Part Two: So Much Deception in a Single 30-Second McCain Ad


It can be difficult to pick which one of Republican Presidential candidate John McCain's television ads against Barack Obama contains the most lies and distortions, but I wrote about one yesterday that I think comes close. It's been running in key states for about a month and pulls out the full Karl-Rove playbook to make people think that Obama has no regard for America's troops and Veterans and that John McCain should be their hero.

In part one yesterday, we used McCain's own Senate voting record to blow away his claim that he has "always supported our troops." Today we look at the rest of what is truly an amazing feat: So much deception in one short ad.

Distortion: "He [Obama] voted against funding our troops"

Is it true in the most absolute sense when considering one vote? Yes, Obama did indeed vote against H.R. 2206. The reason was that it was yet another blank check for George W. Bush in Iraq and Obama, along with 13 other Democratic Senators were holding out for a bill that would fund the troops and eventually bring them home to their families.

There's a big difference between that and what McCain's ad implies -- especially considering all the troop-related legislation cited in part one of this report that Obama voted for and that McCain voted against.

The bottom line is that in his time in the Senate, it is Obama who has "always supported the troops" -- including the biggest support of all in trying to extricate them from the Iraq disaster -- while McCain consistently gives troops, Veterans and their families nothing but lip service and lies.

Distortion: "Barack Obama never held a single Senate hearing on Afghanistan"

Obama sits on four Senate committees and two of them could practically involve a "hearing on Afghanistan" -- the Foreign Relations and Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs Committees. The problem with this? Obama is not the chairman of either of those committees. Obama can recommend a hearing or ask for one -- and McCain has no way of knowing if he has or has not -- but it's the chair who calls committee hearings. Oddly enough, Joe Lieberman is chairman of the Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs committee so I suppose it's McCain's friend Joe who hasn’t had any such hearings.

Now, Obama is chairman of the Homeland Security European Affairs Subcommittee but that group is kind of focused on, well, Europe.

Outright Lie: Barack Obama did not visit troops while in Germany because the military would not allow him to bring cameras into the hospital.

This has already been debunked in so many places nobody even remotely believes it any longer. But I'll let Andrea Mitchell of NBC News, who was with Obama in Germany and says this nonsense is "…literally not true," handle this:

So there you have it. Between what I described yesterday and today, one tiny ad with enough lies and distortions to fill an hour-long soap opera -- except this isn't a soap opera, it's your country and your life.

No wonder the focus of the 2008 presidential race is now turning to how John McCain simply can't seem to tell the truth.

You can read more from Bob at BobGeiger.com.


Bob Geiger September 13, 2008 - 10:28am
( categories: Analysis | USA: Campaign 2008 )

McCain Barbs Stirring Outcry as Distortions

By MICHAEL COOPER and JIM RUTENBERG
Published: September 12, 2008

Harsh advertisements and negative attacks are a staple of presidential campaigns, but Senator John McCain has drawn an avalanche of criticism this week from Democrats, independent groups and even some Republicans for regularly stretching the truth in attacking Senator Barack Obama’s record and positions.

Mr. Obama has also been accused of distortions, but this week Mr. McCain has found himself under particularly heavy fire for a pair of headline-grabbing attacks. First the McCain campaign twisted Mr. Obama’s words to suggest that he had compared Gov. Sarah Palin, the Republican vice-presidential nominee, to a pig after Mr. Obama said, in questioning Mr. McCain’s claim to be the change agent in the race, “You can put lipstick on a pig; it’s still a pig. ” (Mr. McCain once used the same expression to describe Senator Hillary Rodham Clinton’s health plan.)

article

tjfxh September 13, 2008 - 12:44pm

Distortion: "He [Obama] voted against funding our troops"

Due to this kind of negative campaigning, everyone in the legislature has to second guess their votes, with an eye on to how their record might be distorted and used against them in the next election. In addition, much legislation is frivolous, designed solely to be used to attack the opposition and put opposition candidates on the spot in the next election cycle.

Talk about frivolous lawsuits tying up the courts. This frivolity ties up the nation's business and is eventually used to confuse the issues.

Corollary: McCain's promise of bipartisanship and across the aisle cooperation in a McCain/Palin administration is pretty much equivalent to Bush's in the 2000 election. Remember "the uniter?" The same BS.

The real problem is that so far the media has been complicit in this by highlighting the frivolity instead of the issues and failing to call BS immediately, first, to correct the record, and secondly, to end the cycle by making such negative campaigning more costly to one's own reputation than a help in defeating the opponent. Thankfully, the later happening to a degree with McCain, whose truthfulness and honor are now tarnished.

The real problem here is that should McCain win, his truthfulness and honor are so shot that now no one who counts at home or abroad will either believe what he says or take him at his word, and he will therefore not be able to govern the country effectively.

It took Bush a few years to reach this point. McCain is starting out there. This is the real news. Wake up, media. McCain's unbridled ambition is witlessly undercutting himself and he is already trashing his primary store of political capital, being an honorable man and a straight shooter.

tjfxh September 13, 2008 - 1:36pm

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.