxes for.

Doing a fast poll look the key changes can be summarized as it makes the holds of NJ and PA almost certain with the right VP pick for the Democrats. It makes it so that Wisconsin is an easier hold. Michigan is still problematic if McCain teams up with Romney. It makes the toss ups of New Hampshire, New Mexico, Florida, and Iowa easier for Obama. It helps out Colorado in play. It also means that Democrats can go on the offensive in other places.

These are the things that are important: fundamentals. Watch the fundamentals.

Bob Barr entering the race is a fundamental. Whether Obama can get Hillary to drop out nicely is a fundamental. What the Republican smear is, is a fundamental.

Watch these things, not yesterday's polls.

The reality here is that the Libertarian movement was always about slopping at the government trough, and cheap money, cheap land, and cheap gas. The war in Iraq, and subsequent gas tax bail out breaks the social contract by which pot smoking porn loving small government types vote for the largest expansion of the Federal Government since the second world war, religious fundamentalism, and an erosion of anything resembling a strict reading of the constitution.

Obama still has a problem, he's got to get back constituencies ready to bolt the Republican Party, but his problem just got easier, as one of the constituencies that never was going to vote for him has just leaned a bit farther out of McCain's grasp.


Stirling Newberry May 25, 2008 - 7:58pm
( categories: USA: Campaign 2008 )

This is what did Dukakis in. He gave the Bushites a clear target and they used it to good effect. Too bad the Democrats didn't make more of GHWB's prior tenure as the chief of the state secret police--or pound on his involvement in Iran-Contra.

Petronius May 25, 2008 - 10:02pm

Yes, George Bush Sr. was indeed a "fumble mouthed loser", but Dukakis was.. well.. Dukakis. Even without the tank pic, he was bland, tepid, uninspiring, short and not particularly attractive physically. (It sucks the last two matter, but they do.) Obama has flaws, but none of these are among them.

I do agree 100% that reading polls or predicting the outcome today is pointless.

geoduck May 25, 2008 - 10:31pm

Will I ever understand how Dukakis triumphed over Gephardt that year? It's also a shame that Mario Cuomo didn't run then.

Nominay May 26, 2008 - 12:13am

Iowa was written off, Gep played badly in the East, Gore was too green, Dukakis had a record as governor, money, and patience to defeat one by one the other candidates.

Stirling Newberry May 26, 2008 - 1:48am

and Jesse Jackson was, as Bill Clinton reminded us earlier this year, black.

Nominay May 26, 2008 - 4:42am

Here's one to check: there are a ton of Ron Paul delegates and alternates headed to the GOP state convention this week. Rumored that Paul himself will speak early Friday - there is apparently a fear among GOP leadership that the Paul people are going to seize control right away.

Similar to Nevada?
http://www.ronpaul2008.com/press-releases/306/

RENO, NEVADA — The Nevada State Republican Convention was called to an abrupt halt on Saturday, after delegates supporting Texas Congressman and presidential candidate Ron Paul were elected to the 2008 Republican National Convention.

Prior to the recess, the John McCain campaign asked for and was not granted a recess to meet with their delegates. In response, Convention Chairman Bob Beers unexpectedly announced that the contract on the convention hall had expired and the convention would be reconvened at some future date. The Ron Paul campaign is confident that the Nevada State Republican Party will ensure that the votes cast by of all of the delegates at the April 26th Nevada State Republican Convention will be respected.

Curious about what'll happen, I'll be around as a vendor and possibly liveblogging for my job actually...
--
Hongpong.com

HongPong May 26, 2008 - 7:56pm

It would be an ironically perfect symmetry if the riots at a political convention that Rush Limpball so fervently hopes for would happen in the Twin Cities among the Republiterians.
Not that I would wish for such a thing or anything like that.

JT May 26, 2008 - 8:26pm

That sums up the 'conservatives' I know. One old high school buddy has a physical therapy clinic where he charges Medicare up the wazoo to massage old people.

He is raking in the dough. But when I met with him last Spring, he kept asking about how 'conservative' my family/I were/was.

Gimme a break.

As Naomi Klein might point out, we've exchanged 'big government' with tractable employees and strict bureacratic oversight, for a 'client government' with self interested ''private'' players lobbying for cash and writing big bundles of campaign checks to their Senators.

Thank God these people are rugged individualists and not suckling piglets of the government teet.

KingElvis May 28, 2008 - 9:05am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.