Penn & Teller's Bullshit


Early this decade, magicians and comedians Penn & Teller concocted a television program on the Showtime cable network called “Bullshit!”

Its first episodes were a very funny and astute debunking of hapless psychics and spoon benders.

A few episodes later, P&T shifted from rightly ridiculing pseudoscience to attacking real, hard peer-reviewed science — as if the two were the same thing.

P&T devoted much of one program to stating that global warming is bullshit.

By doing so, P&T said that the work of thousands of scientists was as false and dumb as the goofy guesses of a small town carnival fortune teller.

The DVD of that season’s programs is now for sale and YouTube videos from it are now being spread across the Internet.

As a result, the 2003 show where P&T assert as proven fact that global warming is bullshit is now finding a brand new audience — people who take as scientific proof Penn & Teller’s claim that global warming is bullshit.

We’ll leave aside that in 2003 the scientific record showed P&T’s claim was total, provable bullshit.

Today, in 2007, the scientific record is now 4 years deeper and 4 years thicker than in 2003.

It all shows that on the most issue important to face Homo sapiens in its history, Penn & Teller are the spoon benders they used to lampoon.

The cold, naked fork of science shows they are the charlatans, spewing lies as truth. And they are also the rubes, who believe in lies handed to them by the Cato Institute and Exxon and spout them as scientific fact.

So now, in 2007, will Penn & Teller have the guts to delete this 2003 episode from their DVD because its factual basis has been proven completely false?

Will they substitute this episode with a special “correction” edition and admit they were wrong?

BULLSHIT!

See http://www.realclimate.org for actual, real science on climate change.


Douglas Watts January 31, 2007 - 1:03am
( categories: Analysis )

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bullshit%21#Global_warming

Global warming

The threat of global warming was downplayed in the "Environmental Hysteria" episode, contradicting the evidence as presented by the established scientific consensus. [14] Some environmentalists have pointed out that both Penn Jillette and Teller are research fellows of the limited government and free market advocacy group the Cato Institute,[15][16] which receives contributions from various individuals and companies, including ExxonMobil,[17] which itself has been the favored target of criticism for funding of what has been coined "climate change denial" by several environmental organizations, The Royal Society, and several US congressmen. However, donations to the Cato Institute by ExxonMobil between the years of 1991 and 2004 totaled only $90,000[1], a demonstrably insignificant percentage of the Cato Institute's annual revenues of over $22.5 million (2005)[2]. Also, it should be noted that as research fellows, Penn Jillette and Teller are not actually paid employees of the Cato Institute and as such would receive neither funding nor direction from the Institute as to the content of the television series.

In the "Environmental Hysteria" program, Jerry Taylor from CATO claims that scientists predicted an ice age in the 1970s, although these predictions of global cooling never occurred in peer-reviewed scientific literature.[18] Despite the reference to scientific data, no mainstream scientist from the area of climatology is present in the episode, and Penn and Teller instead rely on figures such as the statistician Bjørn Lomborg and critic Patrick Moore. [19] (See also Global warming controversy.)

The same episode disputes current levels of species extinction, although much of the scientific literature projects very high species extinction levels. [20][21] (See also Holocene extinction event.)

quiet Bill January 31, 2007 - 5:00am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.