Police Raids in the US


I normally shun the CATO Institute--in my opinion, Libertarianism in general gets far too many things wrong and its prominent think tanks and scholarly advocates are usually far too biased in their opinions and use of facts. But today I'm linking directly to CATO. This map is a listing of various "botched paramilitary police raids" around the US in relatively recent years (some go back to the 80s). Most of them appear to be drug-related busts, though I've only skimmed the map so far.

Prison brutality was a topic of a recent post here at The Agonist. Reading about some of the raids on this map just reinforces the general point made in that post. Here are a few terrible excerpts:

Donald Scott.

In an early morning drug raid on October 2, 1992, 31 officers from five police agencies break down the door to the multimillion dollar home of Donald Scott.

Frightened, Scott's wife screams, "Don't shoot me. Don't kill me." Hearing his wife's screams, Scott emerges from his bedroom holding a handgun, still groggy from a recent cataract operation. When Scott raises the gun in the direction of the police intruders, the raiding officers shoot him dead.

Despite assurances from the L.A. Sheriff's Department that Scott was farming more than 4,000 marijuana plants on his property, thorough search of Scott's property fails to yield any contraband. In fact, Scott's friends would later say he was adamantly opposed to illicit drugs.

...

According to an L.A. deputy district attorney at the time, two of the agents conducting the raid posed for a triumphant photograph after Scott was shot and killed.

Or how about this one:

The Jerome, Arizona Raid.

In October 1985, a massive team of nearly 100 federal narcotics agents storm a town of just 460 people on a predawn massive marijuana sweep. According to residents, women and children are dragged out of their beds as police break down doors to search homes.

Police seize dozens of pounds of marijuana from the town many describe as an outpost for "hippies."

Next:

Andrea Baker, Erik Kush, Julie Madrigal.

Police conduct a massively armed raid on a home they suspect contains illegal assault weapons and ammunition. In a densely-populated, upscale neighborhood, a SWAT team from the Maricopa County Sheriff's Department, complete with an armored personnel carrier, uses grenade launchers to fire at least four rounds of tear gas into the windows of the home. The quarter-million dollar home catches fire shortly after officers enter.

As the homeowners evacuate, police officers chase the family's 10-month-old pit bull puppy back into the burning house with puffs from a fire extinguisher. The dog perishes in the flames. Police allegedly laugh at Andrea Baker, the dog's owner, as she cries at their cruelty.

Later, the brakes fail on the SWAT team's armored personnel carrier, causing it to lurch down the street and smash into a parked car. The car's owner, Julie Madrigal, had fled the car just moments earlier with her nine-year-old daughter after the two grew frightened by the firing of tear gas canisters by SWAT officers.

The home is completely destroyed. Nearby homes are also put at risk. Police find no assault weapons, only an antique shotgun and a nine-millimeter pistol, both of which are legally owned. Nevertheless, police arrest 26-year-old Erik Kush on outstanding traffic violations.

And finally:

Thomas Spear.

A Las Vegas SWAT team deploys a flashbang grenade and breaks through the glass patio door of Thomas Spear, a 25-year Air Force veteran. Officers handcuff Spear and drag him across the shards of glass while yelling obscenities at him.

The SWAT team believed Spear was about to commit suicide. Spears was actually recovering from brain surgery, was partially paralyzed, and had fallen asleep after taking an extra dose of anti-seizure medication.

Spears had broken no laws. After the raid, the Spears were shunned by neighbors, and forced to move to another town. Spears said enduring the effects of the raid was worse than his illness. "It's much worse than being paralyzed on half your body," he told the Las Vegas Review-Journal.

Now I'm aware that humans make mistakes, and that mistakes made by people with guns tend to be... tragic. That being said, the point here is that most (possibly all) of the cases highlighted on this map should never have happened. In a sane society, people's doors would not be knocked down, guns would not be drawn, SWAT teams would not be called in, jail time would not be served, and lives would not be lost because of a marijuana plant. But we aren't living in a sane society.

Go click around on the map. Scary as hell.


Bolo October 12, 2007 - 12:45pm

on the 3rd story, click here. Joe Arpaio is the sheriff where I live... Maricopa county:

While the incidents listed above are bad enough, they don't get at the more serious problems during Arpaio's 12-year reign. Inmates continue to be killed and maimed in Arpaio's county dungeons, ranked as among the worst in the world by Amnesty International. About 9,000 people are stuffed into the county's jails, which were built to hold a maximum of 5,000 inmates.

Arpaio likes to brag that he spends more money feeding dogs and cats than he does feeding inmates. This, you see, makes him a tough guy, something voters in the past have dearly loved. There's story after story in the press featuring Arpaio boasting how he puts abused pets inside air-conditioned cells while inmates and pre-trial detainees are dangerously packed into stifling overcrowded cells, dormitories and tents.

Bolo October 12, 2007 - 12:59pm

the police involved would be in jail.

Ian Welsh October 12, 2007 - 2:27pm

EOM

Bolo October 12, 2007 - 2:52pm

Ordinary civilian crimes should never bear the death penalty, because there is no special trust invested in ordinary citizens.

But deadly crimes that constitute a grievous betrayal of the public trust, under color of authority, should cause the perpetrators to forfeit their lives-- whether the traitors be politicians or goons. They presume to make life or death decisions regarding the rest of us; they should take that responsibility most seriously, as if their very lives depended on their sound judgment. When they kill and are found to have done so wrongly, the consequences should be automatic and in kind. When they imprison someone falsely, they should be made to serve the full sentence, in the same facility. When they mistakenly invade or destroy our homes, they should make the debt good with their own property.

I am convinced that the only way the authorities can be trusted to extend the benefit of the doubt to the rest of us, is if they face the harshest consequences should they act maliciously or in error. Otherwise they can't be trusted; the results speak for themselves.

chalo October 14, 2007 - 7:52pm

Coupled with the insane and sadistic nature of U.S. Prisons and increasingly privatized databased law enforcement, coupled with database driven roundup initiatives that are taking place, there is real reason to be very fearful indeed. Operation Falcon was a true national scale exercise of the Federal Government to use all levels of police powers. What is so remarkable, was the ability of the Feds to orchestrate a national round up using a central command structure to orchestrate the operation.

What was truly amazing that the local Police, County Sheriffs, State Police, and Federalies, worked in unison to pull this off in a coordinated fashion over a few days time. Over 10,000 people rounded up in that time.

Operation FALCON

"Round-up" or "Dry Run"?

Mike Whitney concluded[45] that the true purpose of the raids was not merely to round up thousands of petty criminals but, rather, that the "Bush administration is sharpening its talons for the inevitable difficulties it expects to face as a result of its disastrous policies. With each regressive initiative, the governing cabal seems to get increasingly paranoid, anticipating an outburst of public rage. Now, they're orchestrating massive round-ups of minor crooks to make sure that every cog and gear in the apparatus of state repression is lubricated and ready to go.

"There are two types of folk music:
quiet folk music and loud folk music.
I play both."

Dave Alvin

Peter C October 12, 2007 - 3:23pm

is about the right being in control.
It is about their beliefs being in the right.
It has nothing about the truth.
I can see a revolution starting to stop our rights being denied.
It will take time, but it will happen.

repressive governments mix administrative clumsiness & inefficiency with authoritarian tendencies.

kimmy October 12, 2007 - 9:01pm

All we need to do is pay Blackwater to protect us.

Synoia October 12, 2007 - 9:16pm

Enjoy.
You are now guilty until proven innocent.
We will kill you and ask questions later.
The war on drugs is now a war.
Shoot to kill.
Answers later.
Bush is enjoying his powers.
He has executive powers on all wars.
Drugs are one small part.
Smoke a little pot, you are dead.
Bush will kill you!

repressive governments mix administrative clumsiness & inefficiency with authoritarian tendencies.

kimmy October 12, 2007 - 9:42pm

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.