Upset Win for the Pirate Party in Berlin State Parliament Elections


The Pirate Party surprised pollsters as well as the general public by procuring 15 seats in the Berlin parliament, following yesterday’s election. To win any seats, a political party has to obtain at least 5% of the vote in the election; the Pirate Party surpassed this total easily, reaching nearly 9% of the vote. To put this in perspective, Angela Merkel’s coalition partners, the Free Democrats, received only 2% of the vote and will not be allowed representation in the Berlin parliament. Despite its name, the Pirate Party is not simply a protest group. It is a serious political movement focused on individual rights to communication, particularly when it comes to the internet. The party does not identify itself as right or left, liberal or conservative. It is, however, anti-corporatist, and is especially opposed to corporations that seek monopolies in public communication.

Berlin has a special status under the German constitution as both a city and a state, and this is the first time the Pirate Party in Germany has obtained federal representation. Merkel’s own party, the Christian Democrats, took another electoral hit on Sunday, as its performance fell to 23% of the vote, behind its opposition and top vote-getter, the Social Democrats, at 29% of the vote. Prior to this election, the biggest success of the Pirate Party in Europe was in 2009, when it won two seats in the European Parliament.

Originally founded in Sweden in 2006, the Pirate Party now has political organizations in all European countries, as well as Canada, the United States, throughout Latin America, and in New Zealand and Australia. Last year Pirate Parties International (PPI) was formed to provide policy coordination and political and electoral assistance to all its members.

The movement began initially to promote file sharing and open data sourcing on the internet, but has expanded its scope to foster transparency in government and oppose any efforts to control or limit citizens’ rights to information. The founding party in Sweden, for example, has donated servers to Wikileaks. The policy statement of the PPI calls for the abolition of all national patent laws, which has put the Pirate Party firmly in the sights of multinational corporations that have obtained or seek to achieve monopolies in software, or which try to act as toll keepers to the flow of information on the internet.

It is estimated from the polling data that at least 15% of Berlin voters under the age of 30 voted yesterday for the Pirate Party. Even so, to achieve 9% of the overall vote, many more older voters had to provide their support as well. The media in Europe and elsewhere have generally ignored the Pirate Party, or treated it as a curiosity – a protest movement with a cute name. The growing success of the party in Europe suggests something different is going on. First, it is the only political movement with coordination across Europe; the Christian Democrats in Germany, for example, never coordinated their activities with the now defunct Christian Democrats in Italy. Second, the party has broken free of the left/right divide and allows voters to transcend their tribal loyalties or even reorder their loyalties to a completely different way of looking at politics.

To move beyond where it is at the moment, though, the Pirate Party will ultimately have to present policy positions on topics such as national defense, educational standards, housing, municipal services, economic growth, jobs, and other matters of vital interest to the voters. This may seem daunting at first for a party that appears narrowly focused on the internet and open communications, but the developments in Germany suggest the voters themselves may see the Pirate Party as able to provide some answers to their problems.

This is primarily because the Pirate Party sets itself clearly in opposition to large corporate interests, especially multinationals and major financial concerns, which are intimately involved in national defense, education, housing, etc. Donations from these companies to politicians often determine how these politicians vote, and one thing the Pirate Party in Germany has promised is to open the doors and windows on the back-scene deliberations that often take place before politicians vote. The electorate in Berlin, at least, appeared to respond to the Pirate Party’s vow to reveal what is going on behind closed doors.

There is also a libertarian appeal to voters who may now feel that the nexus of corporations and government has significantly limited individual rights and introduced authoritarian or even police state regimes in countries that used to pride themselves on their democratic freedoms. These issues in particular may resonate well in Germany. More than just about any European country, Germany has avoided a bloated state sector, it has maintained its export prowess, and its unemployment is not chronically high as is the case among its neighbors. But it also has a history of authoritarian governments, and half of the older voters have living memory of life under communism. German voters are more sensitive than most to the gradual erosion of their civil liberties – they know where this can lead.

Not every country is going to be as accommodating to an upstart political organization like the Pirate Party. The United States is locked into a two party system at the federal level by virtue of the Electoral College voting system. The Pirate Party has done best in electoral situations where multiple parties have a chance and few ever achieve over 50% of the vote at the first go-around. What it clearly represents is an effort by a growing number of voters to break free from the rigid left/right political split that in many circumstances offers no real choice to the voters. It represents as well an expression of concern if not fear of the role corporations play in the political system.

The Pirate Party stands on its head the notion that challenging the rule of corporations and the rights they have assumed to themselves at the expense of individuals is somehow an act of “piracy.” Those who vote for the party appear willing to be branded as pirates, as outlaws or brigands, if that is what it means to assert that individual freedoms and rights should never be subordinate to those of impersonal and often amoral corporate interests.


Numerian September 19, 2011 - 10:04am

and one well worth keeping an eye on. thanks for the news!

Nat Wilson Turner September 19, 2011 - 12:22pm

is more evidence that Berlin is the hippest city on the planet. There's a reason it was one of Frank Zappa's favorite places to play shows.

I'd love to see something like the Pirate Party take hold in the States...if only...

Anyway, I used to live in Berlin and I'm a big fan of the place, so here's more stuff on Berlin's progressive identity as a world city:

Berlin names street after Frank Zappa
Roadway is home to factory that houses practice studios for 160 bands
http://today.msnbc.msn.com/id/20038879/ns/today-entertainment/t/berlin-names-street-after-frank-zappa/

Holiday In Berlin Full Blown - Frank Zappa (orchestrated version from Burnt Weeny Sandwich 1970)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Vb08JeW7vfk&feature=related

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Berlin

More than 60% of Berlin residents have no registered religious affiliation and Berlin has been described as the atheist capital of Europe.

However, the city is still highly tolerant of all faiths:

The faithful of the different religions and denominations maintain many places of worship in Berlin. The Independent Evangelical Lutheran Church has eight parishes of different sizes in Berlin.[94] There are 36 Baptist congregations (within Union of Evangelical Free Church Congregations in Germany, 29 New Apostolic Churches, 15 United Methodist churches, eight Free Evangelical Congregations, six congregations of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, an Old Catholic church and an Anglican church in Berlin. Berlin has 76 mosques, eleven synagogues, and two Buddhist temples.

Creative industries

Industries that do business in the creative arts and entertainment are an important and sizable sector of the economy of Berlin. The creative arts sector comprises music, film, advertising, architecture, art, design, fashion, performing arts, publishing, R&D, software, TV, radio, and video games. Around 22,600 creative enterprises, predominantly SMEs, generated over 18,6 billion Euro in total revenue. Berlin's creative industries have contributed an estimated 20% of Berlin's gross domestic product in 2005.[55] The German headquarter of Universal Music is based in Berlin.

Science

The Berlin-Brandenburg capital region is one of the most prolific centers of higher education and research in the European Union...The city has a high density of research institutions, such as the Fraunhofer Society, Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz Scientific Community and the Max Planck Society, which are independent of, or only loosely connected to its universities. A total number of 62,000 scientists are working in research and development.[51] The city is one of the centers of knowledge and innovation communities

yogi-one September 19, 2011 - 12:30pm

I was there when the Wall fell. I remember walking about East Berlin at night in utter darkness. The state had enough money to light only one lamp on each street. The walls of many buildings were still pockmarked from damage during the war. Potsdam was in a decrepit state. Ten years later when I next visited I couldn't believe the difference. Museum Island had been almost completely restored. The treasures held there, such as the Pergamon Altar, make a visit to Berlin essential for anyone interested in art.

You could see back then Berlin was determined to restore its position as a cultural capital of Europe, and it certainly has succeeded.

Numerian September 19, 2011 - 1:12pm

But somehow I fell in love with the city watching Wings of Desire...

creativelcro September 19, 2011 - 3:26pm

Thanks for this, Numerian!

Always interesting to see how all this is seen from a bit of a distance.

Just some short notes on this development here in Germany which does leave the media here rather surprised too.

1) In fact the CDU gained about 2,1 percentage-points and did a bit better than in the 2006 election for the Abgordnetenhaus. They are boasting about this loud enough at the moment which doesn't take anyone by surprise because they did't have anything to cheer about anywhere in the last few months. - It's noted that the present Major, SPD-Member Wowereit, didn't manage to defend his personal direct district (lost to CDU-Candidate) and will enter the assembly "only" as the first set on the list of his party. The SPD now will choose between the Green Party as a Partner or (not likely) a great coalition with the CDU. The Party "The Left" (in which there remain some former SED and then PDS politicians - more popular in the eastern states of Germany) lost more support than the Green Party gained and will not be asked again to be the smaller partner in a coalition with the SPD as it was during the last years.

2) The Liberal Democrats lost out again and did even worse than some weeks ago in the large but sparsely populated rural state of Mecklenburg-Vorpommern where they weren't reelected to the state Parliament either. (There, another period with a gerat coalition between SPD and CDU seems most likely but a SPD-Green Coalition is nor rueld out yet.) This really gets them and the federal gouvernment into trouble, as they seem to loose all public support.

3) Now to the Point, The Pirates:

Fristly, people tend not to believe the politicians of the established parties any longer and, for the younger genereation, the shine of the Green Party has worn off, even if they in effect achived their goal of getting rid of atomic plants in Germany in the long term.

Secondly, in the field of rights of communication and civil rights, the Pirates hit a nerve:

The media here are, since about a year or two, finally awash with stories concerning data retention rights, personal liberties and copyright law.

Hundrets of thousands of Germans who illegaly downloaded mp3 or software from p2p networks have been served billable notices by one of the about 2 dozen law-firms specialising in this field, typically asking for a sum between 500,- to 1000,- EUR in costs and damages and this business still strives.

There has been a mayor decision of the federal constitutional court prohibiting the law enforcement agencies and internet providers to keep internet traffic data for 6 months, as was planned and already law. A new solution has not been found yet. Interestingly the only one really standing in the way of the CDU and their War-on-Terror-Strategy within the government is the Federal Minister for Justice, Leutheuser-Schnarrenberger. She is a long standing and leading FDP-Member and always has been a civil rights activist of sorts.

Federal and State Privacy officers take it on them to battle google and facebook on the grounds of the (complicated and in parts outdated) privacy laws.

So, (young) people are just fed up.

It will be really intertesting to see if the Pirates can find themselves room for manouver and stay afloat for longer, especially on the local govermental level in the bigger cities and maybe, the other big city-state of Hamburg.

They did not too bad in the local elections in Lower Saxony last week an landed themselves in the council of Hannover too, I think.

This is really fun to watch, but the outcome is rather unforseeable.

A short update:

Here is a small interview (in german) with one of the leading figures of the Pirates: http://www.heise.de/tp/artikel/35/35525/1.html

woset September 20, 2011 - 4:23am

100% champs, i want pirate party to sweep the US!
--
Hongpong.com

HongPong September 20, 2011 - 5:37am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.