The Guardian Challenge - War Propaganda or Real Reporting


Take a look at the image of the Guardian front page today. There are five stories listed. From the "Friends of Syria" meeting, the Saudi's suggest arming the Syrian "rebels" (they already have, according to Brian Downing). Then we get the sub headlines telling us that Assad is targeting children (surely incubators are soon to follow), two journalists are in trouble, and Syria is committing war crimes (what about U.S, UK, and French leader war crimes in Libya?). This is truly "Fair and Balanced" in the Murdoch/Fox sense of the phrase.

While the Guardian stenographers are busy carrying the water for Cameron and NATO, some of their first rate reporters should follow this story.

The Guardian Challenge

This video is from an anti Libyan rebel site. It purportedly shows "-Criminal “rebels” of Misurata locked up and humiliate the residents of Tawerga to the Zoo cage, which was at the end of August – beginning of September." Tawerga, you may recall, is the town of 30,000 black Libyans that was ethnically cleansed by the victorious rebel forces from Misurata.

Here's the challenge to the Guardian. Is this video showing prisoners forced to eat the former flag of Libya for real? Are these prisoners from Tawerga? Are they being abused by rebels from Misurata? We've seen many anonymous pro rebel videos from Syria and Libya. Take a look at this one, Guardian, and tell us all about it. And while you're at it, answer this: where are the people of Tawerga?


Michael Collins February 25, 2012 - 3:58am
( categories: Human Rights )

Don't hold your breath if you ask for answers from the neolibs who were so gung-ho for the intervention in Libya though. I've tried. Resounding silence born out of a severe reluctance to admit this one's aftermath wasn't any better thought out than Iraq's.

Steve Hynd February 25, 2012 - 7:43pm

...better than Iraq. Better "thought out", I don't think one could make such a hot case - but the scale of what we're seeing is a lot less than Iraq.

Bremmer was apparently otherwise engaged, thank god.

"In combat one should be very suspicious of painless moral choices. When you are confronted with a seemingly painless moral choice, the odds are that you haven't looked deeply enough." ~ Karl Marlantes

JustPlainDave February 25, 2012 - 8:10pm

But then again, there was a period of relative calm before the storm in Iraq too - and even then the warning signs were there. I don't think we're done seeing the mess a disfunctional and fractured government and a slew of competing militias can make in Libya, not by a long chalk.

Steve Hynd February 25, 2012 - 8:15pm

...through the equivalent period. About this far in in Iraq they were dropping the Canal Hotel on the UN and starting to make it impossible for the NGOs to work without surrounding themselves in security. In Libya I don't see the same significant amount of effort placed into stay behind forces, the western powers aren't present as reachable targets and the transnationals don't appear to be nearly as active. It certainly isn't good, but does have the quality of being Libyan and that's a key difference.

"In combat one should be very suspicious of painless moral choices. When you are confronted with a seemingly painless moral choice, the odds are that you haven't looked deeply enough." ~ Karl Marlantes

JustPlainDave February 26, 2012 - 8:25am

Bremmer retired to Vermont and occupies his time painting landscapes and occasionally commenting on the world situation.

As you know, I bring up the hundreds of thousands of dead Iraqi civilians, who would have been alive were it not for the Bush invasion. I've struggled to find a cause. Saying it was due to civil strife let loose by the invasion describes rather than explains. But your comment triggered an explanation - the civil strife accounting for most of those civilian deaths occurred in a power vacuum. What led to that vacuum? When Bremmer dismantled the Iraqi Army, the vacuum was created, the stage set for the carnage. It's Bremmer's fault. Let's send him to the Hague;)

I just started "Secret Affairs" by Mark Curtis http://markcurtis.info/

Explains quite a bit, imho.

The Money Party RSS

Michael Collins February 26, 2012 - 1:37am

The Guardian hides behind occasional liberalism and the fact that John Pilger writes there occasionally. But they're just flacks for the Empire Project.

Considering the fact that the credence for the Libyan revolution came from a bunch of suspect tweets, the tape I posted is just as valid a source, and I'm starting with questions.

I will continue my search for a decent English language news source (across the board, not just occasionally). I'm open to suggestions.

The Money Party RSS

Michael Collins February 26, 2012 - 1:24am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.