Massive, Unmitigated Failure


If indeed North Korea has tested a nuclear weapon, and the evidence weighs heavily at this late hour (CNN has said that senior US officials are all but certain it has happened) towards this being so, make no mistake, no matter what you hear from the talking heads in the next few days, this is a massive, unmitigated Bush Administration foreign policy failure. I'll have more thoughts on this later, but basically, our unwillingness to engage the North Koreans bilaterally in the face of all regional powers wishing us to engage them, including China, Russia, South Korea and Japan, has made Northeast Asia more unstable and dangerous. For more on why North East Asia is a more dangerous and unstable place see my primer on North Korea. Will there be sanctions on North Korea now? I personally doubt it. Why? Why would the Chinese want to destabilize such a nation along its border? What will Japan do as well?

Nota bene: Billmon has this one right:

No doubt Tony Snow will step out tomorrow to tell us it's really not such a big deal -- the North Koreans and Kim Jong-il being ever so much nicer and more rational than those genocidal Iranians and their power-crazed dictator, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad.

North Korea would not have gone nuclear had the Bush Administration not arrogantly brushed aside the previous agreement with North Korea and embraced a hardline against them upon assuming office in 2001. All of this was preventable. Since 2001 They have done nothing but ignore the North Koreans, ignored their nuclear program and ignored our interests in the region. That's all that needs to be said about this event. It could have been prevented and was not.


Sean Paul Kelley October 9, 2006 - 12:01am

They were happy with the heating oil that Clinton was sending them. Then Bush comes in and says "no". So, here we are.

Bucksouth October 9, 2006 - 12:34am

Atlantic monthly has a good aritle a while back about the buffont hitler, and noticed that China and the US were freaking out about the nuke, but South Korea, not so much.

The 2 of them might very well bury the hatchet, reunify, and then an economic asian powerhouse ALSO has a nuke.

In the long term, this might not be so bad for Korea, or for stability in the region. In the short term, it kind of sucks.

--
http://bexhuff.com
Of COURSE you can trust the US Government! Just ask the Indians.

bex October 9, 2006 - 12:40pm

It is an unmitigated failure and the world sees that. Only American MSM won't make the connection. Survey of world opinion show most feel the north korean matter is the result of a failure of bush's policies

http://www.miserywatch.com/2006/10/north_korea_fal.html

BGus October 10, 2006 - 4:12am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.