"You Can't Pick Your Side in a Race Riot"


The title of the post is a quote from an inmate who survived the infamous Santa Fe Prison Riot in 1980. The sentiment is obvious, when the worst, most atavistic tribal impulses of human beings take over, people can't make rational choices about which side to take, and often don't even have the choice of remaining neutral.

This unfortunate reality of the human condition greatly complicates the internal politics of a polyglot nation like the U.S.

It's been that way since the American Revolution. Certain ethnic/socio-political groups remained more loyal to the Crown and many were driven out of the country at the end of the war. I'm familiar with this because my father's family were tories who migrated from New York to New Brunswick after the Revolution.

My home state of Texas infamously oppressed the Tejanos who played leading roles in the Texas Revolution once independence from Mexico had been achieved.

German-Americans famously suffered the brunt of an angry populace during WWI, from Wikipedia:

The Red Cross barred individuals with German last names from joining in fear of sabotage. One man was hanged in Illinois, apparently for no other reason than that he was of German descent. The killers were found not guilty of the crime and the hanging was called an act of patriotism by a jury. A Minnesota minister was tarred and feathered when he was overheard praying in German with a dying woman. Some Germans during this time "Americanized" their names (e.g. Schmidt to Smith, Müller to Miller) and limited their use of the German language in public places. Newspapers also printed blacklists of names of Germans, including their addresses, headlined as German Enemy Aliens.

During WWII, Japanese-Americans had it even worse, being interned in concentration camps.

It shouldn't be surprising that our current wars to export freedom and Democracy state of war with two Muslim countries is putting yet another subset of Americans in a very awkward spot. And when one individual snaps, rather than being seen as an example of aberrant individual psychology or criminal evil, the jingo-artists among us seize on this to make the situation even worse.

From TPM:

One conservative writer is already declaring -- without citing any evidence -- that Major Nidal Malik Hasan, the alleged shooter who killed 13 at Fort Hood yesterday, was acting at the behest of the Muslim Brotherhood.

and from Raw Story:

In the wake of a shooting rampage at Fort Hood by a military psychiatrist of Middle Eastern lineage, the hosts at Fox News have begun suggesting that all Muslims in the military should be treated as potential threats.

"Do you think it's time for the military to have special debriefings of Muslim Army officers -- anybody enlisted?" Fox's Brian Kilmeade asked Geraldo Rivera on Friday morning. "Because if I'm going to be deployed in a foxhole, if I'm going to be sticking in an outpost, I got to know the guy next to me is not going to want to kill me."

I hope we can pull out of this downward spiral before it gets stupider and more deadly.

Some excerpts from an interview with a local newspaper editor near Fort Hood in the full entry. She takes a much more measured and responsible approach than the national media.

From Boing Boing's interview with Amanda Kim Stairrett, the military editor at the Killeen Daily Herald.

Besides the families, people really want to know more about the alleged shooter himself. What are you seeing in this coverage?
AKS: A lot of the news organizations are very much wanting to push his religion. Him being Muslim and the impact of that on the incident itself. We don't have anything with that confirmed yet, so I've been really hesitant to say that that played a big part in the incident. We did had a reporter who was at the shooter's off-Post apartment and talked to neighbors. They said he was outspoken about being Muslim and had a lot of pride in his faith. But right now, I've stayed away from saying whether that played a hand in the shooting. I don't know if it's a big problem that people are speculating. I think it's first instinct. But I don't know why new organizations are so prominently featuring surveillance footage of him in a convenience store in traditional clothing. They're building this background in case it turns out that his religion did come into this. But we just don't know right now. And we're not willing to go that route with our reporting at this time.

What's your take on the speculation that's running rampant on TV news with this incident, in general? How does that compare to the actual facts that you know?
AKS: It's been interesting. Very early after the incident yesterday, I was pretty amazed to stand by and listen to, mostly, TV reporters go on air and speculate and report on rumors they'd heard. Whereas, our newspaper is right next to Fort Hood. We have a close relationship and it's always been our policy where we find that it's best to wait for correct information rather than to speculate. Because there's a large family population that isn't necessarily on Post, and don't know what's going on. It's a dangerous situation to get those people worried and worked up for reasons that maybe aren't correct. It's been really frustrating to see all the speculation. I've even been avoiding watching the TV coverage too closely, because I don't want the speculation to accidentally influence what I write.


Nat Wilson Turner November 6, 2009 - 12:09pm
( categories: USA: Armed Forces )

And send them back where they came from.

Jeff Wegerson November 6, 2009 - 4:06pm

but who would prescribe my happy pills?

Nat Wilson Turner November 6, 2009 - 4:07pm

shootings is usually:

"Nothing to see here folks - just a crazy man."

The "no big deal" response to the uniquely American phenomenon of mass shootings got dropped like a hot potato once the shooter turned out to be brown - and muslim.

I'm not saying that politics had nothing to do with it. He should be punished just like anyone. But you have to ask: "What about McVeigh?" He was in the Army too. Should we ban crackers?

One more thing: I just learned this week that Canada actually interned recent immigrants from the Austria-Hungarian Empire after 1914 - and put them in hard labor camps - some until 1920 because of the Russian revolution.

KingElvis November 6, 2009 - 4:56pm

incidents of U.S. domestic terrorism committed by white right-wingers than by muslims. Even if you include the D.C. sniper, I come up with less than a handful of incidents (I'm not counting the numerous ridiculous groups of patsys that have been set-up and then busted by the FBI).
Guys like the Atlanta Olympic bomber Eric Rudolph and Larry Flynt/Vernon Jordan assassin Joseph Paul Franklin just don't get the media heat that the brown-skinned killers do. Guess the media overlords feel that Americans are used to being shot and killed by crazed white guys.

Nat Wilson Turner November 6, 2009 - 5:01pm

but at the same time, I think people putting up false red flags, like social alienation within the military and cracking from listening to soldiers unload their psychological problems, is utter bullshit. These explanations aren't within kicking distance of Occam's razor's.

If you think gays openly serving in the military won't hurt morale, the same military has already accepted Muslims/Arabs/Palestinians.

Lesly November 6, 2009 - 8:08pm

and remember the batshit motivations of mass murderers tend to be pretty hard for non-murderous people to identify with.

Nat Wilson Turner November 6, 2009 - 8:46pm


"We're all of us children in a vast kindergarten trying to spell God's name with the wrong alphabet blocks." ~ Edwin Arlington Robinson

Celsius 233 November 7, 2009 - 5:49am

The number of non-combatant dead in Texas on this particular day is not that much different from the number of non-combatant dead in Iraq or Afghanistan on any particular day. Of course the cheerleading U.S. media gives them a different status. They are front of the bus dead, all the others in Iraq and Afghanistan are back of the bus dead.

stevelaudig November 7, 2009 - 5:55am

How about gun control for Muslims?

Now, there's a tea-bag mind twister for you.

"Turning Japanese I think I'm Turning Japanese I really think so da-da-da det det det det" - The Vapors

Tonsure Wimple November 8, 2009 - 12:10am

Stairrett's comments should be the watermark on the Pulitzer Prize.

"Turning Japanese I think I'm Turning Japanese I really think so da-da-da det det det det" - The Vapors

Tonsure Wimple November 8, 2009 - 12:15am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.