SearchUser loginNavigationTeam Agonist
Universal Pantograph provides technical support for The Agonist. ThoughtfulAbu Aardvark GlobalTimelyMixed Bag of Candy: Who's onlineSyndicate |
This is the stuff Depressions are made of......or, cheerful reading for a Sunday morningIn the list of problems central bankers worry about, the very worst is a systemic crisis. Systemic risk occurs when the failure of one financial institution brings about the failure of another, and it arises from the complex network of bank-to-bank trades that exist in a variety of products. Most central bankers go through their careers without even witnessing a systemic crisis; Ben Bernanke has just started his career right in the middle of one. Make no mistake: this Bear Stearns failure is the very definition of a systemic crisis. Bear Stearns is a major financier for hedge funds; it runs one of Wall Street’s largest back offices for processing trades; it has transactions on its books with everybody big in the derivatives business. If Bear Stearns collapses, there isn’t a bank in the world that won’t be counting their losses. In normal circumstances a bank failure would result in everyone else going back into the market and replacing the trades from the failing bank. The replacement trades would be at new prices, so a lot of banks would have losses, but these would be manageable. Today so many markets are dysfunctional or non-functional that replacement trades aren’t even available. A Bear Stearns collapse creates a hole in a bank’s portfolio that can’t be filled. The loss has to be guessed at, but worse still, the market seizes up even more, so that less credit is available. It’s getting hard to count all the markets that are in cardiac arrest: residential mortgage backed securities, collateralized debt obligations, variable rate auction securities, asset backed commercial paper, structured debt, high yield debt, commercial mortgage backed securities, structured investment vehicles, and recently Aaa rated agency securities (Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac bonds). People and businesses are finding it harder and harder to obtain finance. Despite all the hundreds of billions of dollars of “liquidity” the central banks have thrown into the system, banks are not lending. Despite the dramatic decrease in short term interest rates engineered by the Fed, long term rates have gone higher and have shut off credit for millions. This is exactly what happened in the Depression. Banks went belly-up and credit was no longer available. As one bank failed, customers would line up at their own bank demanding their money back, and because it could not be made available, that bank failed too. A daisy-chain of bank failures took place that starved the economy for credit and caused a massive economic collapse. Economists from Milton Friedman to Ben Bernanke have studied the Depression and concluded that the Federal Reserve was a contributing factor because it tightened money by raising interest rates when it should have been flooding money into the system (dropping it from helicopters, to use Bernanke’s metaphor). Ben Bernanke is as primed as anyone could be to fight the next Depression, but he is failing just the same. A run on the banks is occurring anyway, it just happens to be in a parallel credit creation world that he doesn’t control. Bear Stearns is at the center of the Wall Street credit creation machine, which is the part of the modern financial world which is now imploding. This parallel universe of banking used the securitization process to create credit, selling loans packaged into bonds and other securities to millions of investors around the world. No central bank stands behind this process, though central bankers like Alan Greenspan cheered it on because it took pressure off commercial banks to make loans that would stress their balance sheets and their capital position. That stress is happening anyway, because as this parallel credit creation mechanism collapses, commercial banks that are in the Fed system are being forced to take on the loans that used to be held by Wall Street firms or by investors. The appetite for this is very limited and has already been reached. JP Morgan Chase, which is big into Wall Street finance but also is a member of the Federal Reserve, was asked this week to lend money to Bear Stearns to keep it afloat, but would not do so unless the Fed indemnified it for any losses from a Bear Stearns bankruptcy. Just as in the Depression, credit is drying up throughout the United States economy. The very best efforts of the Fed, the Treasury, and Congress aren’t even slowing down this collapse of credit. Just the other day the government allowed Fannie Mae to increase the dollar size of jumbo mortgages it would accept, but because investors are hesitant to buy any securities issued by Fannie Mae, banks are still not booking jumbo mortgages. As credit dries up, those individuals and businesses highly dependent on debt for their survival are going to fail. It has already begun in the hedge fund business, starting with those funds which are most highly leveraged. Even a blue-chip fund like Carlyle Capital, which held nothing but Aaa rated agency securities, collapsed because the banks holding these securities as collateral sold them to protect themselves from losses. As such sales accelerate, more and more hedge funds will go to the wall. Bear Stearns collapsed because it was as highly leveraged as any hedge fund – roughly $30 in assets for every $1 of capital. It only takes a 5% loss on the assets to wipe out all of the capital of the firm. Bear Stearns succumbed because its assets were especially prone to losses since they consisted of mortgage related securities. But losses are now occurring on much safer assets, and since all Wall Street firms have leverage to the degree Bear Stearns did, all of them are exposed to failure. There are hundreds of companies in the same position. In the past 15 years the credit worthiness of corporate America has deteriorated to the point that 70% of all corporate bonds are now junk debt, meaning these companies have excessive amounts of debt. Less than 10 companies in the U.S. carry a Aaa rating. As those companies with excessive debt are unable to roll over or replace their debt, and as the economy slows, they are going to have a hard time surviving. This problem is already going global, hitting the U.K., Australia, and other countries that experienced housing booms. Ultimately the credit implosion will fell China and India, two countries that have built their economic engines on highly shaky debt pyramids. Already the stock market in China has begun a collapse that looks remarkably similar to the fall of the NASDAQ in 2000. Deleveraging is a term economists are using for this process of shedding assets to avoid more serious market losses eroding one’s capital. As hedge funds, banks, corporations, and individuals increasingly rush to deleverage, the losses are exacerbated, and many just won’t make it. This is how systemic risk is bred and how it destroys credit creation. Without credit, a modern economy starves. Ben Bernanke certainly knows this and has put Bear Stearns on life support in order to stop the contagion from spreading. Bear Stearns – which isn’t even a commercial bank and is not under the Fed’s jurisdiction – is too big to fail in the view of the Fed. It has too many relationships with all the rest of the market to be allowed to go into receivership. But is this a losing battle? History certainly suggests that systemic crises have a way of rumbling on until all the excess debt is wrung from the system, resulting in enormous economic pain. One of the characteristics of a systemic crisis is the loss of confidence in the financial system, and we saw this on display in the Bear Stearns collapse. Early in the week executives at the bank were saying their liquidity situation was sound despite all the market rumors. Suddenly on Friday it was announced by these same executives that their liquidity situation had deteriorated markedly “within the past 24 hours.” Perhaps this is true – executives face severe personal penalties for lying publicly about their company’s situation. But the market was understandably skeptical, which means that the next bank which says publicly it is highly liquid will have to overcome widespread suspicion and doubt. Already rumors are cropping up about other Wall Street firms and large global commercial banks. This is the real battle Bernanke is facing – the confidence battle. All banks exist only to the extent the public is confident the banks can meet their obligations – this is the Achilles heel of leverage. Once confidence is lost, many banks can fail not because their balance sheets are riddled with bad loans, but because of a bank run. Bear Stearns failed because it hadn’t the resources to survive a bank run. The odds are reasonably high that it will be joined by other Wall Street banks, whatever Ben Bernanke does. He can keep these firms on life support to protect the market, but in doing so he is transferring the risk and the losses to the federal government, thereby nationalizing these banks. It is not difficult to imagine that when all the excess leverage and all the bad debts are eliminated from the system, the federal government will own most of the Wall Street banks, many large commercial banks, and also Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. As this becomes evident to the markets, the dollar will not survive on the international exchanges, and U.S. Treasury rates for long term debt such as bonds will rise sharply. The U.S. will almost certainly lose its Aaa rating for its debt. Which brings us back to the question of a Depression. As the banking system is nationalized, and credit dries up, growth in the economy will cease. Already the U.S. is in a recession, but the decline in GDP is about to accelerate significantly to Depression levels of 10% or higher. Unemployment will soar. The true unemployment rate in the economy, counting all the workers who want jobs but are currently being left out of the statistics because they haven’t sought work for awhile, is probably around 8% to 9%. This rate will easily double. The asset deflation that is now ravaging home values will spread not only to other physical assets, but to services and commodities. Nothing will be safe from the pressure to reduce prices and costs. As this process unfolds, the stock market will finally come to terms with the economic reality, and a stock market crash will ensue. This Depression could last somewhat over a year, or be much more prolonged if the Fed keeps too many firms on life support. The Japanese did that in the 1990s during their bout with deflation, and it took at least ten years before the economy started to grow again. Sadly, the only debate left for the United States, and the global economy for that matter, is how long and how deep this Depression will be. Numerian March 16, 2008 - 11:11am
|
![]() Premium Advertising
Advertise Liberally |