Israel putting forth 'unprecedented' concessions, Clinton says

Karen DeYoung and Howard Schneider | Jerusalem | Nov 1

WaPo - Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton said Saturday that Israeli Prime Minister Binyamin Netanyahu had offered "unprecedented" concessions on West Bank settlement construction in an effort to restart peace talks, a departure from the administration's earlier criticism of Israel and a possible signal of impatience with the refusal of Palestinian leaders to join negotiations.

At the start of a day of diplomacy that stretched from Abu Dhabi to Jerusalem, Palestinian leader Mahmoud Abbas rejected Israel's latest offer, relayed by Clinton, to curb most West Bank construction.

The chief Palestinian negotiator, Saeb Erekat, said the plan would have excluded about 3,000 Israeli housing units under construction and would not have applied to East Jerusalem -- thus falling well short of what has become a firm Palestinian demand for resuming direct talks with Israel.

"The U.S. said that is the best they can get" from Netanyahu, even though the Obama administration considers settlements 'illegal and illegitimate,' " Erekat said. The Palestinians will not accept a resumption of talks on that basis, he said.

Unprecedented would be Clinton expecting and demanding Israel to follow UN resolutions. The best they can get? I bet cutting defense aid might turn some heads. And this should go over real well:

AFP - Israel's premier savoured a victory on Sunday after Washington hailed his "unprecedented" position on settlements and backed his call for peace talks to resume without the construction freeze sought by the Palestinians.

"There is no question that the United States are our staunchest friends and that Israel's firm stance on its positions pays off," Deputy Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon happily told public radio on Sunday.

Speaking before the weekly cabinet meeting, Science and Technology Minister Daniel Hershkowitz proclaimed: "The US administration understands what we have always said -- that the real obstacle to negotiations are the Palestinians."

This is not good:

Palestinians expressed deep disappointment and frustration at Clinton's words, which signaled a departure from past U.S. calls for a complete freeze on settlement activity.

"If America cannot get Israel to implement a settlement freeze, what chance do Palestinians have of reaching agreement with Israel on permanent status issues?" Palestinian negotiator Saeb Erekat said.

Similar sentiments were voiced by Jordan and Egypt, the only two Arab countries to have peace agreements with Israel. The two countries said most of the blame lay with Israel, but signaled their unhappiness with the American shift.

Jordan's King Abdullah II traveled to Cairo for talks with Egyptian President Hosni Mubarak. After the meeting, a royal palace statement released in Jordan said both leaders "insisted on the need for an immediate halt of all Israeli unilateral actions, which undermine the chances of achieving peace, especially the settlement construction."

Nov 2/Reuters - The Arab League chief said Arab states shared the Palestinian position that resuming negotiations was futile without a freeze on settlement expansion.

"I am telling you that all of us, including Saudi Arabia, including Egypt, are deeply disappointed ... with the results, with the fact that Israel can get away with anything without any firm stand that this cannot be done," Moussa(Arab League Secretary-General) told reporters.

** Abbas spokesman: Netanyahu has more influence in US than in Israel
** Palestinians accuse Clinton of hurting peace talks
** Clinton: Mideast Talks Should Resume Without Preconditions
** Bibi to Palestinians: ‘Get a grip’


Tina November 1, 2009 - 10:40am




(AP) U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton ,right, and Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu react during a press conference in Jerusalem. Saturday, Oct. 31. 2009. U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton says Israel is making "unprecedented" concessions on West Bank settlement construction.The U.S. administration had previously demanded Israel halt all settlement building before negotiations could resume.But speaking at a joint press conference with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu on Saturday, Clinton said "there has never been a precondition. It has always been an issue with negotiations."(AP Photo/ Rina Castelnuovo, Pool)


I feel the American worker has been sacrificed to the capitalist idols in the ancient Mayan fashion. - Sue Lamb, NYT reader

nymole November 1, 2009 - 2:13pm

Finale of Clinton's Trip Marred by Comments

"They completely blew any good will from this initiative with the bizarre comments on settlements this weekend," said Jeremy Ben-Ami, executive director of J Street, a liberal Jewish advocacy group that supports a freeze on settlements. "Secretary Clinton had to add an extra day to her trip in the Middle East to do damage control."

"They now have the worst of all possible worlds: Arabs, Israelis and Palestinians all said no to the great power without cost or consequences." , said Aaron David Miller, who advised six secretaries of state on the Middle East .


I feel the American worker has been sacrificed to the capitalist idols in the ancient Mayan fashion. - Sue Lamb, NYT reader

nymole November 4, 2009 - 10:30am

this trip has been, I believe the bloom is off the Obama

Tina November 4, 2009 - 10:42am

On a day when Hillary Clinton, in Israel to restart peace negotiations, could claim that "what prime minister [Netanyahu] has offered in specifics on restraints on a policy of settlements is unprecedented...", the Haaretz columnist, Gideon Levy, came back with an appropriate admonishment: 'stop sucking up to Israel.'

What turns out to be Netanyahu's unprecedented offer is nothing less than the promise to continue expansion of existing settlements, like the 150 illegal villages, towns, and cities built in the West Bank and East Jerusalem as shown in the map above. Not shown are the hundred or so illegal outposts that have yet to be dismantled as promised. Hillary's statement again shows that America bends to Israel's will and it is presently this fawning stance that impedes peace, at least according to Levy.

more and map of settlements at mydd

Tina November 1, 2009 - 2:45pm

That you really can preen- it's been done already , they pay people for reading blogs!


I feel the American worker has been sacrificed to the capitalist idols in the ancient Mayan fashion. - Sue Lamb, NYT reader

nymole November 1, 2009 - 6:04pm

(and had trusted her) he might have created an uber-Secretary of everything but State and Defense and put her "I'm not a quitter" ethic to work. Oh well.....


I feel the American worker has been sacrificed to the capitalist idols in the ancient Mayan fashion. - Sue Lamb, NYT reader

nymole November 1, 2009 - 6:11pm

NYT (op-ed)[snips] -
According to media reports, the president’s advisers are searching for ways of reassuring Israel’s public of President Obama’s friendship and unqualified commitment to Israel’s security...

The White House is about to set a new record in the number of reassuring messages and video greetings sent by an American president to Israel, as well as to Jewish organizations in the United States, on this subject. Plans for a presidential visit to Jerusalem are under discussion.

Presidential aides worry that the hostility toward President Obama among Israelis can be damaging to his peace efforts. This is undoubtedly true.

Israelis do not oppose President Obama’s peace efforts because they dislike him; they dislike him because of his peace efforts. He will regain their affection only when he abandons these efforts.

I imagine this last paragraph is intended to and may get more than a few comments on nytimes.com. Complete piece at the link


I feel the American worker has been sacrificed to the capitalist idols in the ancient Mayan fashion. - Sue Lamb, NYT reader

nymole November 2, 2009 - 12:04am

Repeat after me:

"If voting changed anything, they'd make it illegal."
Again--
"If voting changed anything, they'd make it illegal."
Again--
"If voting changed anything they'd make it illegal."

What has to happen to allow this idea to sink in? Changes around the edges while the fundamental things remain as before is not a justification for continued support. Banker lobby AIPAC, beggar man, thief, doctor, lawyer, Taft and Hartley are the chiefs of this little tribe. There's plutonium seeping out of Los Alamos and all's well. We take picnics there several times a summer...

David Westling November 2, 2009 - 2:30am

... are belong to US!

The most unethical dimension of this, well, a leading contender, if the US is caving on 3000 settlements and East Jerusalem generally, all those Palestinian refugees entitled to finally get resettled in the same West Bank & Jerusalem areas.

Because that moral claim is of course Hillary's to give away. Both jolly hill & jolly bibi can agree -- in that marvelous photo above.

--
Hongpong.com

HongPong November 2, 2009 - 4:17am

...we'll dam the Jordan and you'll have the Dead Sea for your water....

suck on *that*!!

Clinton's doing what her husband did for 8 years---nothing at all

-5.75,-4.05
"God gives men a brain and a penis, and only enough blood to run one at a time." -- Robin Williams

justadood November 2, 2009 - 11:50am


"We're all of us children in a vast kindergarten trying to spell God's name with the wrong alphabet blocks." ~ Edwin Arlington Robinson

Celsius 233 November 2, 2009 - 9:02am

gagging...

Clinton backs Israel on settlements stance

Agreement would allow settlers to finish 3,000 houses plus public buildings

By Ben Lynfield in Jerusalem

Monday, 2 November 2009

Palestinian leaders angrily accused Hillary Clinton of undercutting Middle East peace prospects yesterday after she endorsed Israel's plans to continue expanding West Bank settlements

The US Secretary of State for the first time voiced support for Israel's argument that since a freeze on settlement construction had not been a precondition for previous peace talks, it should not be one during the negotiations the US is now trying to convene.

Instead of a freeze, Mrs Clinton urged the Palestinians to accept what she termed an "unprecedented" Israeli offer of "restraint" in settlement construction and to go to the negotiating table as soon as possible without preconditions. "What the Prime Minister [Israel's Benjamin Netanyahu] has offered in specifics on restraints on a policy of settlements is unprecedented," she said in a clear departure from the Obama administration's former position that there needed to be a total freeze. Mrs Clinton was speaking during a joint appearance with Mr Netanyahu. He said that his government would conduct a policy of "restraint" while at the same time enabling "normal life" for the settlers.

more

Tina November 2, 2009 - 11:37am

As soon as someone can explain to me what strategic purpose our relationship serves, i might start believing a small slice of the spin.

We already have 13 aircraft carriers, and Israel doesn't even float. As far as i can see, our relationship actually hurts our interests. It certainly doesn't win us any friends in Islamic countries.

Nor do i buy that we do anything much to restrain Israel. Not restraining Israel would just hasten its slide into an international pariah.

But i don't have any issue with Israel's existence; what i cannot fathom is how willing we are to let the neozionist Likudniks appear as the whole of Israel.

Finally, i think Clinton gives Rice a run for the "Worst Secretary of State" in a long time award. Stupid, stupid, stupid giving the post to a domestic politician with her record if there was any hope of movement on this issue.

Lex November 2, 2009 - 4:19pm

Was it Clinton's poor choices of words or is she going to take the hit for an Obama misstep?

Clinton backtracks on Israeli settlements after Arab anger

David Usborne | November 3

The Independent - Hillary Clinton, the US Secretary of State, was forced into an awkward diplomatic pirouette yesterday, insisting to Arab foreign ministers that Washington had not capitulated to Israel's continuing hunger for new Jewish settlements even if statements she had made 24 hours earlier seemed to imply exactly that.

Arab anger had flared after Mrs Clinton departed from the script of President Barack Obama at the weekend, suggesting that the Palestinians should agree to resume peace talks without preconditions, including that Israel first stop all settlement construction in the West Bank. She appeared to endorse the offer by the Prime Minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, to institute merely a limited suspension of construction in some areas.

While not backtracking entirely, Mrs Clinton attempted in Morocco last night to massage those remarks. Saying that Israel had expressed to her "a willingness to restrain settlement activity," she added: "This offer falls far short of what our preference would be, but if it is acted upon, it will be an unprecedented restriction on settlements and would have a significant and meaningful effect on restraining their growth."

Mrs Clinton, who travelled from Israel to meetings in Marrakesh, also offered fulsome praise to the Palestinian President, Mahmoud Abbas, for taking steps to meet Israel's demands, notably for increased security, and said that "Israel should reciprocate".

Fears are growing on the Arab side that Washington is going soft on Israel out of an overwhelming desire to get talks started again. In the summer, Mr Obama plainly demanded that Israel cease all settlement construction to allow peace talks to go forward.

Mrs Clinton's words, spoken while in Israel on Sunday, prompted a particularly stark warning in Marrakesh from Amr Moussa, secretary general of the Arab League. "I am telling you that all of us, including Saudi Arabia, including Egypt, are deeply disappointed ... with the fact that Israel can get away with anything without any firm stand that this cannot be done," he said. "The Palestinians say that a viable state for their people will not be possible with more settlements."

Tina November 3, 2009 - 2:00am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.