Sanity Outbreak on Ballots


Remember how after the Florida election debacle "hanging chads" were blamed for everything? Remember how the narrative was that the problem was that it was hard for people to use the machines, and therefore the solution was bright shiny video poker voting machines? It was insane, as anyone who looked at the myriad of vote scams on the ground in Florida knew - and I had. Things have come full circle where the NIST bluntly states that electronic voting machines cannot be made secure.

Paper has its problems, but it is still easily the best solution to having a one way blind election system. That is, one where you know how you voted, and it can be checked, without knowing how each person voted. Electronic machines can only be made secure by breaking the wall of secrecy which is essential to what was once called "The Australian Ballot".


Stirling Newberry December 1, 2006 - 9:25am

Local elections in Canada this year, at least in my city of Waterloo, Ontario, used a voter marked, optically scanned ballot. There was no confirmation, though, which I wasn't keen on at first. Then I realized that a scanning machine's confirmation ticket is not worth the electrons used to print it if the machine is scamming you anyway. Its only use would be as a second, paper ballot for the purposes of recounts.

ssclift December 1, 2006 - 12:58pm

Simple, optically-scanned paper ballots returned by mail or dropped into special collection boxes scattered about the landscape (when they're not being used to collect ballots, they can be used to deposit one's property tax payment). No polling places and plenty of observers when the ballots are counted.

Simple. Cheap. Reliable. Verifiable.

I don't know why the rest of the country doesn't do it this way. If we went that way with the national vote, you could return your filled-out ballot by dropping it in any US mailbox.

Petronius December 1, 2006 - 8:03pm

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.