SearchUser loginNavigationTeam AgonistThoughtfulAbu Aardvark GlobalaliasBruce TimelyMixed Bag of Candy: Who's onlineThere are currently 5 users and 417 guests online.
Online users:Syndicate |
America's Back Is About To BreakAmerica's economic back is about to break, and at bottom it's about trade. Let's lay this out really simply. The way you industrialize an economy is through mercantilism. You subsidize exports in some fashion, while protecting your internal market. You can do this through subsidies or currency manipulation or you can do it through tariffs. No nation larger than a city state has EVER industrialized in any other fashion, with the possible exceptions of Russia and England (depending on when you put the dates). England was the first, which was a huge advantage; plus, in effect, they forced their colonies to buy their goods and made sure the colonies didn't supply manufactured goods in exchange. British "Laissez-faire" was roughly half propaganda after all. Mercantilist-driven industrialization occurred in the United States, which had heavy tariffs throughout the nineteenth century and right through the twenties and thirties. It was true of Japan. It is true of China. It was true of all the Asian Tigers. And so on. There is no other path to industrialization that reliably works. Stupid policies like "shock therapy," tried out on Russia, led to an actual reduction in Gross GDP and an actual decline in population. IMF free trade policies imposed on third world countries ensured they would become nothing but poverty-stricken commodity producers. The great oil nations of the Middle East, however rich they seem, are in fact poor, and when oil prices finally crash due to forced substitution taking off, they will be amongst the most wretched and miserable places on earth. Don't cry for the House of Saud, they'll be enjoying their retirement on the Riviera, wrecking hotel rooms and wasting their money on blow and hookers. Normal Saudis, on the other hand, will live lives of complete hopelessness in post-modern wastelands. Now here's the deal: industrialization always requires external markets for the goods. (The only possible exception I can think of might be the USSR, but that was an odd case; more on that another time.) America industrialized on the back of Europe. Japan industrialized (first time around) by forcing other Asians to buy their goods. The second time it industrialized with preferred trade status with the US. The Tigers industrialized by selling to the US and Japan. And China has industrialized, to a large extent, by selling to the US. Now the problem is that mercantilist-style industrialization leads to offshoring of productive capacity. The cheaper and protected domicile (think of the US in the 19th century when it had high tariffs and the Brits were playing Laissez-Faire "destroy the empire" games) gets an outflux of manufacturing jobs from the primary economy. It gets huge amounts of productive investment from the primary economy. (The money China invests in the US is not productive; it finances BS like real estate.) When a country uses such policies to industrialize, it damages the industrial sector of the country it's trading with. It's just that simple because its prices and its labor are underpriced and deliberately manipulated to stay so. (China has been spending about 10% of GDP just to peg the Yuan to the dollar). The early to middle stages of this seem like the best of times to the primary economies elites. Before World War I the British rich were rolling in it. The middle and working classes were taking it on the chin, but that fact, while recognized by the elite, seemed fairly unimportant to them. (The difference being that, at that point, the Brits while having suffered greater relative erosion, at least still had a positive balance of payments due to all the investment money pouring into the city of London, and from there into the hands of the rich. In the US, the rich are still making out like bandits, but the balance of payments is abysmal, more closely following the Spanish than the British example.) The modern twist is caused by the telecommunications revolution. In the old days most service jobs, at least, had to stay at home. In the current day, not so much: hence outsourcing and offshoring. So the "sucking sound" from all the secondary economies is much, much stronger. The problem with this game is that the US just can't take it anymore. For too long other countries have been subsidizing Americans to consume, and in exchange, industrializing on the back of US consumers. But the US consumer broke, with a negative savings rate. Families aren't just failing to save, they're deep in debt. Inflation in real goods that matter--food and fuel--is out of control. There's a huge financial overhang from a massive asset bubble, and suddenly everyone realizes it and the fictions that kept the system operating "really, it's an AA bond!" have come tumbling down. America's back is about to break. And since the US consumer has been carrying the Asian economies, that means a world wide recession at best, and a depression as the worst case (but not necessarily unlikely) scenario. China is not going to "decouple" from the US and suddenly have enough consumer demand to see this through, especially not when they also have out of control inflation and massive exposure to the bad debt. The production that does sell to the US is the margin that makes for the explosive economic growth, and when it's gone, so goes the Chinese economy. This is also going to be true pretty much everywhere else, including Japan (whose free money policy was responsible for the Yen carry trade and thus much of the financial bubble), India and the Asian tigers. And what happens when your back breaks? You become a cripple. The US has lived far beyond its means, on borrowed money, for some time. Rather than either trying to fix the problem, or trying to adjust slowly to reduced circumstances, America is now in danger of having to adjust in one abrupt, sickening crash--from 100 mph to 0--courtesy of hitting a brick wall while Bernanke's foot is on the accelerator, with Congress's foot jammed on top for good measure, as it approves huge amounts of stimulus by way of "war funding." America and Americans have lived well beyond their means for too long. Soon the credit card is going to start bouncing. Smart people cut it up and see a counselor at that point. Bernanke? He prints more money. Should be interesting. Ian Welsh November 26, 2007 - 12:00pm
|
![]() |