SearchUser loginNavigationCreate new accountTeam AgonistEditor in Chief: Steve Hynd ThoughtfulGlobalTimelyMixed Bag of Candy: Corner: Brian Downing's Picks: Numerian's Numbers: Who's onlineThere are currently 3 users and 1327 guests online.
Online users:Syndicate |
Scott McClellan Comes to JesusWhy would anyone volunteer to be slimed by the White House attack machine? A number of former officials as well as whistleblowers from the Bush administration have written tell-all books, and every one of them has been denigrated as traitors and delusional misfits who kept their poisonous opinions about George W. Bush secret even as they worked for him. Richard A. Clarke, a counter-terrorism expert in the Bush administration, wrote Against All Enemies when he left the White House – a damning indictment of Bush’s failure to take terrorism seriously before 9/11. Clarke says that the trashing he received from the administration has left “tire tracks” on his back to this day. But that’s nothing compared to what former White House press secretary Scott McClellan is now receiving for his newly published memoir, What Happened: Inside the Bush White House and Washington’s Culture of Deception. The current press secretary, Dana Perino, describes McClellan as a “disgruntled” former employee, rather like a homicidal postal employee off his medicines. Karl Rove doesn’t remember McClellan ever expressing such reservations, and thinks his book is about as prejudiced and untrustworthy as a leftist blog. Others have called him “self-serving”, “disingenuous” and “unprofessional”. All his former friends complain they feel betrayed and misled. The headlines generated by advance copies of the book read like political pornography for anyone who had serious doubts about the Bush administration: · The Bush administration was “all about manipulating sources of public opinion.” · George Bush “managed the Iraq issue in a way that almost guaranteed that the use of force would become the only feasible option.” · The administration “used political propaganda to sell the Iraq war.” · Karl Rove and Scooter Libby deliberately lied to McClellan about their involvement in Plamegate. · George Bush “convinces himself to believe what suits his needs at the moment.” · The greatest mistake of the Bush administration was “to run away from candor.” Scott McClellan’s friends do have a point. How could he have possibly stood at the podium in the White House press room and uttered lie after lie for three years, if these are the things he truly believed? How could he have met with the president and various other officials and deceived them into thinking he was on board with their actions and their “propaganda”? He must have been a completely different person then. On the other hand, what benefit does McClellan obtain from writing such a book now? He is one of the old-guard Texas hands who rose up with Bush when he was governor, and followed him all the way to the White House. His family has been steeped in Texas GOP activities for decades; his mother ran for governor just last term. He is cutting himself off from the Bush dynasty forever, and probably from the Texas GOP. He can’t possibly have too many friends left in Washington among Republicans, and no one on the left is going to embrace him for uttering things many felt were true all along. Even if he calculates that George W. Bush and all things Bush are now irredeemably tainted in GOP politics, whatever replacement machine comes along is hardly going to embrace traitors. Former Bush political counselor Dan Bartlett has criticized McClellan for having an “out-of-body experience,” but he is probably on to something here even if it is inadvertent. McClellan explains in his forward that the book is an act of “personal contrition – a way of being true to my Christian faith.” McClellan is asserting that the Kool-Aid wears off; it is possible to act and think fully in accordance with the twisted White House way of governance, and afterwards have an epiphany hitherto available only to the fiercest Bush critics. What caused McClellan to embrace such apostasy is uncertain. He has told former colleagues that the book started out very differently and surprised him in its development. Maybe the act of writing was cathartic. Perhaps the story of the unnecessary death of some poor Iraqi stirred his conscience; after all, there are several hundred thousand such stories to choose from. Certainly the Jesus that McClellan has come to accept is very different from the militant, Republican Jesus that evangelical and fundamentalist preachers have mounted on crucifixes all across this nation. Maybe Scott McClellan is truly repentant for his participation in what is in so many ways a criminal enterprise. He could be another Charles W. Colson, the former Nixon operative who went to jail in the Watergate scandal. Colson, while not renouncing many of his right-wing views, has turned preacher, and formed a prison outreach ministry. He recently received the Templeton Prize for advancement of religion, and applied the $1 million award to his prison efforts. Colson had first-hand experience with the prison system in this country, and its effect on the incarcerated. McClellan has no such personal familiarity with the consequences of his years of deceit at the White House press room podium, but there are plenty of places to start. He could volunteer for USAID in Iraq, he could work on finding jobs and housing for the victims of Katrina, he could help clean the wards at veterans hospitals like Walter Reed, he could assist a paraplegic soldier or marine – there are hundreds of such individuals needing a lifetime of care. He could work with the unemployed, the underemployed, the homeless, the victims of mortgage fraud, the hungry, the children in our pathetic excuses for schools. There is just so much he could do. Using a book to show for the first time the candor that has been missing from the White House these past eight years is only a start. Numerian May 28, 2008 - 5:58pm
|
![]() Premium AdvertisingAgonist Page on FaceBookAgonist Facebook Activity |