Is "The Writing on The Wall" For War With Iran?


For some time now here at the Agonist we've been front-paging pieces by Hannes Artens. Hannes is the author of a book, The Writing on the Wall, which is a fictionalized account of an American war with Iran.

Hannes has shown that he has foreign policy chops and now has generously offered a review copy or possibly review copies of his new book for the Agonist. There are a couple ways we could do this.

The first, and I think most interesting, would be to have 3 or 4 Agonistas who are willing to commit to a live chat (perhaps on a Saturday afternoon) to read the book, then at the appointed time, one will review it and Hannes and those who have read the book, along with any other interested Agonistas, will chat about both the book, and what a war with Iran would be like. What scenarios are likely? What are the US's capabilities? In what ways can Iran strike back? Of those ways, which, if any, is Iran likely to choose? Would they work, and what can the US do to blunt or prevent them? I think most Agonistas are familiar with the infamous wargame where unconventional tactics allowed the side opposing America to sink a number of American ships: is there some risk of that here, with the US navy operating in enclosed waters? Are there lessons from the Lebanese war that can be applied here or is this a unique situation? What about the price, and actually concrete supply of oil? The questions go on and on.

The second possibility is a more traditional review. As usual, you'd get the book, and be expected to produce a (good) review within 3 weeks of getting it. If for some reason you couldn't do so, you'd be expected to send the book to someone who can.

If you're interested in either (or both) of these possibilities, please say so in comments, or drop me a PM. The possibility of an Iranian war is something we've been looking at seriously at the Agonist for some time and a thorough discussion of what one would be like could be more than worth our time.


Ian Welsh November 9, 2007 - 6:00am

My class is in hiatus until the spring (don't ask - scheduling is not a departmental strong suit) - I now have a little time to devote to topical fiction and would be interested if the offer's still on the table.

BTW, amazon.ca is stocking this on a pretty lackadaisical level - words to the effect of "order it, we'll see if we can bestir ourselves to get it and send it on to you when we're good and ready".

"A survey data set containing imputed values should not be analyzed uncritically as if all the data were real values." ~ Graham Kalton

JustPlainDave November 15, 2007 - 9:59am

two other takers. I've dropped a note to Hannes to contact you. If you don't hear from him in a couple days PM me and I'll take care of it.

Ian Welsh November 16, 2007 - 10:29am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.