- click here
Editor in Chief: Steve Hynd News Editor: Tina Contributing Editor: Raja Special Contributor: Numerian Contributor: Don Henry Ford, Jr. Assoc. Contributor: Brian Downing Assoc. Writer: Cliff Schecter Assoc. Writer: Nat Wilson Turner Editor Emeritus:Sean Paul Kelley
Tracy Barnett Balloon Juice Drudge Retort Electric Politics The Gist Informed Comment In The Pink Col. Patrick Lang Lance Mannion Mondoweiss Raw Story Jia Tolentino's Books Bruce Schneier Seeing the Forest Skippy the Bush Kangaroo
aliasBruce Arms Control Wonk Jack Cluth Feministing Istanbul Notes Istanbul Calling Beyond Bridges The Reaction Rook's Rant Rubber Hose
Mixed Bag of Candy: Newshoggers Crooks and Liars Scholars and Rogues Ian Welsh Corrente PKU News St Martin Private Eye
Corner: Media Matters Rethink Afghanistan truthout AlterNet truthdig Glenn Greenwald Elephant Journal
Brian Downing's Picks: Al Jazeera Asia Times Night Watch Emirates Journal Soldiers for the Truth The War Report Iraq Casualties Global Security Nat's Nuclear Jazz Lounge: After the Future Grits For Breakfast Clusterfuck Nation The Narcosphere Latin America Herald-Tribune The Latin Americanist Boing Boing
Numerian's Numbers: Mother Jones Tom Dispatch Der Spiegel Big Picture Calculated Risk Bonddad House Bubble Prudent Bear
While everyone is busy worrying about Matt Lauer's new affair, let's take a moment to remember the fact that the oil spill continues. Now. In the present. And it's possibly leaking 70,000 barrels of oil a day.
It is the equivalent of one Exxon Valdez every four days. It is absolutely, utterly cataclysmic. That is not hyperbole.
Drill, baby, drill.
Links: Could leak for years.
U.S. Said to Allow Drilling Without Needed Permits
We Have No Idea How Much Oil Is Really Leaking
BP Has ‘No Certainty’ About Scale Of Disaster
Since Spill, Feds Have Given 27 Drilling Waivers
Gulf oil spill FAR worse than estimated
Odd Smells in New Orleans Conjure Up Thoughts of the Gulf
Gulf Gusher, Worst Case Scenario.
I suspect that number is high. This estimate of 26,500 barrels a day seems reasonable. That number is staggering when you consider the flow continues.
I did inhale.
is that British Petroleum executives have been lying their asses off to Congress and anyone else foolish enough to listen, in an attempt to deflect blame and vastly underestimate the severity of the worst man-made environmental catastrophe in history. Until their next one, that is...
How many more disasters will we allow these corporate vampires to create before we finally put limits on their power? . Cows get milked, rubes get bilked, And fat cats dine on fools and cream.
* steel wellpipe erodes rapidly when crude oil is allowed to flow through it at full pressure (crude contains large amounts of silica). The wellpipe thins and then ruptures, letting the oil get at the rock and soil the pipe passes through. In this case, the sediment surrounding the wellpipe is soft, accumulated silt and sand. No granite, no basalt. Seabed. The stuff sand castles are made of.
* in a well-managd oil well, pressure is kept to a rate that maximizes the useful life of the steel wellpipe. By the time it is worn thin, other wells have been opened, and this first one can be sealed.
* sticking a fire truck hose into your garden soil will show you what this oil reservoir will do to the seabed once the wellpipe ruptures.
* So we have until 'the rupture' to close this thing. After that, there is nothing humans can do to close what may well become a hole several thousand feet wide, venting gas and crude oil as fast as it can leave the reservoir. As the reservoir vents, seabed will fall into it, opening the hole further, venting all the faster, rinse and repeat.
* this means the end of our oceans (thanks to the Gulf Stream) and the end of our atmosphere and the end of our climate as we know it.
* there may be species that can survive this 'caldera event' of the wellpipe rupturing into an open hole in the ocean. Species that thrive in the presence of hydrocarbons.
* is one of 'em us?
And this well has extra sand it seems. The folks at the oil drum are talking about how the leaks are getting worse because of the erosion of the pipes by the sand and the BOP is not immune.
I've no idea where these estimates in the 10s of millions of barrels are coming from - every one I've seen puts the reserve in the billions of barrels - at least 4 billion.
When the existing riser erodes away - and it will very quickly - the rate of escape will multiply quickly, then even more as the downhole casing gives way and the hole is rendered wide open. The theoretical limit on the 7" rathole which penetrated the reservoir will quickly become meaningless as the hole erodes.
3 months to drill a pressure relief well will simply be too late - not to mention that they never got the necessary (geomag) logging tools down the original hole to know exactly how to intersect it. It's a pure shot in the dark. Nevertheless, in three months the borehole will be much, much wider, and even running wide open theres enough product down there to flow for years at that rate.
But the ELE in all of this may be the gas. A sudden escape of the gas reserves there will give new meaning to Texas barbeque.
You threw in a zinger there at the end. Could you tell us ignorant ones more about what could happen with that?
The reserve is estimated to contain 9 trillion cubic feet of gas. A sudden release of even a small percentage of that would be truly catastrophic.
The slashdot link now in the article. The potential for an ELE here is both real and increasing with every day that the blowout is open.
BP later acknowledged to Congress that the worst case, if the leak accelerated, would be 60,000 barrels a day, a flow rate that would dump a plume the size of the Exxon Valdez spill into the gulf every four days. BP’s chief executive, Tony Hayward, has estimated that the reservoir tapped by the out-of-control well holds at least 50 million barrels of oil. NYT
It sounds like they know how bad it really is.
The analysis of the video already pegs it at 70000, and again, that's with all of the existing risers and casings holding fast. At this point I give no credit to the estimates being laid out - neither for leak rate nor reserve capacity.
Nevertheless, the Macondo Prospect (geological site of the catastrophe) doesn't seem to be directly attached to the Tiber field, which is where I got my estimates of 4000 million - it's a bit north of the Tiber. Tiber field has the last successful well drilled by the Deepwater Horizon - which led to my confusion.
The gas estimates in Macondo though, are quite simply off the charts. I'll see if I can find those again.
Mississippi Canyon reserve (where Macando prospect is located):
3,528 million barrels of oil (at 60 degrees F) 8,956 billion cubic feet of gas (at 60 derees F and 15.025 psi)
http://www.gomr.mms.gov/PDFs/2009/2009-022.pdf
Almost 9 trillion cu/ft. Its difficult to quantify it - enough to supply the needs of the US for several hundred years. Or enough to cause a methane hurricane...
has made us all feel better by explaining that, whatever the size of the gusher, it is a very small leak in a very big ocean. Of course, the people who have data which might help you make a sound estimate aren't sharing.
take cyanide, it is a very small pill in a very large body...
bbc
Obama: 'No more cosy relationship'
US President Barack Obama has vowed to end the "cosy relationship" between oil companies and US regulators in the light of the Gulf of Mexico disaster.
Promising "relentless" efforts to stop the oil leak, he rebuked oil industry executives for seeking to pass on blame for the disaster.
He condemned "the ridiculous spectacle" of oil executives "falling over each other to point the finger of blame".
Mr Obama was speaking after meeting his cabinet at the White House.
A lack of vigilant oversight contributed to the oil rig explosion, he said in the Rose Garden.
Federal regulators had, he said, sometimes approved drilling plans based on the oil companies' promises to use safe practices.
The rule from now on, the president said, would be "trust but verify".
Eleven people died when an explosion destroyed the Deepwater Horizon drilling rig on 20 April.
Owned and operated by Transocean, the rig had been working on behalf of BP.
Thousands of barrels of oil have been gushing daily into the sea from the broken well pipe since then, threatening the delicate ecosystem of the US Gulf coast.
BP is using underwater robots in its latest attempt to stop the leak, which involves jamming a tube into the pipe to divert oil to a tanker on the surface.
'The system failed'
Mr Obama said he shared the anger felt by Gulf Coast residents over the oil spill.
"The potential devastation to the Gulf Coast, its economy and its people require us to continue our relentless efforts to stop the leak and contain the damage," he told reporters.
"I know BP has committed to pay for the response effort and we will hold them to their obligation," he said.
"I have to say, though, I did not appreciate what I considered to be a ridiculous spectacle during the congressional hearings into this matter: executives of BP and Transocean and Halliburton falling over each other to point the finger of blame at somebody else.
"The American people cannot have been impressed with that display and I certainly wasn't.
"I understand that there are legal and financial issues involved and a full investigation will tell us exactly what happened but it is pretty clear that the system failed and it failed badly.
"For that, there's enough responsibility to go round and all parties should be willing to accept it. That includes, by the way, the federal government."
Don't the white house visitor logs state otherwise?
In the same way you asked Scotjen61. Not saying one way or the other, but I'd like to see the proof.
This post is brought to you by a "Planted government disinformation agent."
Is this like Obama promising to get tough with big banks?
I don't trust Obie anymore. Of course he is going to come out and say the populist thing.
When the the time comes to hold individuals responsible, and to champion the regulation that's so badly needed, he won't be there.
He'll be out somewhere delivering carefully prepared populist slogans to the gullible.
We know you can talk, but where's the beef, Obie?
Below, is an article from today's Daily Mail (UK), including a comment by a Greenpeace scientist on the ineffectiveness of clean-ups in the context of oil gushers and tanker accidents.
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1278279/Gulf-Mexico-oil-spill-BP-boss-Tony-Hayward-tries-downplay-disaster.html
I suspected there could be an unusually ugly outcome to this, early on in the piece; and the auguries don't seem strikingly propitious at the moment, do they.
How scandalous that Exxon has managed to drag out its appeals and have its fines reduced. Governments are doubtless complicit in the kid-glove treatment of the large coporations by the appeal courts, when large fines are payable.
this is fouling the air here in New Orleans at times. to think this could get worse as some say gives me the foreboding of what will happen to the Gulf. i never ever knew the Gulf was blue until i took a cruise past the Mississippi River delta. and i've lived here all my life.
that no one will be held responsible or even attempt to ameliorate this toxic waste dump if the worst case scenario arises, is the probable result of politics/money today. that our Gulf will be written off due to various factors, is the end result.
Drill baby drill. Gosh, to think i am living in the end times of the environment as a result of the capitalist system. i definitely will consider moving far away from the most beautiful meeting of land and water, delta in America. such wonderful soil animals and aquatic creatures that i grew up with.
and no one will be held accountable or even begin to start to the cleanup, if that is possible. that is my one thought. NO ONE will be held accountable due to the immense money of the Corporations. Soylent Green it is.
BBC, May 15
BP's chief executive has said the Gulf of Mexico oil disaster should not mean the end of deep-water exploration.
But Tony Hayward told the BBC's Today programme that significant changes to the oil industry should arise from what he called a "transforming event".
Thousands of barrels of oil a day have been gushing from a seabed well since a drilling rig exploded on 20 April.
i think obama is way behind the power curve on this one. this is a truely major world disaster. BP is lying thru their teeth, clearly. but you cannot hide the reality of it for ever. the oil IS going to destroy the gulf coast, and probably more. when people see that and look back, they are going to absolutely livid...obama isnt very good at getting out in front of things, and this time its going to do him extraordinary damage...
someone tell hayward to pull that needle out his arm...
too many people are paying with their livelihoods for such epic, untrammeled greed, for humans to get away with such blatantly insane self-indulgence, with apparently zero awareness of the consequences.
yup to yogi, obama needs to ride the populist backlash all the way, not dither and speechify.
the cancer of fossil fuels needs to be starved out of the global bloodstream, stat.
The Learning Center Financial Questions Answered
Advertise Liberally