Republican leaders are already talking, albeit sotto voce and usually with anonymity, about Barack Obama’s landslide victory, and who is to blame. Being Republican means never having to say you’re sorry – it’s the Love Story approach to politics – but that doesn’t mean you can’t throw mud at some other guy in the party when everything has gone badly wrong.
Quite a gaggle of GOP geese are doing just that in a U.K. Telegraph article here. On one side are the apostates who have already criticized the party or even endorsed Barack Obama. This includes “intellectuals” like David Brooks, Andrew Sullivan, Doug Kmiec, and Peggy Noonan, as well as party stalwarts like Scott McClellan, David Frum, Matthew Dowd, and Kenneth Adelman.
More after the jump.
On the other side are the true believers like Rush Limbaugh, and columnists Charles Krauthammer and Tony Blankley. They see themselves as the guardians of conservatism, and are already hinting that those on the other side are “traitors”, which is about as bad as calling them Democrats.
The fault line for this civil war is Sarah Palin.
From everything we have read about her lately, she is not merely chafing under the campaign restraints imposed upon her by John McCain’s chief strategist Steve Schmidt – she is running “off the reservation,” contradicting what John McCain has said or what his positions are, and setting out on her own and refusing to take any blame for what could be an electoral debacle.
Her detractors have called her a “diva” – self-centered and incapable of listening to any advice since her instincts will always guide her straight and true. One wag said it was inappropriate to describe her as a hockey mom; Sarah Palin was in truth the prom queen riding in the back of the convertible waving to all the hockey moms watching the parade.
But here is another truth, assuming John McCain loses on November 4: Sarah Palin already is the head of the Republican Party. She is its future because her allies will see to it that her critics will be drummed out of the party. She is its future because only she can attract crowds of supporters with any amount of enthusiasm. Most importantly, she is its future because her supporters – the evangelicals who overwhelmingly dominate Republican primary voting in all the red states – will easily hand her the nomination in 2012.
No one can stop her ascent now as head of the party because to do so they would have to take on and defeat the evangelical wing of the party. The big business/Wall Street wing of the party, along with the Main Street business interests, are too weakened to mount such a campaign, and in any event, they only provide money, not votes. Suburban soccer moms have slowly been fleeing to the Democratic Party. That leaves no one to stand up to the Christianists who dominate the Republican party.
The Christianists adore Sarah Palin because she is one of them. She talks the talk – which is to say she talks in tongues. She has an anointing by some self-appointed Dominionist bishops who have declared her to be The One (sorry Barack, there can only be one true “The One”). The Dominionists are a growing movement of Christianists who seek political power not to enact any political agenda, but to purify America and extend their brand of Christianity across the nation. Much more so than George W. Bush, Sarah Palin is “of the faith” and understands the code words of the Christianist movement. She understands that the Bible trumps the poor, old Constitution, lying as it is in tatters from the destruction wrought by George W. Bush.
The Christianists will forgive her the Neiman Marcus clothes, the traveling make-up artist, the all-too-human family, and the rumors of past marital problems. Some of these trappings of wealth are simply necessary for her to appeal to the broader secular society requiring purification. The rumors and negative press stories are the works of the Devil, because the Christianists know that Satan is constantly present in our lives with temptations, falsehoods, and snares.
Poll results from the 2004 election showed about a third of the voters described themselves as evangelical or fundamentalist Christians. They attend Baptist or Assembly of God churches. They evangelize constantly, and ensure the growth of the movement by concentrating on the indoctrination of children (hence their hatred for homosexuality, because the whole “sanctity of marriage” concept is really about having children to bring into the religion). On moral issues, such as abortion or homosexuality, they team up with conservative fellow-travelers such as Catholics and Mormons, though on doctrinal matters many Christianists reject both of these religions.
This is the Republican Party here and now, and of the future. It is too late for Peggy Noonan or David Frum to turn the party back to the Reagan era of faux-morality and hard-headed geopolitics. The Republican party entered into a pact with God (or the Devil, depending on your view), and it has now become the Party of God. God’s elect dominate the Republican Party now; they provide the manpower and the votes that determine who runs as a Republican.
Do they have the votes to elect Sarah Palin as president in 2012? Don’t count her out. If she has any overweening sin, it is a lust for power. On November 5th, she will begin positioning herself as party leader, polishing her “policy” skills so as never to be embarrassed again in an interview. A lingering and painful economic depression will chip away at Barack Obama’s aura, and Sarah Palin will be ready to position herself as the newest savior of the country.
The only one who can undo a prom queen or diva is the person herself. It is possible that Sarah Palin in the next four years will find some way to self-destruct. She certainly now has enemies gunning for her, including quite a few back home in Alaska aware of her past indiscretions, betrayals, and even illegalities. It is also possible that Barack Obama will find it in himself to become a new FDR, able to work his way to radical new policies necessary to right the nation’s wrongs, and thereby build a lasting political majority. Sarah Palin’s detractors see Barack Obama as just such a person, and they fear 20 years or more in the political wilderness if the Republicans turn to her for salvation.
But there really is no “if” about it; through an ill-conceived vice presidential search by John McCain, Sarah Palin is in charge. She will run for president, and she may become president. God has already ordained the first event, and perhaps the second.