Kunstler goes mainstream


Reality check. Fudging numbers and wishing upon stars ain't going to fix this mess. A prophet cries from the wilderness. Will you listen? dhfjr.

WaPo

Wake Up, America. We're Driving Toward Disaster.

By James Howard Kunstler
Sunday, May 25, 2008; Page B03

Everywhere I go these days, talking about the global energy predicament on the college lecture circuit or at environmental conferences, I hear an increasingly shrill cry for "solutions." This is just another symptom of the delusional thinking that now grips the nation, especially among the educated and well-intentioned.

I say this because I detect in this strident plea the desperate wish to keep our "Happy Motoring" utopia running by means other than oil and its byproducts. But the truth is that no combination of solar, wind and nuclear power, ethanol, biodiesel, tar sands and used French-fry oil will allow us to power Wal-Mart, Disney World and the interstate highway system -- or even a fraction of these things -- in the future. We have to make other arrangements.

The public, and especially the mainstream media, misunderstands the "peak oil" story. It's not about running out of oil. It's about the instabilities that will shake the complex systems of daily life as soon as the global demand for oil exceeds the global supply. These systems can be listed concisely:

The way we produce food

The way we conduct commerce and trade

The way we travel

The way we occupy the land

The way we acquire and spend capital

And there are others: governance, health care, education and more.

As the world passes the all-time oil production high and watches as the price of a barrel of oil busts another record, as it did last week, these systems will run into trouble. Instability in one sector will bleed into another. Shocks to the oil markets will hurt trucking, which will slow commerce and food distribution, manufacturing and the tourist industry in a chain of cascading effects. Problems in finance will squeeze any enterprise that requires capital, including oil exploration and production, as well as government spending. These systems are all interrelated. They all face a crisis. What's more, the stress induced by the failure of these systems will only increase the wishful thinking across our nation.

And that's the worst part of our quandary: the American public's narrow focus on keeping all our cars running at any cost. Even the environmental community is hung up on this. The Rocky Mountain Institute has been pushing for the development of a "Hypercar" for years -- inadvertently promoting the idea that we really don't need to change.

Years ago, U.S. negotiators at a U.N. environmental conference told their interlocutors that the American lifestyle is "not up for negotiation." This stance is, unfortunately, related to two pernicious beliefs that have become common in the United States in recent decades. The first is the idea that when you wish upon a star, your dreams come true. (Oprah Winfrey advanced this notion last year with her promotion of a pop book called "The Secret," which said, in effect, that if you wish hard enough for something, it will come to you.) One of the basic differences between a child and an adult is the ability to know the difference between wishing for things and actually making them happen through earnest effort.

Read the rest at the link. Please.


Don May 24, 2008 - 10:03am
( categories: Miscellany )

Kunstler, hits upon one of the efforts that can be initiated/reinvigorated immediately. It is the revitalization of Amtrak, for starters. It's rather sad to see how our Congress reacts to the price of a barrel of oil. The Congress wants to slap the hands of Oil Company Execs in public, rather than embrace the truth of Oil as a limited dirty resource. Kunsler does hit on how the Auto is a sacred cow, but we will have to keep these beasts of burden, I would hate to shovel all those used oats and hay up from the village streets.

"There are two types of folk music:
quiet folk music and loud folk music.
I play both."

Dave Alvin

Peter C May 24, 2008 - 11:25am

but we'll be worse off than those that shoveled shit because we've killed off beasts of burden.

A few things that need to be done, now:

Halt further highway development.

Build sidewalks and bicycle lanes.

Build efficient passenger rail and other mass transit systems.

Revamp railroads for freight.

Reduce speed limits to 60 mph.

Close down foreign military bases so we'll have money to spend at home.

Implement additional taxes on gasoline (but not diesel for farm, construction or semi-trucks) with a system of rebates for the poor.

Dedicate 100% of fuel taxes to development of alternative energy sources, infrastructure development, and energy conservation technology. While new sources of energy are unlikely to keep us all driving, they may save lives (as in freezing to death, etc...)

I did inhale.

Don May 24, 2008 - 1:14pm

The U.S. has to devolve the Empire, that means military spending gets cut. The military as it is configured for Empire and insuring the flow of Oil is not paying off by protecting the U.S. economy. All our industrial might is now on Export of weapons, that is big export business. Can't eat weapons, but you can steal food with them.

Will we be able to adapt? I doubt it. With the mind set of wanting to wage cultural wars/corporate theft inside of Congress, there is not enough brain power left over for serious redirection of policy.

The one glaring example of what the priorities are, brings to mind the day after 9-11-2001, 50 fully armed DEA, FBI, IRS agents raided Medical Marijuana Clinics in Los Angeles. The day before the U.S. was attacked in deadly spectacular fashion. With the unknowness of the situation, would it not be more advantageous to keep at the ready all those gun totting, badge wearing folks at the ready to fret out people who do intend to do real damage. It is a threat all those Hippies, Mexican farmers, Emerald Triangle growers that might make a nickel or two and contribute to some political cause that the government decided was the root cause of 9-11 and needed some attention.

Oh well, I have a well with a wind mill to pump the water, some fertile bottom land, cars that get 50mpg, the ability to convert used oil into stuff that powers the pickups and tractors. I may be going to hell in bucket, at least I am enjoying the ride.

"There are two types of folk music:
quiet folk music and loud folk music.
I play both."

Dave Alvin

Peter C May 24, 2008 - 1:38pm

and river barges are probably the most energy-efficient methods of moving freight. It's odd to see empty railroad tracks sharing the same corridor as truck-clogged Interstate 5 running the length of the West Coast. It's even more puzzling when you discover that a good proportion of the truck traffic is doing the LA-to-Seattle run. Much of the track is so poorly maintained that freights and passenger trains must reduce speed drastically.

We really need to bring rail transportation into the 21st century.

Petronius May 24, 2008 - 1:39pm

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.