UK wanted US to rule out Bin Laden torture

Richard Norton-Taylor | July 28

The Guardian - Ministers insisted that British secret agents would only be allowed to pass intelligence to the CIA to help it capture Osama bin Laden if the agency promised he would not be tortured, it has emerged.

MI6 believed it was close to finding the al-Qaida leader in Afghanistan in 1998, and again the next year. The plan was for MI6 to hand the CIA vital information about Bin Laden. Ministers including Robin Cook, the then foreign secretary, gave their approval on condition that the CIA gave assurances he would be treated humanely. The plot is revealed in a 75-page report by parliament's intelligence and security committee on rendition, the practice of flying detainees to places where they may be tortured.

The report criticises the Bush administration's approval of practices which would be illegal if carried out by British agents. It shows that in 1998, the year Bin Laden was indicted in the US, Britain insisted that the policy of treating prisoners humanely should include him. But the CIA never gave the assurances.

Read the report.


Tina July 28, 2007 - 6:28am

Bush II wasn't appointed president until 2000.This time line makes it appear that MI6 knew of CIA torture in 1998.Or am I missing something?

PR July 28, 2007 - 11:23am

...of a possible extraordinary rendition, though it's far from clear where they would have rendered him to - the Saudis stripped ObL of his citizenship in 1994 - Egypt might be one possibility, given the centrality of EIJ members to the organization.

"When intelligence producers realize that there is no sense in forwarding to a consumer knowledge which does not correspond to his preconceptions, then intelligence is through." ~ Sherman Kent

JustPlainDave July 28, 2007 - 11:29am

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.