
An email from Stirling Newberry on what Bhutto's death means for US policy in South-West Asia and the 'War on Terror:'
Bhutto's death merely confirms what should be obvious by now: creation of Pakistan as a military state will, in the not very long run, produce a country which is a greater threat to global security than Baathist Iraq was. The Iraq war was about the last resource: oil. But the next wave is over control of technology. Bhutto herself was a corrupt reactionary, however she was also part of the slow democratic process and creation of national political coalitions. The crass, and this was as crass as it gets, use of security forces to eliminate political opposition has been rising as a mechanism around the globe. It was Plato who pointed out that the "feverish city" of pursuing only money would lead to war and conflict, and now, over two thousand years later, that lesson is about to be retaught. Strangely Bhutto's death has a silver lining: she is a better martyr for Democracy than she was in life an advocate of Democracy. However, she's going to have a great deal of company before things get better, and her death, in the short term, increases the probability that Pakistan will see more politcal violence on the way to establishing a state which will be an increasing focus of expansionist extremism.
Iraq and Afghanistan have been strategic victories for extremism, in that the United States and its allies have not only been unable to defeat it militarily, but have created a far more active, organized and successful extremism, and have created a full strategic commitment situation. One of the parts of the decline of American Empire has been the increasingly colonial component. Previously American military force was used to hold the frontiers against the USSR and PRC, while internal elites were used to control most of the important countries. We didn't need to station military forces in countries that were part of the empire. Now we must.
Sounds about right to me.
For further discussion of Benazir Bhutto's assasination, see also the Agonist's Bhutto breaking news compilation thread.