Big Problems Brewing For the Federal Reserve


For economic analysis and commentary, go to the Bonddad Blog.

Two days ago, the Federal Reserve announced it would leave rates unchanged. The stock markets rallied on the news because traders interpreted the Fed's statement as implying a rate cut was more likely. Granted, there is a ton of "reading between the lines" when it comes to Fed statements (in fact, there are people who actually make a career of interpreting these statements). However, what traders failed to realize -- and what most economists did realize -- was the Federal Reserve is caught between the proverbial rock and a hard place. While the economy is obviously slowing, inflation has not.

Let's back up to late last summer when the Fed stopped raising rates. Paraphrasing most of their public statements goes something like this: As the economy slows, so will inflation. What the Fed was counting on was decreased supply and demand that naturally results from slower growth would lead to lower prices.

They have half of the situation right. GDP growth is much slower, coming in at 2%, 2.6%, and 2.2% for the 2nd - 4th quarter of 2006, respectively. Housing has the big reason as it decreased 11%, 19% and 19% in the same quarters. Right now manufacturing is hanging between expansion and contraction. Consumer spending is the one strong point of the economy, but it is slowing as well as evidence by the last few retail sales reports.

So we have slower growth. The problem is inflation is not slowing as predicted. Here is a year-over-year graph of the percent change in inflation. It comes from the blog The Mess That Greenspan made:

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Inflation is running hotter than the Fed would like. There are several problems. First, gas prices are increasing:

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

And agricultural prices are increasing as well:

Photo Sharing and Video Hosting at Photobucket

Both of these graphs indicate prices for staples -- goods we pretty much need -- are increasing. This is what makes the core price changes so important. When the Fed -- or any other economist -- is talking about core rates (rates less food and energy), one of the things they are looking to see is how price increases in food and energy are bleeding through into other prices. That's why the year-over-year changes in core inflation are so important from a policy perspective. The increases mean energy and food costs are bleeding through into other prices in a variety of ways. For example, increased energy prices means transportation costs are increasing, which means companies have to raise prices to pay for the increase. Increased food prices means eating out is more expensive, hence restaurant prices increase. You get the idea.

The Fed may have to make a very difficult choice in the coming year: choosing to lower rates -- despite inflationary pressures -- to keep the economy from moving into a recession, or to stimulate the economy out of a recession. If they do that when inflation is increasing, they run the risk of allowing inflation to get out of control. And no central banker wants that.

In other words, it really sucks being on the Fed right now.


Bonddad March 22, 2007 - 5:08pm
( categories: Economics )

The Fed made their own bed. Unfortunately, we have to sleep in it.

Ian Welsh March 22, 2007 - 5:11pm

that the Fed will continue to buy this recovery until they cannot pay for it any longer. They will pander to the markets, until the markets no longer believe them, as was the condition in the 70s.

They will buy the recovery with cheap rates, for cheap rates are holding up asset values the world round. If rates go up much, there is so much structural that will go wrong, from real estate to the value of an education, that they will not let it go wrong until they cannot stop it.

Then wrongness will be etched in caps.

http://mauberly.blogspot.com/

mauberly March 22, 2007 - 5:35pm

In over 20 years in the same business everything is positively most definitely collapsing. It does not matter one bit what they say or don't say, the reality is in how business operates, or not.

Lasthorseman March 22, 2007 - 6:21pm

somewhere in the Agonist, somebody said that between inflation and deflation, the government will choose to get out of their pickle by triggering inflation. Do you think there is some of this going on?

LJ March 22, 2007 - 6:34pm

Numerian thinks we're going into deflation and has since I have talked to him. I don't know. I believe we're caught between inflation and deflation and so long as we can avoid either we're alright. But there are forces out there that could cause us to go either way. A severe problem in the mortgage arena could cause a deflation. Oil and other commodities plus cheap money could cause inflation.

I don't think it is a foregone conclusion what will happen. Clearly it is better to pay back debt in cheaper dollars. Inflation can bring that about. But if people get the idea that that is going on, everything changes. Stocks and bonds will get hammered mercilessly.

http://mauberly.blogspot.com/

mauberly March 22, 2007 - 6:52pm

which cannot be answered yet, is whether TPTB are now actually choosing to quietly choose a weak dollar, inflationary tack hoping to tiptoe past the graveyard yet again. Playing off the inflationary vs. deflationary pressures has worked very well since the '80's. Now are they tilting toward the inflationary side of things?

I know, who is to say? But, a thought.

LJ March 22, 2007 - 7:55pm
mauberly March 22, 2007 - 8:27pm

Deflation or inflation is a choice - a bad choice, but a choice. My guess is that if forced to choose Bernanke will choose inflation.

Ian Welsh March 22, 2007 - 11:09pm

Great Failures. His economy. The reason it's taking so long to collapse is because he probably really really screwed this one up.

vwcat March 22, 2007 - 9:08pm

"Why the US sub-prime mortgage bust will spread to the global finance system"

http://henryckliu.com/page126.html

tjfxh March 22, 2007 - 9:46pm

"Through mortgage-backed securitization, banks now are mere loan intermediaries that assume no long-term risk on the risky loans they make, which are sold as securitized debt of unbundled levels of risk to institutional investors with varying risk appetite commensurate with their varying need for higher returns. But who are institutional investors? They are mostly pension funds that manage the money the US working public depends on for retirement. In other words, the aggregate retirement assets of the working public are exposed to the risk of the same working public defaulting on their house mortgages. When a homeowner loses his or her home through default of its mortgage, the homeowner will also lose his or her retirement nest egg invested in the securitized mortgage pool, while the banks stay technically solvent. That is the hidden network of linked financial landmines in a housing bubble financed by mortgage-backed securitization to which no one is paying attention. The bursting of the housing bubble will act as a detonator for a massive pension crisis."

Comments anyone? Is this true, half-true, or just paranoia?

Bolo March 23, 2007 - 12:43am

About 2/3 true. Banks may think they can pass off the risk... we'll see.

Ian Welsh March 23, 2007 - 1:40am

Numerian knows who is holding what here; I would imagine there is some reasoned and researched opinion. I have not seen any simple analysis of it.

http://mauberly.blogspot.com/

mauberly March 23, 2007 - 6:32am

Raise rates and the market tanks while bond prices drop.

Drop rates and the dollar will drop thru the floor at .80 while precious metals become the currency of last resort and major inflation takes off as foreign dollars return.

Hold steady and the RE collapse sucks liquidity out of the economy and consumer pockets.

This is the viscous flip side of the virtuous cycle they have goosed to exhaustion. There is no escape. And this time the rest of the world will curse the American devil that won't pay its bills.

Takachi99 March 22, 2007 - 10:11pm

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.