So what are we doing about it?


Content here at the Agonist has been pretty bleak lately.

There are obvious reasons--the state of the USA, as well as international news coming out of countries like Burma; along with less obvious ones--some of our community members are dealing with traumatic events, we're burning Ian out with his valiant writing efforts, and as a group I think we can fairly lay claim to a certain level of burnout, too.

But burnout and despair don't get our problems solved, and alienating people from hope and reality-based optimism doesn't move a progressive agenda forward.

Now, I have to give a personal thanks to the community around the Agonist. I know that you are an incredibly intelligent, informed, and actively engaged group of people who, as individuals, are doing what you can to make a difference. (How do I know? Your comments here, my conversations with you in less public channels, and what Sean-Paul has shared with me about you.) You're an impressive group, and you've reaffirmed my faith in "regular people" on many occasions.

We're all facing dark days, and I know that our community members have rolled up their sleeves to work on solutions. That can mean cutting a check or volunteering your time for a good cause; it can mean working in a job where you can make a difference; or it can mean making conscious, progressive choices in child-rearing and elder-care and how you manage your personal consumption of resources. It can mean a host of innovative, passion-driven actions ranging from the public and high-profile to the intimate and personal.

I have a favour to ask you: could you share your personal stories of what you're doing?

How did you get so on fire about a problem or issue that you decided to do something about it? What did it take to get involved and what are you doing now? What advice would you give for someone who cares about the same things?

One of the failings I find with political websites is that the messages are disproportionately about what "those people" should do: whether "those people" are elected officials, civil servants, executives at large corporations, citizen of other countries...somehow the responsibility, and indeed the ability, for effecting change seems to fall on someone else, and inevitably on someone who is remote and inaccessible.

How about what we can do? Or better yet, what we are doing?

So I'm asking, as a personal favour, for you to please let us know some of what you're doing, or what you're aware of that's going on in your communities. Leave a comment here, or if it gets long, go write a stand-alone post.

I think we could all use a dose of hope, and I look forward to hearing what everyone is up to.


Shaula Evans October 6, 2007 - 8:21am
( categories: Agonist )

Rebirth of the Goddess, by Carol Christ.

wherein she named Nine Touchstones of the ethics of Goddess religion:

Nurture life.
Walk in love and beauty.
Trust the knowledge that comes through the body.
Speak the truth about conflict, pain, and suffering.
Take only what you need.
Think about the consequences of your actions for seven generations.
Approach the taking of life with great restraint.
Practice great generosity.
Repair the web.

I had no trouble with Carols' manifesto back then, and only wish we could yell it even more loudly today.

graham October 7, 2007 - 6:03am

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ten_Commandments

and she's lenghtening the contract, used to be only 3-4 generations, not 7. lol
you know your Bible better than I. what did Jesus say was most important?
editted to add: I think Luke 10:25-28 is what I had in mind.
we seem to have a hard time defining neighbors

dk October 7, 2007 - 6:18am

let me take off my patriarchial hat for a moment, and note that for maybe 50-60,000 years, the womb not the phallus was the predominant cultural metaphor.

Sex therefore served as an icon of the self becoming itself, a very different representational value, relating to erotic desire of divine becoming itself. We are made from stardust and we seek to return to the stars.. We are all neighbours, sharing in the cosmic dance.

The symbol of the womb is not a thrusting, pulsating overwhelming power representation. Rather the womb prefigures the whole human being, a being to be inclusive, embracing, nurturing, intimate - a gentle energy but more overwhelming than the brief pulse of the penis.

The long oppressive history of patriarchal dominance and interference, instilled by male models of philosophy initially and then male led medical practice, debased and decreased a holistic understanding of sexuality that included the female perspective.

As humanity settled into the city lifestyle and war became male dominated, the very idea of neighbour changed.

Today, as in Jesus' day neighbour is someone who lives nearby and implicity has the same value system.

Hence love your enemies became a profound metaphor for early christians. By the middle ages the dictum became personified and thus legitimised warfare between cities/states and countries.

Tolstoy railed against militant nationalism, and used the injunction to love thy enemy as his primary text.

I am continuall amazed by customers who come in and abuse me for stocking books on Buddhism, Islam, and Judaism; truly we have a long way to go in understanding who our neighbour is.

/aside.
Master 23 is watching the southpark episode on Mel Gibson and the Passion as I type this: "we live in a rational community and everybody knows this is only a movie" Sadly for many Iraq is just a movie on the tv news.

I better turn off this stream of consciousness and go to sleep. Nite :)

graham October 8, 2007 - 6:01am

another glass of wine on me! you wrote that? that was beautiful.
I was looking for the link for that before I realized that was you writing. you sounded just like a goddess worshipping feminist whose boyfriend came before she did! wow , lol.
did we ever discuss "When God was a Woman"?
you're spot on in your analysis, IMO. while I was trying to figure out that it was Luke I was remembering, (but really it must have been Matthew), I came across a scripture about the universe, the world, and Mary's womb being the point of creation. and Jesus being the point of that point. you know this one?
says to me that we all carry the divine spark. and Catholics know women are important, hence the exalted position of Mary not present in Protestantism. but lordy aren't you men scared of Mary Magdalene? you shouldn't be, note that they share the same name. men catagorize women into sluts and mothers, we are all of the above. but it's nothing to fear.

dk October 8, 2007 - 6:34am

Mary Magdalene: Natural, uncontrolled, daemonic, chthonian, untamed. Scary.

Mary, Mother of God: Demure, submissive, controlled, Apollonian. Not quite so scary.


"Vanity, Vanity, all is Vanity."

Raja October 8, 2007 - 9:43am

just a brain dump of a range of stuff I have read over the years.

re 'point'I think you may be referring to Teilhard de Chardin, but
possibly von balthasar(have you read him?).

Peter Kreeft writes a reflection as Jesus: So the universe was a womb for humanity, and humanity was a womb for Israel, and Israel was a womb for Mary, and Mary was a womb for me. Thus, Mary is the point of the universe, and I am the point of that point but I have not got the book so cannot check if he is quoting someone else.

My nursing career cured me of any fear of women lol.

off to work, so can't stop and write more, later!

graham October 8, 2007 - 4:54pm

thanks I was never gonna find that again, but I remember he had a funny name. I was reading a review of his book. geez, I just assumed since Kreeft wrote "I am the point of that point" it referred to a quotation somewhere, but now I see what you mean. you know I don't practice but it's the closest culturally to me so I use Christianity as a reference a lot. as artappraiser would say, I just "cherry pick" the parts I like out of all the major religions. but I trust my insticts still. ah! maybe we're back to the animal/pre-language/subconscious morality/inner voice/soul thingee. now if only I could make myself understood! but I know you follow....

dk October 8, 2007 - 8:58pm

I am continuall amazed by customers who come in and abuse me for stocking books on Buddhism, Islam, and Judaism; truly we have a long way to go in understanding who our neighbour is.

At the same time, I'm always inspired by the books of dialogue between religions. It sounds like getting people to read them is a whole other project, but I'm glad they're being written.

Shaula Evans October 10, 2007 - 12:31am

Thanks, Graham7 -- I've never seen it before.

The nine touchstones are remarkably similar to Buddhist ethics.

One of my perennial favourite books is Mind of Clover: Essays in Zen Buddhist Ethics by Robert Aitken. I find it incredibly grounding and reaffirming to read. (It is definitely on my desert island reading list.)

Shaula Evans October 10, 2007 - 12:29am

personal projects? Mine don't make very good stories.
I have been neglecting my blog: The Executioners Thong for reasons not quite the same as burnout but close. Point to what is wrong, cruel and dishonest in the way the nation is being run is not choice...the only good news is the occasional breakthrough in medicine or science. And the bush league are busy gutting science where they can.

I am biking to work, I am designing solar powered AC equipment, I still show up at the rallies when MoveOn sends out the word.

But talking, writing or doing, its all the same: a lot of the positive stuff we'd rather do and write about won't happen until every loose dollar that can be borrowed ceases to flow into inhumane causes and eventually the pockets of the republicans favorite corporations.

I LOVE reading Ian, Stirling, SPK and others.

Shaula: "...starved for a sense of community..." Bingo! There is a reason for me to try and keep engaged. I may not solve many problems but at least I'll run into some sympathetic company

greensmile October 7, 2007 - 7:30am

I'd beg to differ, greensmile. Yours make great stories.

(I am not surprised, but I do think it is great how many people here bike for transportation, and now many are into solar power and alternative energy.)

Shaula Evans October 10, 2007 - 12:33am

heh, really. gallows humor is so rich in the blogosphere.

i do plenty, the basics that all progressives should do. i volunteer, i shop locally, i conserve in all the ways i'm supposed to, i'm politically active in my community. and i blog. not sure what impact that has, but it gives me an outlet and a place to be in the company of the Equally Bleak.

chicago dyke October 7, 2007 - 7:32am

from one chicago dyke to another, you should come to the benefit we're having today at FEED. you know I always resented that old agonistas might mistake you for me when you first arrived here, but not any more. yours is a similar but distinct and much more resonant voice.
please come breakfast, lunch or dinner
2803 W. Chicago Ave. corner of California

dk October 7, 2007 - 7:41am

We the equally bleak are certainly delighted to be in your company, babe. :)

Shaula Evans October 10, 2007 - 12:34am

Whoever those may be. Damn. Also, I just saw the latest Resident Evil. Now, THAT is bleak.

creativelcro October 7, 2007 - 11:07am

someone talked about how we should get away from the Internet. The same thought occurred to me about a month ago. It was then that I decided to work as a volunteer for the local candidate of the provincial Liberal party of Ontario. Not only did I land amongst people who like myself are passionate about politics, but also, I have never had so much fun. Yesterday, I helped barbecue hot dogs (I am a vegetarian – lol) for the workers in the campaign office, canvassed on the phone for a while and spend the afternoon ‘mainstreeting' with a group of people including the candidate himself as well as George Smitherman, the minister of Health of the provincial government. While speaking to people in the street and handing out pamphlets, we met another group of canvassers from a different party. Suddenly, I found myself face to face with Jack Layton, the leader of the NDP. He had a wide grin on his face and, since we're all Lefties, I felt like giving him a big hug. lol. However, I contained myself and gave him a ‘firm' handshake instead. On Election Day, I will do whatever is required; I may act as a poll clerk like Canuck, I may offer people rides to the polling station etc. Then, after the polling stations close, I'll join in to, hopefully, celebrate at a big party for the campaign workers.

Regarding “Dealing with Problems” by David Caruso – whenever I’m faced with a problem I always ask myself what the worst case scenario would be. I then familiarize myself with this hypothetical situation and start looking at my options. This is a mental exercise I perform that somehow reduces the size of the problem. It always works well for me since the worst case scenario rarely presents itself. And if it did, I’ve already found a solution for it.

When I first discovered the Agonist I used to marvel at the superior intellect, wisdom and sublime command of the English language of its contributors. I must have visited for about a year before I posted my first fateful comment. In the beginning I vacillated between contributing to the posts or remaining silent. I believed that I wasn't smart enough. However, I managed to talk myself out of this inferiority complex and since then I've learned how to navigate through the myriad of topics. I automatically grab my dictionary when I come across a JPD post. And ES, you've referred to the “Overton Window” twice this year.:-) Like everyone else, I've got my favorite posters – their comments are usually brief, to the point and funny. Anyhow, I will continue to try and improve my English. What springs to mind is the movie “Il Postino”. I remember a scene on the beach where the postman dreamily recounts and admires the metaphors used by the poet Neruda. Sometimes I feel like that postman, when I sit here and dreamily admire the structure of a sentence or a metaphor used by someone to strengthen an argument.

Thank you for this wonderful post Shauna and for your words of encouragement. It’s interesting to read some of the personal stories and experiences of the Agonistas. It’s here at the Agonist where I can let reign my fiery side. The other side of me, the gentle person, I reserve for my patients in the community who are dying. I am grateful for the many comments of appreciation I receive from the families. Appreciation for a job well done is not expressed enough in our working world. It’s a pity because people thrive on appreciation.

This brings me to Ian. I have been a silent admirer of your work for a long time. I’m always amazed at the variety and depth of the topics you bring to this forum. You are responsible for most of the stimulating discussions that take place. It always saddens me when you are subjected to hurtful comments. You deserve better. Keep it going, Ian.

And then there’s Tina, the ‘all-seeing’ Tina. She darts around - gives a comment here, posts a follow up there, poses a question, answers a question and the list goes on and on. Your contribution to this site is immeasurable. A heartfelt thank you for all that you do.

SPK and Stirling, also many thanks for your exceptional gifts.

Finally, I honestly believe the world would be a better place with more Quiet Bills and Ricks who are always humming in the background to keep this site sailing smoothly.

Happy Thanksgiving!

adrena October 7, 2007 - 1:50pm

There is really a wonderful set of official and unofficial editors here. :) I must admit that lots of little birdies that whisper in my ears in order for me to keep up. I am always amazed when I have the time to look thru recent posts and diaries how much I miss! And also don't forget the wonder humor and cultural posts by Doug. :)

Tina October 8, 2007 - 6:05am

Thank you for handing out all the accolades, adrena. The amount of work that goes into this place is boggling, and it is great to see people publicly recognized. (And the moral support goes a long way.)

I'd probably hug Jack Layton if I got to meet him, too. (Or at least that would be my first instinct.)

My heart goes out to you on the hot dogs. At one point when I was eating completely vegan, I wound up making Thanksgiving Dinner for 120 people....

I've handed out grip cards at the polls on election day, worked phones, coordinated volunteers, done tech support, helped set up a coordinated victory party...it's like opening night on a theater run, no matter what part you're involved in: crazy energy, lots of excitement, and hundreds of people holding their breath.

I hope you will give us an update on how election day goes and what you wind up doing.

Shaula Evans October 10, 2007 - 12:41am

(I thought some people might take offence if I wrote "irregular people.")

Shaula Evans October 10, 2007 - 12:35am

as much as i hate to say that, it's true. it takes faith to make those small choices and acts often enough to make a difference, though it's daunting. and then it takes faith to do more, because you feel alienated by activism in the media. it's portrayed as woefully uncool and rare to care about stuff.

i am an optimist. i refuse to indulge in what i'm referring to as "political nihilism"; the belief that nothing will improve, regardless of our efforts. both are positions of faith. one will eventually be true, and i hope it's mine. similarly, admonishing "those people" is as you've said, depressing and apparently inadequate. thank you for inviting these stories, because what's needed is more of us to enable this optimism: the world can be saved if you come and join us.

i recently hosted my first moveon event. i regularly contact my representatives. i'm participating in a group trying to spread ecological practices and awareness in the community. i'm consistently trying to write and act from the perspective that things could be better, but i'm grateful for how far we've come.

thanks again. keep it up. this is exactly what we should be doing.

bs October 7, 2007 - 6:04pm

I mean, spiritual support! :)

creativelcro October 7, 2007 - 8:28pm

as solely synonymous with Christianity. That's fingernails on my own personal chalkboard.


"The best-informed man is not necessarily the wisest. Indeed there is a danger that precisely in the multiplicity of his knowledge he will lose sight of what is essential."

- Dietrich Bonhoeffer

Escher Sketch October 7, 2007 - 10:11pm

I do my best to share your attitude...I've had a ring-side seat on Virginia state politics for a while, and the infighting and ineptitude and sheer pettiness is so disheartening.

That's why I love stories about DOING: they make a great antidote.

Shaula Evans October 10, 2007 - 12:45am

What I've been doing is thinking and writing. It may seem rarified but I must insist that until the Left gets it together philosophcially nothing can move forward. I see that there have been quite a few posts that seem to cross the line between what I believe can be done in a republican democracy and what could be said to lie beyond the scope of this noble but superceded project. I wish to quote from Cary Nederman apropos this: "If the downfall of principalities is the fixed structure of human character, then the failing of republics is a devotion to the perpetuation of institutional arrangements whose time has passed." I have come to believe that it is liberalism itself that is the key arrangement whose time has passed. Political liberalism in its most fundamental sense is what I am referring to. Bentham, Mill, Locke. All heroes to me, but to continue to embrace them uncritically is to be fighting a war rooted in eighteenth-century social dynamics. Looking back to the Sixties can be more than mere nostalgia, I believe principally because at bottom this movement for liberation ultimately rejected liberalism. "Compromise solution" leads to stagnation, and the sort of drift that power can naturally use to further its own ends on an institutional scale. Ther are two main forks in this road, one which places the liberation of humanity at its center and one which places the liberation of the individual at its center. You say, what about a combination, but it just doesn't work that way. Marx believed that his collectivist revolution would also liberate the individual, but in fact personal autonomy was not a priority with the communists. When the association is paramount, the individual is sacrificed. We must form unions of some kind to end Authority, but it is critical that these associations be constituted in such a way that the individual is not its servant. Liberalism can now only serve the elites which have brought this social system into being. That this system admits many more members and kinds of members than any that has existed before is not a relevant point, since the requirements for entry no longer meet the needs of the freedom-seeking person. They are rooted in the old 18th-and 19th-century conception of the citizen, fundamentally Protestant, male, and interested in economic stability in such a way as to marginalize any personality type but what would now be called the "corporate" one. Homo economicus doesn't look like he did 150 years ago, but he lurks beneath the surface of the social organism still. Now females and people of color are admitted if they dampen their otherness and behave like Protestant males of the nineteenth century in certain crucial aspects. The important thing is a devotion to work. Liberalism is therefore basically hostile to eroticism and play, and Huizinga has shown that play is the fundamental drive of humanity. This patriarchal substrate is what must be overthrown. Out time to be alive is short. The revolution, I insist, is maximized by self-realization. Not to be construed as petty egotism, but an egoism that has passed through many stages to arrive at a self that has freed itself of petty particularisms. One must be invested personally at the deepest levels of our beings to gain the resolve necessary for this Herculean task which looms before us.

David Westling October 9, 2007 - 12:40am

have put into replying to the posts on this thread.

Too often the personal response is what is lacking on so many websites.

We need to continually nurture and encourage each other.

You set an awesome example. Thank you.

graham October 10, 2007 - 3:40am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.