Wanted: Recommendations On Calphalon And All Clad Cookware

Q: I'm interested in purchasing high quality cookware and have narrowed my selection down to Calphalon and All Clad. As such I've yet to decide on stainless steel, stick resistant, or non-stick, regardless of the supplier. With respect to suppliers, I'm leaning toward the All Clad realtive to overall quality, performance, and reliability but have a strong dislike for the All Clad handles - they are poorly designed relative to ergonomics (I'm 6'3", 200lbs and the All Clad handles hurt my hands when picking up the larger saute pans, etc.). A friend of mine owns the Calphalon stainless and swears by it (he likes classics becasue they are classics and I wonder if he really did any comparison shopping). I'd like opinions and comments (relative but not exclusive) to the following, ideally from those who own Calphalon or All Clad ... * Why did you purhcase the brand you own? * What do you like most and least about what you're using now? * What would you do if you had to throw out what you have and buy new? * Whats better - stainless (stick?), stick-resistant, or non-stick? - do you have trouble cleaning stainless? - should one use stainless for the pans not likely to need scouring i.e. its only the saute/fry pans that would likely require scrubbing - what about reactions of the food with the non-stainless pans? - is there any problem with the non-stick coatings contaminating humans i.e. does this stuff stay on the pan and if it comes off over time will consuming it cause me any harm? * Do the handles really make the All Clad less desireable from a users' perspective (I only "test drove" the pans in the store ... what happens when one really uses them to cook)? Also, is this stuff all fair trade pricing? I never saw any of it on sale and never heard of a place to buy it at discount. Thanks, in advance,

A: I enjoy cooking with all of it, but I personally prefer stainless to anodized aluminum. I think stainless is easier to clean. I also prefer the regular cookware instead of non-stick. I can't quite put my feelings into words, but I can tell you that when selling the cookware in WS, we had *much* more non-stick left in stock after Christmas than regular. I also watch cooking shows almost constantly and have never seen a professional chef cook on non-stick cookware. My theory (and it's just a theory) is that professionals always use some sort of oil or butter when cooking, and the theory behind non-stick is that those things aren't needed. So why buy non-stick when you're going to use oil/butter anyway? And besides, good cookware allows food to cook evenly and sticking shouldn't (theoretically) be a problem. I really don't know about non-stick coatings hurting you. I don't think All Clad and Calphalon are fair trade. I bought my All Clad on sale at Bloomies. Large department stores always have different pieces on sale...WS almost never does. I think Crate & Barrel does sometimes. (Having worked at both WS and Crate & Barrel, I'm going to say this and I hope my boss at WS doesn't read it, but Crate & Barrel has better prices than WS. But don't tell anyone I said it). So, I hope I've helped you somewhat. Basically, I think people decide whether they like cooking on stainless or aluminum (anodized), then make selections based on their decision. My only definite advice is don't go out and buy a whole set of one or the other...mix and match for best results.

Discuss It!

Most Popular Articles

More

Marketplace

Related Articles

More

Related Categories

More

Recently Added

More

You Recently Visited

Other Great Sites