The Answer Is No


Recently I wrote an article discussing whether municipalities, specifically New Orleans, had an obligation to bring low income people back from evacuation. In the article I discussed and asked the question does the city owe the poor a return ticket back to poverty and to their slums?

According to many in Louisiana and along the Gulf Coast, the answer is a resounding no! It appears that many jurisdictions are rezoning and allowing previously zoned areas to expire so that they can remove the makeshift trailer parks that FEMA created after the Katrina catastrophe. The modern day “Hoovervilles” are becoming unwelcome to the local governments. These governments want to evict the evacuees and shut down the trailer parks. According to these jurisdictions the trailer parks have become crime-infested, pockets of poverty. There are some who believe that it is not about crime or poverty, but has racial implications. The residents in these jurisdictions have a concern about poor, black people living in their neighborhoods.

Mr. Roberts complained that such residents were often idle, but many evacuees have burdens that prevent them from working.

Gwendolyn Marie Allen, 55, formerly of the Uptown section of New Orleans, now lives in Renaissance Village, a large FEMA trailer park near the Baton Rouge airport. Ms. Allen is the sole caretaker for a son, 20, who was given a diagnosis of schizophrenia after a violent episode in the park, and a severely retarded brother, who huddled on the bottom bunk of a bed in their travel trailer, clad only in adult diapers. In an interview, Ms. Allen periodically shushed his wordless moans by waving a green flyswatter in his direction.

“I want to get out of here, baby, this is not no house,” she said. “I want something where he can move around.”

As proof of her resourcefulness, Ms. Allen opened the freezer of the trailer’s compact refrigerator where, to make room for bargain packs of meat from the supermarket, she had removed the shelves.

“The renters aren’t asking that much, just give us a start,” she said. “Put us there, and we could do what we have to do to survive. We could catch it from there.”

NY Times

As I stated previously these local governments are not going to rebuild the public housing and low rent houses that these residents formerly resided in. And as if that wasn’t enough they are in the process of demolishing what housing was left, most of which would require little if any rehabilitation. No, this is about recreating New Orleans and the Gulf Coast in a whole new image, an image that does not include poor, black folks.

Is this a sign to poor, black folks everywhere? If your home is destroyed by natural disaster or any other means you could and very well will be relocated, never to return. Of course, for most black folks this is nothing new. We have homes that are destroyed every year in our neighborhoods by fires or other catastrophes that are never rebuilt, only to become empty lots, lots that become dumping grounds and over-run with foliage. I think we are all though, a little bit shocked by it being done on this grand of a scale. I can’t recall the relocation of so many poor blacks from any major city on this magnitude. These people were once proud residents of these cities and have a right to be brought back home.

I am afraid however we are seeing the recasting of New Orleans, where if you aren’t rich and white, we don’t want you. It is unbelievable that with all the low skill labor that is needed in New Orleans that they are not going to provide adequate housing for these workers? Where are these workers suppose to live? The current development plans include raising the rent in these renovated areas two to three times what the apartments were before. These minimum wage workers will not be able to afford to live in the city where they work.

So my question to these civic leaders is who is going to make up your beds, wash your dishes, and supersize your meals without these workers?

False history gets made all day, any day,
the truth of the new is never on the news - Adrienne Rich

The Disputed Truth


Forgiven July 16, 2007 - 9:26am

a horn, you're cool; otherwise...

http://mauberly.blogspot.com/

mauberly July 16, 2007 - 5:29pm

The majority of poor black folks don't play the horn, they just be poor. They have a chance to build a new NO and Gulf Coast and if they can they are going to do it minus all poor folks. This is more neocon testing for the rest of America...

Forgiven July 16, 2007 - 5:49pm

this plan to move the blacks, where will they go? I'm thinking once they send all the brownfolk home they can fill the tent cities with blacks. ;-)

Tina July 16, 2007 - 6:08pm

...and run with it. Sounds to me like they're "sunsetting the ni**ers" outta town once again.

I missed something, I guess.....when did it become a crime to be poor and black in this country?

-5.75,-4.05 "I am in earnest; I will not equivocate; I will not excuse; I will not retreat a single inch; and I will be heard."
William Lloyd Garrison
US abolitionist & editor (1805 - 1879)

justadood July 16, 2007 - 6:18pm

been a crime to be poor, being black or brown just compounds it. The plight of the homeless perfectly illustrates that.


"I beseech you in the bowels of christ think it possible you may be mistaken."

Scott M July 16, 2007 - 8:49pm

Social Policy–The Katrina Experiment. Displacement into other areas of the country may give indications as to whether destroying pockets of urban poverty and placing people in other areas may indicate if that is a successful strategy.

The “Experiment” discussed

Conclusion: The social-science elitists may find it hard to believe, but poor blacks really can figure out what they need to do when the facts are put in front of them and the responsibility is theirs to act.

-----

The pdf report does sound heartless, and the title cries out to be less clinical, but it may be years before the effects of moving such a large number of people is known. Seems like in early reports, genders may not respond favourably to new locations. Many changes do need to be made to FEMA to make it more humane--people deserve to be treated with dignity regardless of their education or economic status.

canuck July 16, 2007 - 6:37pm

Some of the crap that these guys try to get away with is ridiculous. Cities without poor black folks. What will they think of next?

Forgiven July 16, 2007 - 9:37pm

So my question to these civic leaders is who is going to make up your beds, wash your dishes, and supersize your meals without these workers?

What do you think illegal immigrants are for?

Conservatives are not necessarily stupid, but most stupid people are conservatives. John Stuart Mill

Don Quijote July 16, 2007 - 7:27pm

We'll get an immigration bill passed yet...

Forgiven July 16, 2007 - 9:38pm

..the IIs still have to live somewhere. They gonna bus them in from out of state every morning?

geoduck July 17, 2007 - 1:02am

Maybe they could do like Israel and the Palestinians...fence them into camps at night and let them out in the morning for work, oh wait they already do that...its called the ghetto

Forgiven July 17, 2007 - 9:08am

between the treatment given to whites and blacks is shameful.

However, in the case of New Orleans, I question whether low-lying areas should be re-developed for people of any color. Read Rising Tide and you'll know why. New Orleans dodged a bullet. They may not be so lucky next time. The events that doomed N.O. were set in motion long ago, and are, quite possibly, beyond repair.

I did inhale.

Don July 17, 2007 - 9:21am

The geography is bad, but it always has been for NO. In the meantime while we wait for the "big one" the city will be inhabited by urban whites, while the evacuees are left stuck out in nowhere land without a pot or a window to throw it out of...shameful indeed

Forgiven July 17, 2007 - 10:32am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.