Categories

Archives

Credit Where It's Due: Obama & Israel Edition

President Obama has given more help in military aid dollars and military equipment to the state of Israel than any other US leader, something I find reprehensible given Israel’s plainly un-democratic apartheid regime. However, credit where it is due – he’s finally given up his obsession with preserving his options and taken the advice of his military leaders, using an un-ignorable proxy to end any chance of Israel dragging the world into a senseless regional conflict at least while Obama is in office.

Stunned by a rebuke from the United States’ top general, Israel is preparing a climbdown strategy in its war of words over Iran’s nuclear programme, aware that its room for manoeuvre is shrinking rapidly.

…In a move that dismayed Israeli ministers, U.S. Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, General Martin Dempsey, told reporters in Britain last week that the United States did not want to be “complicit” in an Israeli attack on Iran.

He also warned that go-it-alone military action risked unraveling an international coalition that has applied progressively stiff sanctions on Iran, which insists that its ambitious nuclear project is purely peaceful.

Dempsey’s stark comments made clear to the world that Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu was isolated and that if he opted for war, he would jeopardise all-important ties with the Jewish state’s closest ally.

“Israeli leaders cannot do anything in the face of a very explicit ‘no’ from the U.S. president. So they are exploring what space they have left to operate,” said Giora Eiland, who served as national security adviser from 2003 to 2006.

“Dempsey’s announcement changed something. Before, Netanyahu said the United States might not like (an attack), but they will accept it the day after. However, such a public, bold statement meant the situation had to be reassessed.”

Well done, Mr. Obama.

8 comments to Credit Where It's Due: Obama & Israel Edition

  • Anonymous

    TIME: U.S. Scales Back Military Exercise with Israel, Affecting Potential Iran Strike“Basically what the Americans are saying is, ‘We don’t trust you.’”

  • matttbastard

    Al Monitor:

    Some three weeks ago, on the occasion of his 89th birthday, Israeli President Shimon Peres gave loud and clear public expression to his opposition to a possible Israeli military strike against Iran’s nuclear installations. This followed two years during which Peres is said to have counseled Israel’s leaders in closed quarters against the ramifications of such an attack. Giving a number of separate interviews on Aug. 16, Peres did not oppose such a strike under all circumstances. Rather, he warned against an attack that would not receive a green light from Washington.

    Coming after almost every former chief of Israel’s defense and intelligence agencies — and a few of the serving chiefs as well — have already expressed publicly or semi-publicly their opposition to such a strike, Peres’ intervention raises a good question: Why does he matter? Why does someone, who in the Israeli constitutional set-up fills no more than a ceremonial role, count? Without decision-making authority, why should Peres’ voice be considered a significant addition to the already formidable chorus warning of the implications of such an attack?

    The significance of Peres’ intervention in this debate has little to do with the office of the presidency which he now holds. Nor is it only tied to the fact that in the past few years — after a political career that now spans at least six decades — Peres has become a consensus figure in a country where almost no one enjoys such respect. Instead, it results from Peres’ unique standing as the father of Israel’s own nuclear efforts.

    Make sure to read the whole damn thing — Feldman makes an interesting realpolitik argument as to why a unilateral strike on Iran would endanger Israel’s nuclear deterrent capabilities.

  • JustPlainDave

    …has been higher than any other US president?

    Everything around you that you call life was made up by people that were no smarter than you and you can change it, you can influence it, you can build your own things that other people can use.” ~ Steve Jobs

  • Cheryl Rofer

    I still can’t quite figure out what is going on, what Israeli leaders think they’re doing in particular.

    Feeling so vulnerable, Israel needs strong assurances from its key ally, said Dore Gold, a former Israeli ambassador to the United Nations and confidant of Netanyahu.

    “We have to hear something a lot more concrete, a lot more public from the U.S., which is the leader of free world. What is it going to do?” Gold told the Army Radio station.

    Poor babies. Is this group therapy or international relations? Since when does a country lay out its war plans in detail?

    There seems to be something of a media consensus developing that Israel isn’t going to attack Iran this week and the President and the Prime Minister are bffs.

    @MicahZenko just tweeted “Obama should get Netanyahu + Ahmadinejad together while they’re in NY for UNGA, and brief them both on CENTCOM plans for bombing Iran.”

    Next week Bibi will be having a tantrum again. This is just nuts.

  • Steve Hynd

    Reuters, Nov 2011: “”I try not to pat myself too much on the back, but this administration has done more for the security of the state of Israel than any previous administration,” Obama said.

    And Colin Kahl, Obama Has Been Great for Israel – Anyone who tells you otherwise is distorting reality.

    The case for Obama’s Israel policy begins with record-high levels of Foreign Military Financing (FMF). The Obama administration has increased security assistance to Israel every single year since the president took office, providing nearly $10 billion in aid — covering roughly a fifth of Israel’s defense budget — over the past three years. To put this in perspective, this is about 20 percent higher than the remaining six dozen recipients of U.S. FMF combined. Historic aid levels have been complemented by other steps to ensure Israel’s unrivaled military advantage in the region, including high-level consultation with Israeli officials on U.S. arms sales to the region, operational cooperation to improve Israel’s conventional military and counterterrorism capabilities, and providing Israel with advanced technology, such as the fifth-generation stealth Joint Strike Fighter, to which no other state in the Middle East has access.

    Under Obama’s direction, the United States has also deepened defense cooperation aimed at helping Israel address its most pressing security concerns, including rocket and missile threats emanating from the Gaza Strip, Lebanon, Syria, and Iran. When then-Senator Obama traveled to Israel in 2008, it wasn’t for a political fundraiser. Instead, he visited Israeli victims of Palestinian rocket fire in the southern town of Sderot, declaring “I came to Sderot with a commitment to Israel’s security.” These were not just words. As president, Obama has championed efforts to provide Israel with $275 million over and above its annual FMF to help finance Iron Dome, an anti-rocket system that has already saved Israeli lives by intercepting approximately 90 percent of projectiles launched against protected areas in the country’s south in the past year.

    This assistance is part of a comprehensive package that underwrites Israel’s multitiered rocket and missile defense. The package includes U.S. aid for the development of the David’s Sling long-range rocket defense system and the Arrow ballistic missile defense (BMD) systems. It also involves maintaining an advanced U.S. X-band long-range radar system in Israel’s Negev desert, positioning U.S. Aegis BMD ships in the eastern Mediterranean, and conducting the largest joint military exercises in history to improve U.S.-Israel missile defense cooperation.

  • JustPlainDave

    Everything around you that you call life was made up by people that were no smarter than you and you can change it, you can influence it, you can build your own things that other people can use.” ~ Steve Jobs

  • adrena

    2007 – 2.4 billion
    2012 – 3.075 billion: $75 million more than in fiscal year 2011


    “The great humanistic and historical task of the oppressed is to liberate themselves and their oppressors as well” ~ Paulo Freire

  • adrena

    did Obama decrease or increase military aid to Israel?


    “The great humanistic and historical task of the oppressed is to liberate themselves and their oppressors as well” ~ Paulo Freire

Leave a Reply