Radicalizing The Muslim World


Today Juan Cole writes:

As usual, Israel is radicalizing the Muslim world. The US, too, will suffer.

Isn't this what Karen Hughes, as head of public diplomacy, was supposed to prevent? Just goes to show you how much faith this administration has in PR and how little it knows about the real, long-term, tedious, grinding work of making friends (or at least not outright enemies) out of foes.

I said Monday night on the radio, last night on the radio and here that at some point the moderates would have to turn against us as Hezbollah showed it could do what no moderate Arab regime could do: stand up to Israel and survive.

Fine mess we've gotten ourselves into, yes?


Sean Paul Kelley July 27, 2006 - 11:52am

is that this administration is actually highly skilled at PR in some limited ways. They're simply so staggeringly lacking in empathy - like a person suffering a neurological disorder - that they think everyone on the planet is like Americans - or wants to be American - and are thus vulnerable to the same information techniques, the same emotive appeals and buzzphrases, that they used campaigning in Texas. It's like watching a computer virus trying to infect a Labrador Retriever; they use "democracy" like that's actually supposed to mean something to a starving Somali. They should try "sandwich".

Escher Sketch July 27, 2006 - 12:08pm

this blunder by the ever confused Ms Hughes
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/9777092/

Asylum July 27, 2006 - 8:34pm

The actions of Israel invading Lebanon again reveal to the world the stunning ability that the Israeli government to co-opt the decision-making apparatus of the Amercian government. The US is now seen to be supporting a govenment that engages in extra-legal targetted assassinations, a country with a secret nuclear program and country that invades a soverign country. Is there any point at which the interests of Americans diverge from those of Israelis? If so, what is that point?
Old Prairie Dog

lesbrost July 27, 2006 - 12:55pm

it's less a co-opting of the decision-making process in the US but a convergence of goals with a small cabal at the top of the US.

A Napoleonic cavalry officer might not recognize an F16 as a weapon from its form but would click in two seconds when he saw a demonstration of its function; similarly coup d'etat in 2006 no longer always looks like Colonels with handguns bursting into Presidential chambers and soldiers in WWII helmets seizing radio stations against a backdrop of waving palms.

So this cabal - for whatever reason - is committed to policies which they are well aware are anathema to America's democratic institutions, which would act to prevent their pursuit. So they have to constantly find new tools to circumvent them; war powers, unitary executive, dissolving oversight, signing statements, gross manipulation of public perception...

There looks to be a quid pro quo, 'you give me the objective conditions where I can sell or pursue or justify "X" and I'll give you the objective conditions where you can do "Y"'.

Of course it's not so simple as that. But IMHO that's part of the dynamic.

Escher Sketch July 27, 2006 - 1:16pm

...to America's democratic institutions, the political support for many of these actions sure seems to be widespread. Any objective strategic assesment of the immediate example given, Hizbullah and Israel, says that being in diplomatic lockstep with Israel does not serve America's vital interests, but political support for that lockstep is damned near universal amongst the political class and quite high amongst the electorate. The House vote was 410:8 - that's a pretty big cabal. Similarly, polling on a range of issues shows much, much more support (commonly up to about 10 times more) expressed for Israel than various Arab groups (n.b., it also shows high rates of not knowing or having no opinion as to which party to support).

These actions are an anathema to America's democratic ideals, but those who populate much of the decision making echelon in those institutions and much of the electorate ceased to rigourously test their actions, beliefs and policies against those ideals some time ago.

"We declared war on terror, it's not even a noun, so, good luck. After we defeat it, I'm sure we'll take on that bastard ennui." - Jon Stewart.

JustPlainDave July 27, 2006 - 2:46pm

While our democracy, in the hands of the neocons, moves towards using force to export and expand democracy, those we deem as extremists are using persuasion to democratically assume power. That, in my opinion, is perhaps the epitome of irony. Worse yet, it is an indication that our foreign policy is an unmitigated failure that may well alter the world order for decades.

Read an analysis that discusses the implications of the current U.S. foreign policy and how the neoconservatives have simply leaped over the politics of conflict...here:

www.thoughttheater.com

Daniel DiRito July 27, 2006 - 1:50pm

While our democracy, in the hands of the neocons, moves towards using force to export and expand democracy

Emphatically no on this. Not a chance. The "rebranding" camapaign where the term "regime change" - undoubtedly tanking in focus groups - was morphed into "exporting democracy" happened about three or four years back. The term was hardly on the radar screen previous to that. I'll bet they had to get out their dictionaries to be confident they could actually spell democracy consistently.

They don't "do" - or even have much respect for - democracy. It's just a Pavlov's Bell term for the American public.

Musharraf, a main ally in the WOT - military dictator. No criticism. But they criticize the Venezuelan and Iranian elections as flawed and illegitimate, and they refuse to recognize Hamas when elected.

All while refusing to be bound by decisions taken in the world's largest democratic fora, the UN, the ICC - even Geneva - because they're flawed. But Pakistan, a military dictatorship, somehow... isn't.

Reject what is QED mere cynical semantic manipulation.

Escher Sketch July 27, 2006 - 2:12pm

Evangelicals unite for Israel

7/26/2006 9:00:00 PM GMT

More than 3,000 Christians flocked to Washington and are staying at their own expense to ask Bush’s admin "not to restrain Israel in any way in the pursuit of Hamas and Hezbollah", as part of the first annual summit of Christians United for Israel, the founder of the group said.

More...

combined with this

Israel uses cluster bombs, chemical weapons in Lebanon

..."Israel fired several artillery-fired cluster munitions at Blida at around 3 p.m. on July 19. The witnesses described how the artillery shells dropped hundreds of cluster submunitions on the village. They clearly described the submunitions as smaller projectiles that emerged from larger shells."

Lebanese authorities are investigating reports that Israel has also used phosphorous munitions in its attacks.

The Lebanese Minister of Health has warned earlier that Lebanese children who got hurt in Israeli attacks are suffering from the impact of white phosphorus.

Same allegations were made by the Lebanese President Emile Lahoud.

Investigations are underway to determine what caused the death of eight Lebanese found in the Southern town of Rmeileh.

Mario Aoun, head of Lebanon's doctors' syndicate, told The Daily Star, investigators started the probe after "suspicious" bodies were found following one of the Israeli attacks.

Samples from the eight bodies found "are currently being analyzed at the American University of Science and Technology," Aoun said, suggesting that suspicions chemical weapons may have been used, but "nothing is certain."

"The causes of their deaths are not clear. The bodies are completely black, yet they are not burned. There are no wounds, no internal hemorrhaging and their muscles and hair are intact," he added.

I mean, who could possibly think it wouldn't?

stunster July 27, 2006 - 3:50pm

my hometown. He has a huge mega-church on the north side of town. And the people who attend are freaks. Waaaaaaaay out in right field religious zealotry land. Here is the website of his 'ministries.'

He wields a great deal of power in San Antonio and in the US at large.

Bite Your Head Off

Sean Paul Kelley July 27, 2006 - 4:35pm

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.