The Market Collapse Spreads


Seems that the US collapse is going worldwide, as of this writing. The story here isn't very complicated. Mortgage woes (not subprime, it's spreading beyond subprime, which is the problem) are causing problems in a number of hedge funds. The huge securities binge of the last few years was made possible in large part by bundling mortgages of various types into instruments which could be sold to investors. When done properly, the theory was that if even a few defaulted, eh, the instrument as a whole should be fine. But it wasn't always done properly, and even when done so it still wasn't done properly, because the risk was much higher than standard models predicted because mortgage lenders were lending to all sorts of people who shouldn't be loaned to and because the housing market was a bubble but since people in the middle of a bubble can never admit that (if many people did, it wouldn't be a bubble) they didn't account for the fact.

Add that to extremely loose money policies by a number of major central banks (Japan, most notably right now, but the US in the past) and the necessity for the Asian countries to buy dollar denominated assets so they could prop up the dollar, and thus their export industries, and you had a classic recipe for a financial bubble.

We then had mortgage lenders start going under. Some hedge funds were forced to admit that they were taking staggering losses (including, but not limited to some Bear Sterns funds) and either add liquidity or stop redemptions, and the entire system started to realize just how widespread bad loans, and therefore bad securities, were. Since these funds tend to be heavily levered (10:1 and up), each time one can't make its margin calls means various other funds, banks and lenders suddenly have bad loans on their hands. They then must consider selling in order to cover them.

In addition, a lot of securities were listed on the balance sheets at "book price" (aka Mark to model). Now that various funds are being forced to sell them in a rush, they're getting "market prices" and the market prices are much lower than the book prices. Other funds, otherwise unaffected, have to take this account in how much they're valuing the securities on their books (market prices generally trump book prices), which causes them to suddenly have balance problems. And so it spreads - or can.

Meanwhile the Yen is rising, and there is speculation that the Bank of Japan wants to raise the overnight rate from its (practically free) rate of 0.5%. If the rise continues, or the rate does increase, a lot of people who have been borrowing from Japan to invest in US assets are going to be caught in a vice and forced to sell off. (Which means, odds are, that the BoJ will back down for now while making it clear people should start an orderly unwinding of such positions).

How bad's all this going to be? Bad. That said, the European Central Bank has stepped in with a huge injection of liquidity (which so far isn't stopping the panic), as has Australia, and the Bank of Japan. But the market was hoping for, and didn't get, an easing of the Fed rate -and overnight funds, while they may help the banks sop up the mess a bit, won't necessarily deal with the underlying problem, which is that a bunch of people are waking up and realizing the securities they were sold are going to pay back cents on the dollar.

The pain, in other words, is real, and it's probably going to require an S&L style bailout in the end. And since it is real, even if the market manages to recover due to enough liquidity from the central banks, the underlying problem will continue to unravel. And if the banks insist on sending huge amounts of liquidity into the market over a longer period, well, we'll probably have yet another bubble.


Ian Welsh August 10, 2007 - 2:21am
( categories: Analysis | The Markets )

Countdown to a crisis

Friday August 10, 2007
Guardian Unlimited

February 8

HSBC issues first profit warning as bad debt provision from UK mortgage lending spirals

March 13

Dow Jones Industrial Average falls 242 points after rise in mortgage arrears and home repossessions in US

April 2

US lender New Century Financial files for bankruptcy after increase in bad loans

May 4

Dillon Read, hedge fund run by Swiss bank UBS, closes after losing £62m on sub-prime

June 23

Bear Stearns says two hedge funds with billions invested in sub-prime market are in trouble

June 29

Caliber Global Investment, hedge fund run by UK's Cambridge Place, sells assets after £4.4m losses on sub-prime

July 18

US Federal Reserve chairman Ben Bernanke warns of debt contagion from sub-prime lenders

July 23

AXA Investment Managers closes £460m sub-prime related fund to new investors.

July 26

Alliance Boots and Chrysler fail to find buyers for £10bn of debt to fund buyouts

July 27

Cadbury delays sale of its US drinks division blaming turmoil in credit markets

July 30

German lender IKB issues profits warning linked to sub-prime lending. CEO quits

August 1

German banks bail out IKB bank for £2.4bn. In Australia, Macquarie Bank says two of its funds face losses of 25%

August 2

Mitchells & Butler's £4.5bn property spin off delayed by credit turmoil

August 6

Bear Stearns co-president Warren Spector ousted over bad debt fiasco

August 7

£23bn sale of Virgin Media in doubt. US lender American Home Mortgage goes bust

August 9

BNP Paribas suspends three funds. ECB opens emergency funds to ease credit crunch

Tina August 10, 2007 - 5:45am

January, 2007: The Agonist, an American internet publication, warns of serious sub-prime risks and repurcussions? We saw this more than a year ago.

"There is a principle which is a bar against all information, which is proof against all argument, and which cannot fail to keep a man in everlasting ignorance. This principle is, contempt prior to examination."

Sean Paul Kelley August 10, 2007 - 10:16am
Don August 11, 2007 - 7:29am

Wrote about it back in 2002 on the Atlantic's forums, which both Maha and Stirling can confirm. ;) And we were writing about it on BOP in 2004.

But being right too early does you no good. People never remember, it's the ones who started pounding it just before it became obvious to the world who are now associated with it.

Ian Welsh August 11, 2007 - 7:39am

One has to be a subscriber to see Atlantic posts :(

Tina August 11, 2007 - 8:34am

Yeah, that's why I'm not there anymore. I doubt they have posts that far back. If they do and you manage to get on, look for the Dow 36,000 threads, that's where Stirling, myself, Elaine Supkis and a few others used to tear it up on economic and market matters.

Ian Welsh August 11, 2007 - 8:13pm

when one writes about things like this in advance is "in the long run, we're all dead", neh?

The capitalist's credo - the ultimate argument for "short-term" over "long-range" thinking and a worthy companion to "Posterity? What's posterity ever done for me?"


"The best-informed man is not necessarily the wisest. Indeed there is a danger that precisely in the multiplicity of his knowledge he will lose sight of what is essential."

- Dietrich Bonhoeffer

Escher Sketch August 11, 2007 - 1:55pm

Markets go red as contagion spreads

Europe's central bank releases £64bn emergency funds as US bad debt crisis takes hold around the globe

David Teather and Andrew Clark in New York
Friday August 10, 2007
The Guardian

Central banks on both sides of the Atlantic pumped billions into the financial system to calm nerves over an impending credit crunch yesterday - but their actions only served to heighten alarm, leading to a fresh plunge in global share prices.
The European Central Bank injected an emergency €95bn (£64.5bn) into the markets, in its first intervention since the turmoil triggered by the 9/11 terrorist attacks on New York and Washington DC in 2001.

In America, the Federal Reserve added $24bn in temporary reserves to the US banking system to shore up liquidity and bring down short-term interest rates, while the Bank of Canada mounted a similar operation.
The moves, however, seemed to fuel a sense of crisis over defaults in America's mortgage lending industry, which are causing a ripple effect through the banking industry as much of the debt is bundled up and sold on.

On Wall Street, blue-chip shares had their worst day in four months as the Dow Jones Industrial Average dropped by 387 points to 13,270. Stock prices swung wildly, and trading volumes hit an all-time record with 2.8bn shares changing hands. Of the Dow's 30 component stocks, 29 ended the day lower.

Bourses across Europe fell, with the FTSE 100 in London finishing down 122.7 at 6271.2. The nervousness spread to all assets that appeared risky, including commodities.

The fresh sell-off was sparked by an announcement from the French bank BNP Paribas that it had blocked withdrawals from three investment funds worth €2bn because of the "complete evaporation" of liquidity. A spokesman for the bank described it as a technical issue, and said he hoped it would be a temporary situation.

There were also reports that the US bank Goldman Sachs has suffered losses in two of its hedge funds. Goldman is said to have sold down positions at its North American Equity Opportunities and Global Alpha funds, both of which rely on computer models rumoured to have struggled with recent volatility.

Nick Parsons, head of markets strategy at nabCapital, said that one of reason investors were so nervous was the sheer complexity of contemporary financial markets with the growth of instruments such as securitisation and credit derivatives.

"The problem for the markets is they don't know where this is heading. It is like walking blindfold through a minefield. There is no way of knowing who owns this stuff. But what is clear is that this is not just a US problem. This debt is owned by a huge variety of institutions, some you've heard of, some you've never heard of, and some you are probably going to hear of soon."

snip snip
more

FAQ: What's shaking the markets

Why are financial markets in a panic?

Investors are worried that fallout from the credit crunch in the US is much more widespread than feared. So they dumped risky assets yesterday, causing sharp market falls.

What has caused the credit crunch?

Many US mortgage holders on low incomes have been unable to meet their loan repayments, their homes have been repossessed, and banks are having to write off sub-prime loans.

Why has this affected Europe?

Many banks in the US and Europe have bought these sub-prime loans, often packaged in pools of debt.

Why is this a problem?

These debt pools are worth a lot less than banks paid for them and are very difficult to sell. Some banks have been forced to close funds that were exposed to these loans and the US sub-prime sector.

Why are central banks worried?

Central bankers are concerned about a squeeze on the amount of cash in the financial system. This is because when investors are worried about risky markets, they want to hold high proportions of cash.

What were central banks doing yesterday?

Banks led by the European Central Bank were making large amounts of cash available to commercial banks.

Did the Bank of England do anything?

No. Mervyn King, governor of the Bank, said on Wednesday the turmoil in credit markets was a long way from being an international financial crisis.

Did the central banks' money calm markets?

It is too soon to say. Investors were glad central banks have acted. But sometimes when bankers show concern it makes markets even more panicky.

Tina August 10, 2007 - 5:57am

called the Fed to demand cheaper interest rates. And China calls for higher rates.

Rock, hard place. Sword and the wall.

I did inhale.

Don August 10, 2007 - 7:47am

Right now in August is the traditional time that all the big moneyed people take their vacations. Just like the Boy King in Crawford Texas. Boy King announced yesterday before taking an all expense paid flight to Crawford: "I am told there is enough liquidity in the system to enable markets to correct,". I feel bad for you Texans having to claim him. Just like the dude Regan who got this whole ball of crap going in high gear down hill, claiming my home state of California as his home also. On top of that, the prime ranch area above Santa Barbra as his home. I was very glad that his property did not but-up to mine.
The country is facing what may be financial melt down and the boy king goes on vacation. It’s true that one can work from a vacation home, but as commander codpiece, he needs to stay at the throttles on this one, and stay in D.C. and sweat with the little folks.
"The president's job is to think not only about today, but tomorrow"
george bush delivers deep insights in a speach given on
April 19, 2007
Tipp City High School
Tipp City, Ohio

Peter C August 10, 2007 - 9:35am

Yep, Reagan was born in Illinois but is remembered as a Californian. Shrub was born in Connecticut but is thought of as a Texan. In the circles that I travel in, we never claimed him.

I will say that, back when he was Governor, we wound up having dinner in a small French restaurant (I guess it's a Freedom restaurant now!) where Shrub and his party were having dinner. I was favorably impressed at how unobtrusive he and they were trying to be in such a small shared space. It was also the only time that I've ever been favorably impressed with him.

Eric Gen August 10, 2007 - 10:11am

a true Texan. He is, however, a world class asshole.

"There is a principle which is a bar against all information, which is proof against all argument, and which cannot fail to keep a man in everlasting ignorance. This principle is, contempt prior to examination."

Sean Paul Kelley August 10, 2007 - 10:17am

SPIEGEL ONLINE - August 10, 2007, 11:18 AM
URL: http://www.spiegel.de/international/business/0,1518,499160,00.html

BAD DEBTS
American Mortgage Crisis Rattles German Banking Sector

By Frank Hornig, Lothar Pauly and Christian Reiermann

Germany has bailed out one bank burdened with American "subprime" mortgage risks, but the fun may not be over -- as the earthquake in world markets this week demonstrates.

Cheap deals on American home loans are haunting investment banks in Europe. Average housing prices are falling across the United States, "for the first time since the 1930s."
Getty Images

Cheap deals on American home loans are haunting investment banks in Europe. Average housing prices are falling across the United States, "for the first time since the 1930s."

The saviors of the German financial sector came together early this month in a sterile conference room at the Düsseldorf headquarters of the IKB commercial bank. The head of Germany's state development bank KfW, Ingrid Matthäus-Maier, looked anxious. Jörg Asmussen, a departmental head at the Finance Ministry, wrung his hands. His boss, Finance Minister Peer Steinbrück, called from his home in Bonn; other top leaders of German banks were also listening in.

Germany had been hit by a version of the crisis that surprised French investors on Thursday, sending stock markets from New York to Tokyo into unexpected dives. Debts arising from America's so-called subprime mortgage sector had just caused IKB to falter.

The most thankless job fell to Matthäus-Maier. She had to tell those in attendance that KfW's stake in IKB was in an unforeseen predicament. The niche bank specializes in the rather dull sector of financing mid-sized companies; but recently it had taken on risky investments in the United States. The bank's management made some bad bets, and lost. Now it was teetering on the edge of insolvency, unless other German financial institutions chipped in with emergency funding.

Jochen Sanio, president of Germany's banking supervisory agency BaFin, was pessimistic: If IKB folded, the failure might spread to other institutions, and maybe set off the biggest bank crisis since the Great Depression in the 1930s. Bundesbank President Axel Weber was less bleak, but made another troubling prediction: A chain reaction could endanger Germany's banking reputation. The gathering of bankers and government officials decided to undertake the biggest rescue operation for a single bank that Germany has ever seen.

American Dreams Gone Sour

The epicenter of this financial quake is the United States. Hardly a day passes now when an American mortgage lender or hedge fund doesn't go belly-up. The world's equity markets first plunged in response to the crisis in mid-July. Germany's leading stock index, the Dax, lost over ten percent in a matter of days, and America's Dow Jones dropped six percent.

Another round of panic hit world markets this week after a French bank, BNP Paribas, had to freeze three investment funds worth €2.76 billion ($3.79 billion) because of American mortgage debts. The Down Jones fell three percent on Thursday, and central banks in the US, Europe and Japan have injected money markets with billions of dollars to ease credit jitters.

The crisis has even started to frighten US consumers, whose joy in spending has until recently the bedrock of the world economy. They're not just victims in this story, but also the cause of the mess. They've built and bought big new houses on easy credit without thinking about potential consequences. This was not a problem as long as real estate values climbed, allowing them to take out ever-larger housing equity loans. But the overheated US housing market started to crash this year, putting an end to the carefree days of American homeownership.

Rising house prices in America started a craze for "subprime" mortgages, or housing loans offered to homebuyers below the prime lending rate. Typically these loans involve a low-rate grace period before a higher rate comes into effect. And as long as housing prices boomed, debts associated with these mortgages could be packaged as attractive investment vehicles for big institutions. But now the market has stalled and abundant credit for such risky investments has dried up -- and anyone, apparently, can run into trouble.

One Bank's Quick Decline

much more

Tina August 10, 2007 - 9:59am

Three economists on NPR Diane Rehm yesterday responded to a callers question about a comparison with the S&L rip off of the late '80 by saying that...Oh no, hedge funds are private enterprise ...the government has no obligation to bail them out(paraphrasing).
Ah, the delusions of worshipping at the the shrine of the Free Market.
Stirling is right, the Decade of Stupidity. Dumber than dirt or a box of rocks.
I read somewhere that Americans love to have their financial crashes in autumn.

JT August 10, 2007 - 10:38am

"There is a principle which is a bar against all information, which is proof against all argument, and which cannot fail to keep a man in everlasting ignorance. This principle is, contempt prior to examination."

Sean Paul Kelley August 10, 2007 - 11:35am

It would be interesting to put into the timeline comments from certain people about the morgage problem is fully contained. Seems like I heard that a lot all down the line.

Joaquin August 10, 2007 - 11:36am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.