SearchUser loginNavigationCreate new accountTeam Agonist
Universal Pantograph provides technical support for The Agonist. ThoughtfulTimelyMixed Bag of Candy: Who's onlineThere are currently 7 users and 864 guests online.
Syndicate |
The Immorality of Moral PeopleIt's well documented that the most ostensibly moral people often commit the most immoral acts. One can charge them with hypocrisy, but the phenomenon is more complicated than that. People who are intensely moral tend to elevate the value of certain strictures over others. A recent study makes the point:
The problem with this study is that it takes something that is a variable, the question of "what is moral" and assumes it. If a "moral" person doesn't see cheating, for example, as immoral, then to them it isn't. Morality is intensely malleable depending on circumstances, culture and upbringing. If you know that gays are bad, or abortion is murder, or that your nation is the best and worth killing for, then there is no immorality in shunning gays, killing abortionists (based on the thinking that if someone is murdering hundreds it is moral to kill to stop them) or in obeying orders to kill in wartime (which boils down to murder, when you get right down to it). The more certain you are of your moral code, the easier it is to justify doing what others might consider immoral acts in pursuit of what, for you, is the true morality. And so there is nothing odd about the bigotry of some truly religious and their willingness to kill those their faith tells them to kill. There is no oddity in the true patriot killing for his country. But there's also no oddity in the Quaker who won't kill under any circumstance, or the missionary who cares for lepers, or the whistle blower who cannot be corrupted at any price. Moral codes, truly believed, are swords. A strong moral code is both a shield and a bane, making you strong in some directions and weak in others, vulnerable to being used by those who manipulate you through your code. Ian Welsh November 21, 2007 - 9:00am
|
![]() Premium Advertising
Advertise Liberally |