Justified Pessimism


By Ian Welsh, February 23

is not, in fact, pessimism. It is realism.

I find the “be happy” crowd odd. We have, in the past few years, seen millions of Americans and Europeans impoverished and lose their homes. We are seeing a wave of austerity in the 1st world which has and will impoverish many millions more. In the last quarter of 2011, Greece was on track for -7% annualized GDP growth. Civil liberties are under assault throughout the world, and the surveillance state is tightening its grasp. In the forseeable future, and one which is, now, almost unstoppable, we can expect to lose hundreds of millions of lives to climate change, and that, frankly, is the optimistic scenario, one which is almost certain not to occur. A billion is a good middling number, and it could easily go much higher. Many climate scientists believe we are beyond the point of no return.

None of what has happened, or which will happen, couldn’t have been stopped. For decades, with increasing stridency, prophets have warned of what would happen. Those prophets, in the grand Cassandric tradition, were ignored.

The left, virtually the world around, with the exception of Latin America, is in disarray and retreat, suffering defeat after defeat, from economic populist issues to civil liberties issues (other than gay rights). The forces of reaction, once aiming only at the edifices of mid 20th century liberalism, are now aiming to roll back the twentieth century en-masse, getting rid of socialized medicine (under assault even in England), child labor laws, reinstituting debtors prisons and celebrating inequality which exceeds even that of the gilded age. Gays may gain the right to marry, women may keep the franchise (and be allowed to vote between parties who will do the same thing at varying paces), but we will all be impoverished, largely powerless and watched 24 hours a day together.more at link


Raja February 25, 2012 - 8:31pm
( categories: Economics | Liberties )


Find out just what any people will quietly submit to and you have found out the exact measure of injustice and wrong which will be imposed upon them,and these will continue till they are resisted with either words or blows,or with both~FDouglas

Celsius 233 February 26, 2012 - 2:57am

2nd that Nice. What is more heartening are the comments Ian makes after his post. The commentators response often shows the various ways that have been found to withdraw consent of/with the system, that alternatives can be developed, expectations modified and needs reassessed to allow greater options. A lot of creative thinking is on demonstration in the stories being told.

Arnie February 26, 2012 - 11:22am

his is one of the few blogs I read these days.

Tina February 26, 2012 - 3:48pm

I second Celsius 233.
I have been digesting Ian's latest post and the comments for the last couple of days.
In my rural conservative community(Rep. Walburg's 7th congressional district) I hear this same pessimism. My community of poor working class, rural folks have been registering this pessimism for some time. For most of them their response has tended towards the fascist, brown shirt side. This response has been stoked, nurtured, and groomed by the "news" sources they consume.
These folks have been skidding for a couple of decades down a slope of more debt, lowering income, increased work load, lowered expectations, growing stress, decline in public services ( for rural people this means crappy roads and underfunded public schools), bad teeth, bad health, bad TV, bad food, bad Walmart crap, bad politicians with bad promises. It has made them bitter and vindictive.
Many of them hunt, fish, garden, farm, raise livestock, or have family and friends that do, so the fall is being somewhat cushioned. But they are definitely swinging into Brown shirt mentality; thus the appeal of the mean wingnut politicians.
The Democrats have been complicit with their inability to take any stance in opposition to the corporate overlords, and their cooperation with them.
The only radical ideas in the political sphere come from the extreme right. People who have no faith in the status quo either gravitate to those ideas or become apathetic and withdraw.
When the middle class feels as much pain as the working class have then they will react. If they gravitate to a more radical left ideology the Overlords have been grooming their brown shirts for decades to respond. They are armed and angry.
The left has done nothing to respond to this. The Democrats have done nothing to respond to this.
It will not be pretty.

farmgirl February 26, 2012 - 11:18am

Neither perceives the world as it actually is.


"The best-informed man is not necessarily the wisest. Indeed there is a danger that precisely in the multiplicity of his knowledge he will lose sight of what is essential."

- Dietrich Bonhoeffer

Escher Sketch February 27, 2012 - 12:30pm

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.