Euro Officially Surpasses Dollar


For market and economic analysis, go to the Bonddad Blog

The financial press reported last week that the euro, the new currency created only five years ago and used by most European nations, has supplanted the U.S. dollar as the most widely used form of cash internationally. There are now more Euros in circulation worldwide than dollars.

This alone is not necessarily troubling, as the dollar remains the world’s most important reserve currency. About 65% of foreign central bank exchange reserves are still held in dollars, versus only about 25% in euros. And the European Central Bank faces the same inflationary pressures that our own Federal Reserve Bank Governors face, including a growing entitlement burden that threatens economic ruin as both societies age. European politicians want to spend money just as badly as American politicians, and undoubtedly will clamor to inflate-- and thus devalue-- the euro to fund their creaky social welfare systems.

Still, the rise of the Euro internationally is another sign that the U.S. dollar is not what it used to be. There is increasing pressure on nations to buy and sell oil in euros, and anecdotal evidence suggests that drug dealers and money launderers now prefer euros to dollars. Historically, the underground cash economy has always sought the most stable and valuable paper currency to conduct business.

This is what happens when supply-side economics and rampant "shop 'til you drop" consumerism is the dominant economic policy of a nation.

The US government has run massive fiscal deficits for the last 6 years. Despite the accounting tricks used to mask the deficit's true size, the Bureau of Public Debt reports that total outstanding debt on September 30 2001 was $5,807,463,412,200.06 and currently stands at $8,593,076,179,156.67 -- an increase of 48% in six years. At the same time, the US government has cut taxes and gone to war, which has increased discretionary expenditures over 30%. Here's a graphic representation of the "MBA President's" fiscal policy (the top line represents expenditures):

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

The US consumer has continually increased individual purchasing for some time. This has resulted in a mammoth trade deficit:

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

To finance this deficit, foreign governments have doubled their purchases of US Treasuries over the last 6 years:

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

Instead of savings, the US consumer has gone into debt to finance US growth.

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

US Savings:

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

The end result of these policies is simple: Despite the many protestations of a "strong dollar policy" has come under continued assault in the currency markets. Here's an 8-year chart of the dollar.

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

A devalued dollar leads to several basic economic problems.

1.) The US Federal Reserve's ability to lower interest rates in the event of an economic slowdown is hemmed in. A devalued dollar means the US has a higher probability of importing inflation. The Federal Reserve is charged with price stability. If it lowers interest rates and the dollar is decreasing in value, it may import inflation.

2.) The possibility of the dollar being shocked be a random economic event are higher. Consider that over the last few weeks Thailand implemented draconian currency controls that sent its markets down 10% in a day. While the government reversed policy within 24 hours, if they hadn't have done so, it is possible the effects would have eventually bled over into the dollar.

3.) Right now foreign central banks are playing a giant international game of chicken. No one want to see their official reserves decrease in value. So, they all want to slowly sell dollars and buy more euros. However, by selling dollars they may create a selling panic that further decreases their respective currency reserves. In the current environment the possibility of one government making the wrong move is higher simply because of the dollar's precarious valuation.


Bonddad January 2, 2007 - 8:55am

The amount of cash is small in the world of corporates and credit cards.

The inflation pressures in EUrope are smaller than in the USA because the gasoline price is not as significant in the economy and because of the new member countries.

During the last year Estonia reported 11% GDP growth in the autumn. Finland is expected to report 5.6%-5.9% GDP growth for the year 2006.

the euro to fund their creaky social welfare systems.

The Readers' Digest forecast imminent destruction of Europe because of "creaky social welfare systems" in 1970's. Since then the USA has followed European social welfare system solutions in many ways.

My understanding is that Chinese leaders admire most the Swedish system.

-- 101 ways to avoid the subjunctive mood

Gandalf January 2, 2007 - 9:51am

The economic news of 2006 was that the EU growth surpassed Japanese and American growth. Most of the East Germany bill has been paid.

-- 101 ways to avoid the subjunctive mood

Gandalf January 2, 2007 - 9:53am

I was in east germany over christmas, and must say things have really, really changed, even since a year back.

I'm a regular visitor, and before, the mood was always the same, sorth of apathic. No work, (20++ % unemployment), no prospects. The young people were leaving for the west or abroad, if they could.

Somehow it felt like they didn't WANT to try very much either, as if they didn't believe things could be turned around, or that this is what fate had dealt them. A very difficult psychology to get inside, especially if you come from some sort of functioning, equal opportunity market economy their behaviour and mood could be very incomprehensible. I've seen a small reflection of the same mood in many other disadvantaged east european places, but somhow the presence of social welfare and a (percieved or real) feeling of being exploited by the wessies made things in east germany feel especially hopeless.

Maybe it was worse because those that could had a real chance to leave, and did so, this hasn't been true for much of the rest of eastern europe.

Anyways, the mood this year was very different. Lots more people out in the street, buying things. Lots more shops, and more expensive stores. And unlike before, people were actually carrying home big bags rather than just window shopping. A huge LEGO store, an IKEA, and expensive fashion shops seemed everywhere.
More jobs (unemployment in germany is now less than 4000000 for the first time in a long time, and dropping fast), my father-in-law now has a solid job, after being on/off for years (he's a mechanical engeneer and in his 50's). That a 50+ engeneer can now find a good job tells you a lot about the economy!
And construction seemed everywhere, they're building a new underground metro/rail system. And they have a new factory for producing trams. And a new BMW plant. They even built a retractable roof for the stadium, for the world cup.

But best of all, no one even mentioned the wessies/ossies thing this time around, somehow that stuff now seemed less relevant/forgotten.
Over new years they raised taxes (sales tax went from 16 to 19 percent!!), and noone seemed to complain much about it at all. Again, that's quite unheard of, in the old days such an increase would be a matter of major and endless complaints, and be considered a wrongdoing comparable to throwing garbage in the wrong recycling bin (the ultimate crime in germany).

Finally, they introduced a new, much improved birth leave arrangement, 12-14 months leave at 2/3 salary. (The old arrangement was very bad, and (as a result?) germany has had an extremely low birth rate, the lowest in western europe).

All iun all, I'd be quite suprised if germany doesn't see a serious economic upswing + a serious cut in it's deficit for 2007.
We'll see next year...

incy January 2, 2007 - 8:58pm

I think the everyday Europeans are much more practical as well as just plain moral than most Americans.

that does it. i am buying Euros. and Gold.
****************************
If this were 1700, they'd be saying: "Since civilization began, slavery has existed. It's human nature." I would have believed it. If 1800: "Women will never vote. They are not born rational". I would have believed it.
2006: Make war irrelevant

bernadene January 2, 2007 - 11:37pm

I remember my impression of West Germany's wealth in the late 80's when I was first there being cemented by a friend asking me to keep an eye out for any cars with visible dents, with Bondo on them, scratches or dings.

It took me days to spot one.

Escher Sketch January 2, 2007 - 11:55pm

The subjective economy perceived by people shapes their mood. The subjective economy is loosely related to macroeconomic figures. More and more research is done nowadays how people perceive economy. A decade ago that kind of research was loathed.

The transition of the former socialist countries was made in a quick&dirty style. Thus the living standard of many middle class people deteriorated, what created neonazism etc.

DDR was the wealthiest state in the former socialist bloc.

All in all, I'd be quite suprised if germany doesn't see a serious economic upswing + a serious cut in it's deficit for 2007.

The slow upswing has been there in the figures for a couple of years. The slow upswing means at the moment +0.5% faster GDP growth each year, thus I expect that 2007 is better in Germany than 2006 was, but not radically.

ECB sees growth ahead because it threats to increase the interest rate. Construction cools down when the interest rate rises enough.

-- 101 ways to avoid the subjunctive mood

Gandalf January 4, 2007 - 2:14pm

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.