How Internet monitoring sparked a CSIS investigation into a suspected homegrown terror cell

Michelle Shephard | Toronto | June 3

The Toronto Star - Last night's dramatic police raid and arrest of as many as a dozen men — with more to come — marks the culmination of Canada's largest ever terrorism investigation into an alleged homegrown cell.

The chain of events began two years ago, sparked by local teenagers roving through Internet sites, reading and espousing anti-Western sentiments and vowing to attack at home, in the name of oppressed Muslims here and abroad.

Their words were sometimes encrypted, the Internet sites where they communicated allegedly restricted by passwords, but Canadian spies back in 2004 were reading them. And as the youths' words turned into actions, they began watching them.

According to sources close to the investigation, the suspects are teenagers and men in their 20s who had a relatively typical Canadian upbringing, but — allegedly spurred on by images of conflict in Iraq and Afghanistan and angered by what they saw as the mistreatment of Muslims at home — became increasingly violent.

[more at link]

[Comment: I'm looking forward to this being swept up into partisan debate expressed in terms of American domestic politics about as much as I look forward to root canal work. ~ JPD]

"We declared war on terror, it's not even a noun, so, good luck. After we defeat it, I'm sure we'll take on that bastard ennui." - Jon Stewart.

where did they do anything other than participate in Internet sites and make a movie?

They have made no overt threat??? Jeez, this is not as if they have been caught red-handed planting bombs or actually doing a terrorist activity? Is it a crime to 'think' of terrorist-type activity? Where are their bombs, their guns, their WMD? Apparently, two of them did have some type of revolvers? Criminals have hand guns ... that doesn't make them terrorists!

Strikes me the guilty parties are the CSIS, the RCMP and the police for spying on them! This is much worse than McCarthyism, because it isn't isolated to one person motivated by selfish career ambitions spearheading attacks on groups of people calling them commies. It's our government using the weight of its combined forces and all its resources to prosecute its own citizens labelling them terrorists.

I await to hear what the evidence is for the case that will be announced later this morning. Much of the case is dependent on US authorities who should have all their marbles in place in order for the Canadian police to make the arrests and place the charges against these alleged Canadian terrorists.

but thank God criminal charges are being laid. At least proof will have to be produced they are guilty as charged.

It will be an interesting trial, because it may reveal the extent of the spying the CSIS, the RCMP and the police have used in order to produce their evidence.

How many innocent Canadians have been indiscriminately spied upon that haven't resulted in charges? Is Big Brother Canuck spying on me now as I type this? :-(

I await to hear what the actual charges are and the relevant criminal code #'s that were allegedly broken. Thanks for the link to the new terrorist laws that probably are relevant. The preamble, "includes a conspiracy" is distasteful, unless it is connected to an actual threat that is imminent and presents a clear danger to the public or individuals within/without our borders.

on the Toronto Star's website. They are:

1. Fahim Ahmad, 21, Toronto;
2. Zakaria Amara, 20, Mississauga, Ont.;
3. Asad Ansari, 21, Mississauga;
4. Shareef Abdelhaleen, 30, Mississauga;
5. Qayyum Abdul Jamal, 43, Mississauga;
6. Mohammed Dirie, 22, Kingston, Ont.;
7. Yasim Abdi Mohamed, 24, Kingston;
8. Jahmaal James, 23, Toronto;
9. Amin Mohamed Durrani, 19, Toronto;
10. Steven Vikash Chand alias Abdul Shakur, 25, Toronto;
11. Ahmad Mustafa Ghany, 21, Mississauga;
12. Saad Khalid, 19, of Eclipse Avenue, Mississauga.

I speculate the twelve names are Musllim?

The list of the 12 adults were named in my previuos post. Also charged were five youths, who cannot be named.

----

You could be right Escher Sketch, they could be Scots ... I took a wild guess they were Muslims. :-)

Jun. 4, 2006
THOMAS WALKOM, NATIONAL COLUMNIST

Suppose, just suppose, that one or more of the 17 charged yesterday with terrorism is innocent.

This is not the common assumption. I suspect most Canadians assume that Ontario was in great danger from terrorists, that police nipped this danger in the bud and that all of the 12 adults and five young people they arrested are guilty.

All of which may be true. Terrorists do exist. There is the terror we don't think about, committed by nation states under the rubric of security sweeps or targeted reprisals. And there is the terror we do think about, the terrorism of misguided individuals, loons, right-wing militias or Al Qaeda and its Islamist acolytes.

Militant Islamists have committed outrages in the United States, Indonesia, Spain and Britain to counter what they see as the crimes of these countries against Muslims. There is no obvious reason to assume that similar criminals won't try the same thing here.

All of which is to say that the Mounties may be absolutely correct when they say they stopped the 17 from using homemade detonators and three tonnes of fertilizer to blow up as yet unspecified targets in southern Ontario.

There may indeed have been a terrorist conspiracy that involved what the RCMP assistant commissioner Mike McDonell yesterday referred to as "training areas," where militants tramped about in big boots, cooked on outdoor barbecues, built bombs and used a wooden door for target practice.

That's the implication from the evidence shown to reporters yesterday: five pairs of boots in camouflage drab, six flashlights, one set of walkie-talkies, one voltmeter, one knife, eight D-cell batteries, a cellphone, a circuit board, a computer hard drive, one barbecue grill, one set of tongs suitable for turning hot dogs, a wooden door with 21 marks on it and a 9-mm handgun.

Or it is possible that the only thing that these bits of evidence prove is that a group of young men went somewhere where they tramped around in big boots, cooked on barbecues, played soldier and generally acted like jerks — which young men are occasionally wont to do.

The three tonnes of ammonium nitrate allegedly purchased was, as McDonell said, three times the amount used in the Oklahoma terror bombing of 1995.

But, as he also said, farmers routinely buy three tonnes of ammonium nitrate "every day." They use it for fertilizer, not bombs.

In short, we don't know much yet about what these men and boys were trying to do. We don't know if this series of arrests, called Operation O-Sage by the Mounties, pre-empted the kind of actions that in the United Kingdom led to last year's bombing of the London subway by otherwise unremarkable young Britons.

That's one possibility. It's certainly the explanation favoured by Prime Minister Stephen Harper, who yesterday praised the police.

Another is that this is a reprise of the infamous 2003 Project Thread fiasco, in which RCMP and immigration officials accused 23 Muslims of terrorism only to acknowledge later that at most the men were guilty of minor immigration fraud.

Still another possibility is that this may turn out to be Canada's version of the 2004 Virginia "paintball" trial, in which one man was sentenced to life and another got 85 years.

In that controversial case (even the presiding judge complained the outcome was unfair), nine Muslim men were convicted of participating in terrorist training — the main evidence being that they had played paintball in the woods outside Washington.

What we do know about Operation O-Sage is that the RCMP, as well as the Canadian Security Intelligence Service, have been tracking the suspects since 2004. We also know that at least some of their neighbours knew police were watching them. Presumably, some of the suspects did, too.

If the alleged conspirators knew they were under surveillance, it seems odd that they continued along merrily with plans to make explosives.

But perhaps they are not bright terrorists. Or perhaps they are not terrorists at all.

With luck, we will get these answers at trial. This time at least, Canada has chosen to deal with alleged terrorists in the proper way, by charging them with criminal offences and allowing the case to come to court — in Canada.

For too long, the government's preferred option was to let others handle our problems. In 2002, CSIS agents escorted alleged Canadian terrorist Mohamed Mansour Jabarah across the border so he could be arrested by the FBI and convicted in a secret trial. Later that year, the RCMP co-operated with the Americans to have them arrest Canadian suspect Maher Arar in New York (he was later transferred to Syria to be tortured).

Five other alleged terrorists are simply being detained without charge under Canada's very elastic immigration act until they can be deported.

So, in this context, the 2004 decision to charge Canadian Mohammad Momin Khawaja for terrorism and yesterday's unrelated decision to charge the 17 are welcome. At least the accused aren't being sent to Syria.

During the next few days, much will be written and broadcast on the 17. Their lives will be re-examined through the prism of the arrests as reporters try to retrace the steps that allegedly led them to violent jihad. Unnamed security sources will leak details designed to bolster the police case. Families and friends will proclaim the innocence of those charged.

Take it all with a grain of salt. We know that police arrested people. We know they seized some materials — all legal — that can be used to make explosives. So far, we don't know much else.

Toronto Star

Bomb-making material delivered in police sting

Michelle Shephard and Isabel Teotonio | Toronto | June 4

The Toronto Star - The delivery of three tonnes of ammonium nitrate to a group suspected of plotting terrorist attacks in southern Ontario was part of an undercover police sting operation, the Toronto Star has learned.

The RCMP said yesterday that after investigating the alleged homegrown terrorist cell for months, they had to move quickly Friday night to arrest 12 men and five youths before the group could launch a bomb attack on Canadian soil.

Sources say investigators who had learned of the group's alleged plan to build a bomb were controlling the sale and transport of the massive amount of fertilizer, a key component in creating explosives. Once the deal was done, the RCMP-led anti-terrorism task force moved in for the arrests.

[more at link]

[So I wonder, says I, how long it'll be before the allegations of entraptment begin to propagate, wrapped up in the "Harper as son of Bush" meme. I'm guessing not long - you say cynical, I say realist. ~ JPD]

"We declared war on terror, it's not even a noun, so, good luck. After we defeat it, I'm sure we'll take on that bastard ennui." - Jon Stewart.

...that these guys were very difficult to distinguish from "other youth".

The ties that bind 17 suspects?

ANALYSIS | `They represent the broad strata of our community,' the RCMP says.

Surya Bhattacharya, Nasreen Gulamhusein & Heba Aly | Toronto | June 4

The Toronto Star - In investigators' offices, an intricate graph plotting the links between the 17 men and teens charged with being members of a homegrown terrorist cell covers at least one wall. And still, says a source, it is difficult to find a common denominator.

Some of the students, who cannot be named because they are not yet 18 and their identities are protected by Canadian law, attended the same high school.

The suspects are mainly teens and men in their young 20s, with the exception of 43-year-old Qayyum Abdul Jamal, a bus driver and recognized figure at a Mississauga Islamic centre.

[snip]

RCMP Assistant Commissioner Mike McDonell said yesterday the suspects are all Canadian residents and the majority are citizens. "They represent the broad strata of our community. Some are students, some are employed, some are unemployed," he said.

"Some are actually recruited. Going out and looking for marginalized youth, if we can call it that, and other ones it's common association within a community." As police briefed the media, families, friends and neighbours told stories of the men they believe are wrongly accused.

[more at link above - detailed profiles can be found here]

[Comment: Once again the Star shows its newsroom depth - there's one heck of a lot of stories on this. ~ JPD]

"We declared war on terror, it's not even a noun, so, good luck. After we defeat it, I'm sure we'll take on that bastard ennui." - Jon Stewart.

MUSLIM REACTION | Few surprised by arrests, but leaders say more must be done to prevent involvement with extreme ideologies

Madhavi Acharya-Tom Yew | June 4 | Toronto

The Toronto Star - Members of the Muslim community expressed shock and sadness — but not surprise — at the arrest of 17 people from the GTA who have been charged with terror-related offences.

Though some leaders worry that Muslims may feel the sting of backlash, others say the community must do more to fight extremist views within its own mosques.

Investigators made a point of saying yesterday that the arrests are not an indictment of any particular faith or national group. Muslim leaders also said they hope Canadians will remember that those charged are innocent until proven guilty, and that those who hold to violent and extreme religious views are a tiny fraction of the approximately 750,000 Muslims who call this country home.

[snip]

"There was a documented increase in hate crimes against Muslims in Canada following the Sept. 11 attacks. Community members also say they suffered incidents of verbal abuse after the transit bombings in Spain and London, Elmasry said. "We're expecting the same after this news."

He added, "The accused are innocent until proven guilty. We hope the media will not find the community guilty by association."

"We declared war on terror, it's not even a noun, so, good luck. After we defeat it, I'm sure we'll take on that bastard ennui." - Jon Stewart.

By BETH DUFF-BROWN and ROB GILLIES
The Associated Press
Sunday, June 4, 2006

TORONTO -- Canadian authorities decided to move quickly against a suspected homegrown terror ring and head off any attack on Ontario targets after undercover Mounties delivered bomb-making materials in a sting operation, according to a news report Sunday.

The Toronto Star said the Royal Canadian Mounted Police itself delivered the three tons of ammonium nitrate that authorities reported Saturday had been acquired by a group of Muslims apparently inspired by al-Qaida.

Once the deal was done, police moved in for the arrests, the Star said. It added that investigators had learned of the group's alleged plan to build a bomb and then controlled the sale and transport of the fertilizer.

It wasn't clear how the sting sale developed, and there was no indication of whether police might have altered the fertilizer to make it unusable in a bomb.

Authorities refused to discuss the Star's story. They have revealed few details of the purported plot, news of which was followed by vandalism against at least one mosque and e-mailed threats to Muslim leaders.

Police officers are saying privately that Web surfing and e-mail among the suspects initially led to the investigation beginning in 2004, something that Canada's ambassador in Washington, Michael Wilson, alluded to in an interview with CNN's "Late Edition."

"My understanding of it is that the Internet played a very important part of it. Whether there was a direct inspiration or an indirect inspiration, the Internet was, according to the police, was a very important part of their activities," Wilson said.

Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said the Canadian operation was "obviously a great success for the Canadians. They're to be congratulated for it."

Police arrested 12 adults, ages 19 to 43, and five suspects younger than 18 Friday and Saturday on terrorism charges, including plotting attacks with explosives on Canadian targets. The suspects were citizens or residents of Canada, and police said they had trained together.

Cpl. Michele Paradis, a spokeswoman for the Mounties, disagreed with a government official who said privately that more arrests might be made this week.

"Not right now," she said. "Once we once analyze and sort through everything that was seized as a result there may be. At this point we are confident that we have the majority of people."

The 17 suspects represent a broad spectrum of Canadian society, from the unemployed to the the college educated. The 12 adults live in Toronto, Mississauga and Kingston, Ontario. The five youths cannot be identified under Canadian law.

more from the Washington Post

-----

Mounties delivered the 3 tons of explosives to the suspects??? :-)

Has anyone seen the Toronto Star article this Washington Post article refers to that makes the claim? It's not on the Star's site. I can't imagine the Washington Post making such an allegation unless they checked their information very carefully. They are a very reputable source of news. There is no story like this in the Canadian press that I can find.

So, the defendants' lawyer (s) will contend the sting amounted to entrapment by the RCMP?

The RCMP now has lost quite a bit of their credibility for this case by not including this fact in the release of the initial story that has been reported widely in the Canadian press IMHO.

In the article, Secretary of State Condoleeza Rice has categorically denied these defendants can be linked with the counterparts in the United States. "We certainly don't believe that there's any link to the United States, but obviously we will follow up," Rice said on CBS's "Face the Nation," noting the investigation was continuing.

----

So much for these alleged Canadian terrorists being international in scope. Their lawyer (s) if he/she is smart will have already taped Ms. Rice making that statement and replay it in court as part of their defense.

-----

How odd? Now the link from the Washington Post doesn't bring up the same story? Should have posted the whole thing--now the story that I posted is lost except for what I cut and pasted. :-( But the one about the RCMP delivering the fertilizer to the suspects is now on the Star's website. See story that follows this one. No idea what happened and why it is the Washington Post no longer has this particular story on their website.

Massive sweep | Investigators controlled the sale and transport of three tonnes of ammonium nitrate in an undercover probe of an alleged homegrown terrorist cell
Police say they moved in quickly to avert attacks in southern Ontario
Jun. 4, 2006
MICHELLE SHEPHARD AND ISABEL TEOTONIO
STAFF REPORTERS

The delivery of three tonnes of ammonium nitrate to a group suspected of plotting terrorist attacks in southern Ontario was part of an undercover police sting operation, the Toronto Star has learned.

The RCMP said yesterday that after investigating the alleged homegrown terrorist cell for months, they had to move quickly Friday night to arrest 12 men and five youths before the group could launch a bomb attack on Canadian soil.

Sources say investigators who had learned of the group's alleged plan to build a bomb were controlling the sale and transport of the massive amount of fertilizer, a key component in creating explosives. Once the deal was done, the RCMP-led anti-terrorism task force moved in for the arrests.

At a news conference yesterday morning, the RCMP displayed a sample of ammonium nitrate and a crude cell phone detonator they say was seized in the massive police sweep when the 17 were taken into custody. However, they made no mention of the police force's involvement in the sale.

"It was their intent to use it for a terrorist attack," said RCMP assistant commissioner Mike McDonell. "If I can put this in context for you, the 1995 bombing of the Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City that killed 168 people was completed with only one tonne of ammonium nitrate."

Ammonium nitrate is a popular fertilizer, but when mixed with fuel oil it can create a powerful explosive.

Standing behind McDonell were the chiefs of police from Toronto and Durham, York and Peel regions, as well as officials with the Ontario Provincial Police and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service — representing about 400 people involved with the investigation of the group.

"This group posed a real and serious threat," said McDonell, speaking near a table with seized evidence such as a 9-mm Luger handgun, military fatigues and two-way radios. "It had the capacity and intent to carry out these acts."

The suspects were allegedly planning to launch attacks in southern Ontario, but officials would not specify targets. Nor would they say if attacks were considered imminent.

However, they did say the TTC was not a target. Sources told the Star that the Toronto headquarters of Canada's spy agency on Front St., adjacent to the CN Tower, was on the group's alleged list.

The names of the 12 adult suspects now in custody were made public yesterday, but identities of the youths under the age of 18 cannot be released, according to Canadian laws protecting minors. Of the adults, six are from Mississauga; four from Toronto and two were already incarcerated in Kingston on gun smuggling charges.

The charges laid against the men included participating in or contributing to the activity of a terrorist group, including training and recruitment; providing or making available property for terrorist purposes; and the commission of indictable offences, including firearms and explosives offences for the benefit of or in association with a terrorist group.

Charged are Fahim Ahmad, 21; Jahmaal James, 23; Amin Mohamed Durrani, 19; and Steven Vikash Chand, 25, all of Toronto; Zakaria Amara, 20; Asad Ansari, 21; Shareef Abdelhaleen, 30; Ahmad Mustafa Ghany, 21; Saad Khalid, 19; and Qayyum Abdul Jamal, 43, all of Mississauga; and Mohammed Dirie, 22 and Yasin Abdi Mohamed, 24, who are incarcerated in Kingston.

As officials spoke with reporters, the suspects were being loaded into unmarked vehicles at the Ajax-Pickering police station, where they had spent the night. Wearing leg irons and handcuffs, they were taken to a Brampton courtroom in groups of between two and six to appear before a justice of the peace.

Anser Farooq, a lawyer who represents five of the accused, pointed at snipers on the roof of the courthouse and said: "This is ridiculous. They've got soldiers here with guns. This is going to completely change the atmosphere.

"I think (the police) cast their net far too wide," he said, adding his clients are considering suing law enforcement agencies.

The father of one accused, Mohammed Abdelhaleen, spoke outside the courthouse after his son's appearance, saying there is "no validation" to any of the charges against any of the suspects.

"I have no idea what this is," said the distraught father. "I'm sure it's going to come to nothing. We're playing a political game here. I hope the judicial system realizes this."

With quivering lips, the father said he was in "a very bad place right now. The damage is already done."

Around the same time, Karl Nickner of the Canadian Council on American-Islamic Relations issued a statement that he is confident "the justice system will accord these individuals transparency, due process and the presumption of innocence."

"We stand behind our security forces and the Canadian government in their desire to protect Canada," said the executive director. "As Canadian Muslims, we unequivocally condemn terrorism in all of its forms."

It's still unclear how the group of suspects is connected and police yesterday offered few details of its alleged activities. But sources close to the investigation told the Star that the investigation began in2004 when CSIS began monitoring fundamentalist Internet sites and their users.

They later began monitoring a group of young men, and the RCMP launched a criminal investigation. Police allege the group later picked targets and plotted attacks.

Last winter some members of the group, including the teenagers, went to a field north of the city, where they allegedly trained for an attack and made a video imitating warfare.

Sources said some of the younger members forged letters about a bogus school trip to give to their parents so they could attend.

Police said there were no known connections to Al Qaeda or international terrorist organizations, but that the group was homegrown, meaning the suspects were Canadian citizens, or long-time residents and had allegedly become radicalized here.

This type of extremism was blamed for the suicide attacks in London last July which claimed the lives of 52 commuters travelling on the subway and a double-decker bus.

"They appear to have become adherents of a violent ideology inspired by Al Qaeda," said Luc Portelance of CSIS, adding there is no direct link to the network.

John Thompson of the Mackenzie Institute said he has long warned officials about the possibility of homegrown terrorists and what he dubbed the "jihad generation."

"There's been a focus on (recruiting) younger Muslims, especially those who were mostly raised here," said Thompson, who is director of the Toronto-based think tank.

Recruiters, or "ideological conditioners," he said, have been actively seeking members in Toronto-area mosques, community centres and schools since 2002.

Officials have not linked the suspects to terror cells abroad, but Portelance was quick to point out the investigation is ongoing.

Sources say the cases of two men from Georgia, now in custody in the U.S. facing terrorism charges, are connected to alleged members of the Canadian group.

Yesterday, officials offered few details about the suspects or how they met, saying only they come from a "variety of backgrounds" and represented a broad strata, including students, the employed and unemployed.

"It is important to know that this operation in no way reflects negatively on any specific community or ethnocultural group in Canada," said Portelance. "Terrorism is a dangerous ideology, and a global phenomenon. ... Canada is not immune from this ideology."

When asked why Canadians would want to attack targets in Canada, Portelance said: "Clearly, they're motivated by some of the things we see around the world," he said.

"They're against the Western influences in Islamic countries and have an adherence to violence to reach a political objective. But as far as the specific motivators, I think they probably change from individual to individual."

Speaking in Ottawa at an enrolment ceremony for 225 new Canadian military recruits, Prime Minister Stephen Harper offered his views.

"As at other times in our history, we are a target because of who we are and how we live, our society, our diversity and our values — values such as freedom, democracy and the rule of law — the values that make Canada great, values that Canadians cherish."

Toronto Star

The FT gets up on its hind legs on "Canada" - nymole

Financial Times - Saturday morning was probably not the best time for the Federation of Canadian Municipalities to urge the US to slow the implementation of tighter border controls on travellers from Canada.

The chances of Washington heeding that call – already low – had been diminished a few hours earlier when Canadian police arrested 17 people on suspicion of plotting a series of terror attacks against targets in heavily populated southern Ontario.

The arrests, one of the biggest anti-terrorism operations in north America since the terror attacks of September 2001, are likely to fan debate in Canada on several other emotive issues, notably immigration and the presence of 2,000 Canadian troops in Afghanistan.

Friday’s operation is also sure to provoke closer public scrutiny of the country’s rapidly growing Muslim community. While the men arrested on Friday were Canadian residents, several were immigrants from countries as diverse as Egypt, Somalia and Trinidad.

In line with a generally tolerant attitude towards immigrants, Canadian Muslims have until now faced little of the backlash that has followed attacks in the US and Europe.

“It’s a wake-up call to the Canadian state and the Muslim community, because it’s a reflection of failure on all our parts,” Tarek Fatah, communications director for the Muslim Canadian Congress, told the Canadian Broadcasting Corporation.

Toronto’s mayor, David Miller, added that “we need to do some work to find out how people would be sucked into this kind of activity”.

Police alleged the arrested men were arranging delivery of three tonnes of ammonium nitrate and enough other bomb-making equipment to blow up several large buildings. Ammonium nitrate, normally used as fertiliser, can be turned into a crude bomb.

The Toronto Star reported on Sunday that the ammonium was supplied by the authorities as part of a “sting” operation.

The police refused to identify the group’s intended targets, but said they were all in Canada. Local media reports have mentioned Toronto’s landmark CN Tower, offices of the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS), and the parliament buildings in Ottawa

The men, including five under 18, have been charged under an anti-terror law passed in late 2001.

The law has so far been used against only one person, Mohammad Momin Khawaja, an Ottawa software specialist, who is awaiting trial for alleged connections to a UK terror group. Several other people are being held without charge in Canada.

US officials have been concerned for some time that Canada’s relatively relaxed immigration and asylum rules could make it a staging ground for terror groups.

An Algerian-born man, Ahmed Ressam, is serving a 22-year sentence in the US for planning to detonate a suitcase bomb at Los Angeles International Airport during millennium celebrations in 1999. Mr Ressam was detained when he entered Washington state from Canada in a car containing explosives and timing devices.

Mr Fatah said that several of those arrested on Friday attended a small mosque in Mississauga, a Toronto suburb. The oldest member of the group, Qayyum Abdul Jamal, 43, was the mosque’s imam. CSIS said that the men were followers of a “violent ideology inspired by al-Qaeda”.

Large numbers of immigrants, especially from south Asia, have moved into the Toronto area over the past decade. Most have been allowed to enter Canada under a controversial family reunification provision.

The Liberal party, which formed the government from 1993 until earlier this year, has built a strong constituency in these communities.

The new minority Conservative government has retreated from earlier plans to tighten immigration laws. The prime minister, Stephen Harper, said on Saturday that “we are a target because of who we are and how we live”. But pressure is sure to increase on the government to make Canada a less welcoming target after the weekend’s events.

_{"at some point I'm hopeful I'll figure out something to put here"}

Reuters is reporting...

TORONTO (Reuters) - Vandals smashed windows of a Toronto mosque after a weekend police sweep that netted 17 suspected al Qaeda sympathisers accused of plotting bomb attacks, and Canadian Muslims expressed fear on Sunday that a backlash had begun.

"Numerous windows were smashed" at the mosque either late Saturday or early on Sunday and the incident was being investigated, a police official said in an interview.

A second official said he had no information on whether there was a link between the vandalism and the arrests.

Mohammad Alam, the president Islamic Foundation of Toronto, said the incident may be the beginning of religiously motivated reprisals against the country's Muslim population, estimated at more than 600,000.

Canadian Police Moved in on Terror Suspects After Sting Delivery of Bomb Materials, News Report Says

By BETH DUFF-BROWN and ROB GILLIES

TORONTO Jun 4, 2006 (AP)— Canadian authorities decided to move quickly against a suspected homegrown terror ring and head off any attack on Ontario targets after undercover Mounties delivered bomb-making materials in a sting operation, according to a news report Sunday.

The Toronto Star said the Royal Canadian Mounted Police itself delivered the three tons of ammonium nitrate that authorities reported Saturday had been acquired by a group of Muslims apparently inspired by al-Qaida.

Once the deal was done, police moved in for the arrests, the Star said. It added that investigators had learned of the group's alleged plan to build a bomb and then controlled the sale and transport of the fertilizer.

It wasn't clear how the sting sale developed, and there was no indication of whether police might have altered the fertilizer to make it unusable in a bomb.

Authorities refused to discuss the Star's story. They have revealed few details of the purported plot, news of which was followed by vandalism against at least one mosque and e-mailed threats to Muslim leaders.

Police officers are saying privately that Web surfing and e-mail among the suspects initially led to the investigation beginning in 2004, something that Canada's ambassador in Washington, Michael Wilson, alluded to in an interview with CNN's "Late Edition."

"My understanding of it is that the Internet played a very important part of it. Whether there was a direct inspiration or an indirect inspiration, the Internet was, according to the police, was a very important part of their activities," Wilson said.

Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice said the Canadian operation was "obviously a great success for the Canadians. They're to be congratulated for it."

Police arrested 12 adults, ages 19 to 43, and five suspects younger than 18 Friday and Saturday on terrorism charges, including plotting attacks with explosives on Canadian targets. The suspects were citizens or residents of Canada, and police said they had trained together.

Cpl. Michele Paradis, a spokeswoman for the Mounties, disagreed with a government official who said privately that more arrests might be made this week.

"Not right now," she said. "Once we once analyze and sort through everything that was seized as a result there may be. At this point we are confident that we have the majority of people."

The 17 suspects represent a broad spectrum of Canadian society, from the unemployed to the the college educated. The 12 adults live in Toronto, Mississauga and Kingston, Ontario. The five youths cannot be identified under Canadian law.

Rocco Galati, a lawyer, said he represented two of the men from Mississauga, an immigrant-rich town just east of Toronto.

He described Ahmad Ghany, 21, as a health sciences graduate of McMaster University who was born in Canada. Ghany's father is a physician who emigrated from Trinidad and Tobago in 1955, Galati said.

His other client, Shareef Abdelhaleen, 30, is an unmarried computer programmer of Egyptian descent, Galati said. He emigrated from Egypt at age 10 with his father, who is an engineer on contract with Atomic Energy of Canada Ltd., a private that firm provides services to nuclear utilities in Canada and other countries.

"Both of their families are very well-established professionals, well-established families, no criminal pasts whatsoever," Galati said. "That's why we're anxious to see the particulars of the allegations against them."

Two suspects, Mohammed Dirie, 22, and Yasim Abdi Mohamed, 24, already are in an Ontario prison serving two-year terms for possession of illegal weapons.

Officials said the 17 arrests came after a lengthy operation involving some 400 intelligence and law-enforcement officers and was the largest counterterrorism operation in Canada since the adoption of Canada's Anti-Terrorism Act following the Sept. 11 attacks on the United States.

Toronto Mayor David Miller said he was told by the city's police chief several months ago that a suspected terrorist cell was being investigated in the Toronto area.

"I was relieved that police had discovered the activities at a very early stage," Miller said. "I was relieved on behalf of Torontonians because I knew because of the police activities that if there was an actual threat, they would be able to stop it before anything serious happened."

Mike McDonnell, an assistant commissioner with the Mounties, said Saturday that the amount of ammonium nitrate acquired by the alleged terror cell was three times that used by American anti-government extremists to blow up the Alfred P. Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City in 1995, killing 168 people and injuring more than 800.

The fertilizer is safe by itself, but when mixed with fuel oil or other ingredients, it makes a powerful explosive.

The FBI said the Canadian suspects might have had "limited contact" with two men recently arrested on terrorism charges in Georgia. There was no indication Sunday, however, that the 17 detainees were trying to plan an attack in the United States.

"We certainly don't believe that there's any link to the United States, but obviously we will follow up," Rice said on CBS's "Face the Nation," noting the investigation was continuing.

Aly Hindy, an imam of Scarborough's Salaheddin Islamic Center, said he knew nine of the suspects and complained that Canada's spy agency, CSIS, has unfairly targeted his mosque and congregants for years.

"They have been harassed by CSIS agents and this is what they come up with?" Hindy said. "I'm almost sure that most of these people will be freed."

Hindy predicted the case would end up like a 2003 high-profile security investigation that ended up embarrassing authorities.

That case, a joint immigration and Mountie investigation, was touted as the dismantling of an al-Qaida cell. Twenty-two Pakistani students and an Indian national were arrested, but it ended up being just an immigration case that sent the students home branded as terrorists.

Mohammed Abdelhaleen, the father of one of the those arrested over the weekend, was alarmed by the huge police presence at Saturday's court hearing, where snipers perched on nearby rooftops and dozens of officers armed with M-16 assault rifles guarded the entrance.

Abdelhaleen said he feared his son had already been convicted in the court of public opinion. "The damage has already been done," the father said. "He just goes and prays in a mosque. That's all he does."

Muslim leaders voiced worries that the highly publicized arrests would cause a backlash against their community of 750,000 people.

A mosque in northwest Toronto was vandalized overnight, with 25 windows and three doors smashed, police said. Enuof Baksh, the building's caretaker, said people were distraught when they saw the broken glass Sunday morning.

Mohamed Elmasry, president of the Canadian Islamic Congress, told AP that he and other Muslim leaders were getting threatening e-mails.

He said Muslims would now have to deal with hate crimes, as they did after the Sept. 11 attacks and bloody bombings in London and Madrid, Spain.

"It's already happening. A mosque was vandalized. We hope Canadians will be more rationale and consider the facts," Elmasry said.

Copyright 2006 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

ABC News

That was the story that was originally on the Washington Post site. Now it’s on the ABC website. Copied and pasted the whole thing in case this one changes too.

-----

Seems there is a conflict whether these alleged terrorists have a connection to US suspects? Fair amount of confusion between articles that are being released, reported, and possibly 'leaked' to the press.

------

If I were Harper I would restrict the flow of information that Canadians are being told! :-) Dratted international press--just can't gag or shut them up!!!

comparing the 3 tonnes of ammonium nitrate they allegedly seized with the "one tonne" of ammonium nitrate used by McVeigh to blow up the Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City.

McVeigh's bomb contained more than 2 tonnes of ammonium nitrate.

Here’s one link that says the Oklahoma bomb was about two tonnes. Most authoritative sources say 4800 or 5000 pounds. 2 tonnes would be approx 4400 pounds.

That information is readily available on the Internet. Seems like there is some sensationalizing going on by the police?

Nine nabbed in massive terrorism probe

http://agonist.org/node/31112

Snipers, leg irons, selected evidence, police brass — all calculated to sway the public, lawyers and security experts say

Jun. 5, 2006. 01:00 AM
LINDA DIEBEL
TORONTO STAR STAFF REPORTER

"A good spectacle ... theatrical atmosphere ... like 24 ... an awards show."

Reviews for a Mirvish production, right? Maybe a Hollywood blockbuster or fast-paced new action series on Fox?

Wrong. It's how several lawyers and security experts describe the sombre, indeed frightening, events which transpired in the GTA over the past weekend.

At a news conference Saturday, a dozen of the highest-ranking police officers in the province gathered to announce that an alleged terrorist cell had been shut down before it could explode a truck bomb three times more powerful than the device used in Oklahoma City. They were circumspect about Operation O-Sage, arguing time constraints in the preparation of evidence as well as police procedure.

The anti-terrorism task force was careful about the wording of its news release, saying that the group "took steps to acquire" the three tonnes of ammonium nitrate, a popular fertilizer used to make bombs. As well, they laid out selected evidence for the photographers and TV crews, showing only "sample" bags of ammonium nitrate.

Meanwhile, under massive police security which included sharpshooters on nearby roofs and tactical squad officers with submachine-guns, suspects were brought in leg irons to the provincial courthouse in Brampton. There, in Room 101, Justice of the Peace John Farnum postponed bail hearings until tomorrow morning.

For the experts contacted by the Star, these events were as much about creating an image for the public as about charging the individuals. And it's an image, they argue, that could hurt the right of the accused — 12 men and five youths — to a fair trial.

Being on message — "on script" as the spin doctors put it — is a concept more easily associated with politicians than police chiefs. But for a veteran of the criminal justice system like Toronto lawyer Walter Fox, it's the obvious lens through which to judge events.

The principal audience, in his view, is the Canadian public.

"Police think they have to present a show of force to advance the public's understanding that these guys are dangerous," said Fox. "Does it prejudice the mind of the public? I think so.

"As a criminal lawyer, I am well aware that police and the prosecution are never stronger than at the moment when they've brought their suspects into court for the first time. I've also learned that the stronger the police seem to be at this point, the more suspicious I become that they don't have a complete case."

Overall, Fox tends to believe that the checks and balances of the justice system will probably win out. David Jacobs, a Toronto lawyer with extensive experience in international human rights law, is less sure.

"The fanfare around the arrests creates such a theatrical atmosphere one wonders if it is necessary for the enforcement of justice.... It raises the emotional level without necessarily shedding any light," he said.

In Brampton Saturday, lawyer Anser Farooq, who represents five of the accused, clearly saw the image of snipers on the roof and police armed to the teeth as negative to his clients. "This is ridiculous," he told the Star. "They've got soldiers here with guns. This is going to completely change the atmosphere."

Inside, lawyer Rocco Galati, representing two suspects, complained to Farnum about the leg irons and armed officers in the courtroom, adding: "I do not feel safe with an automatic weapon facing in my direction."

Police evidence was carefully chosen for the news conference, held at the Toronto Congress Centre by the RCMP-led National Security Enforcement Team.

The chief speaker was RCMP Assistant Commissioner Mike McDonell, and lined up behind him were chiefs of police from Toronto, York, Durham and Peel regions, as well as representatives from the Ontario Provincial Police and the Canadian Security Intelligence Service.

"When I saw all that brass lined up with every cop in southern Ontario and Canada telling us what a wonderful job they had done, I thought it was like an awards show," said Fox. "Everybody will tell you it's standard but they are all working to influence the public."

He had questions, as did Jacobs, about exactly how three tonnes of ammonium nitrate were "acquired" by the suspects. The Star has learned that when investigators monitoring the men found out about the alleged purchase of the fertilizer, they intervened before delivery, switching the potentially deadly material with a harmless substance.

Jacobs advised vigilance in seeing what comes out in court about how far police went. He said that the courts have been drawing a line past which law enforcement officers can't go without being seen as having induced the commission of a criminal offence.

He found it interesting that police referred to the 1995 Oklahoma City bombing where 168 people died in an explosion at a federal building. He said that if, for example, police arranged for delivery of the ammonium nitrate, it would shed a different light on proceedings.

"In Oklahoma City, there was no suggestion police were involved," said Jacobs, adding that there are a number of important unanswered questions in the investigation.

Jacobs also criticized police for linking the suspects to Al Qaeda, the terrorist group responsible for the 9/11 attacks, without providing evidence. Police said that cell members were "inspired" by Al Qaeda.

Fox chuckled at the way evidence was presented, notably the use of similar bags of ammonium nitrate, not the actual evidence.

Watching it on TV, he said, he had the sense of reading an old crime pulp magazine from the '50s, with lines like: "At a location similar to the one pictured above, the following events took place ..."

more

Plot began in chat room

CSIS monitored discussions on bombing targets `Training camp' visit turning point for investigators

Nicolaas Van Rijn | June 5 | Toronto

The Toronto Star - For most Canadians, ammonium nitrate — even after it was used to destroy the Murrah Federal Building in Oklahoma City in 1995, killing 168 people, including dozens of kids in a daycare centre — is nothing much more than a commonly used plant fertilizer.

Farmers buy and use it by the tonne, mixing it into the soil to ensure a bountiful crop.

But mix ammonium nitrate with the inflammatory rhetoric of an Internet chat room, and it instantly acquires the potential to become something entirely different, needing only the addition of a little fuel oil to turn it into a lethal bomb.

So when a shadowy group of disaffected urban youth began talking in an Internet chat room in the fall of 2004, espousing anti-Western views, the Canadian Security Intelligence Service was listening.

The spy agency, and an alphabet soup of other security agencies across the continent, closely monitor such sites, where talk may sometimes turn to buildings and bombs and bringing global jihad home to North America, to Canada.

Often it's just that — talk — but when CSIS began monitoring the sites allegedly used by some of the 17 men and youths arrested on terrorism-related charges in a sweeping series of raids across the GTA Friday evening, the Canadian spy agency heard enough to remain interested, and increased surveillance of the group.

[Comment: I have a feeling that this episode is going to end up being mentioned in the debate over electronic surveillance in the United States, particularly if this is how they really made the initial pickup. ~ JPD]

"We declared war on terror, it's not even a noun, so, good luck. After we defeat it, I'm sure we'll take on that bastard ennui." - Jon Stewart.

How would you like to be driving down the road and see this guy in your headlights?

Or be entering a courthouse or other public building and be greeted by this guy?

----



What are earth are they doing with machine guns outside buildings—who are they going to mow down with these things?

Once saw something similar going into a bank in Mexico—never went back to that country because of it. These heavily armed guards aren’t needed for security—a gun in a holster is more than adequate. What are those packages he has strapped to his legs? He looks like an alien creature with that antennae sticking out of the side of his head.

I do remember seeing armed troops in Montreal when civil liberties were suspended because of Trudeau’s Emergency Measures Act. Hundreds were arrested and thrown in jail who had nothing to do with the FLQ. The question we have to ask ourselves is what civil liberties are we willing to give up for the Anti-Terrorism Act? I’m not willing to part with any of mine. Won’t get a passport with a chip or a National ID card that has a tracking device. And I will insist that the government roll back the spying they are doing on me on my computer, email, telephone and other records that violate my right to privacy. Throw away those freedoms and it invites a military society that is ruled by guns instead of laws.

The response to terrorism should be measured and not endanger the public’s ability to live peaceably among the population. Until now, I regarded the police as a positive influence in the communities. They're now turning into scare mongers and people I'd run away from when I saw them. He looks like he'd be pleased to stomp the life out of me with his huge, ugly, black boots. The black eyes of the guard outside is equally threatening. What's next, armed troops in the cities?

Nor was I impressed with seeing these young defendants in leg irons--they've only be accused--they have been found guilty of nothing. The presumption of innocence is a very important ingredient--the onus is on the prosecution to 'prove' their allegations. If the Anti-terrorism Act they're using to prosecute these individuals is too loose to protect the concept of innocence, God help us all because we could be next.

Betcha if they seized my computer, I could also be accused and possibly found guilty because of statements I've made--not once has there ever been an overt act in my life that imperilled another person. But given free access and a microscope that examines my thoughts, there have been dark moments. The prosecution has confiscated the defendants' computers and will use the information they find on them. Who decided they had the right to take them and use their own words against them?

From the Globe and Mail:

Terror in Canada: Perspective, please

Here? In Canada? Right in our midst?

The dread of the enemy within is one of the most powerful any society can confront. News that authorities have broken up a suspected terrorist conspiracy in Ontario is bound to stir such fears. Some will even leap to the conclusion that our experiment with mass immigration and multiculturalism is failing, that our very tolerance and openness have become a weakness. That would be both rash and unjustified.

From the Toronto Star:

"Or it is possible that the only thing that these bits of evidence prove is that a group of young men went somewhere where they tramped around in big boots, cooked on barbecues, played soldier and generally acted like jerks — which young men are occasionally wont to do."

Also from The Star:

"all 17 who were arrested are innocent until found guilty in a court of law. And second, if Canada is to fight those who want to unleash acts of terrorism against us, we all will be compelled to draw upon the best of what Canada has represented over the decades — diligence and fairness."

From the CBC:

"My son is a decent person. He was raised very well. He is a very sensitive, very shy person." Haleem said his son is still recovering from a heart operation he had in April."

From the Toronto Sun:

Were the alleged terrorists captured in the country's biggest ever terrorist bust infiltrated by agents and later entrapped? Does it matter?

"Constitutionally it sure does," said terrorism expert Dave Harris last night.

----

Bring on the trial. I want to see the evidence. We better see something other than some flashlights and a soldering iron: Documents and records, firearms, bomb making material and plans--all of it! If they are guilty let them all rot for 20 years. If they are innocent, then free them.

Not a secret trial but one where it is reported widely in the media. The wheels of justice will determine the guilt or innocence of the charges.

No need to arm ourselves or panic that it has happened within our midst. Rule by law is for everyone and it is the only way to deal with terrorism. I do expect when all the evidence has been heard, the intrusive parts the RCMP and CSIS are currently authorized to use, will be rolled back and privacy restored to all Canadian citizens.

----

Dave,

I agree the number is 4,500 pounds (a little over 2 tonnes) of ammonium nitrate that was used in the Oklahoma bombing. One thousand pounds, which is currently being reported is not the correct amount.

Another Terrorist Attack Coming Soon?

June 5, 2006
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
(CBS) U.S. officials believe Canadian arrests over the weekend and three recent domestic incidents in the United States are evidence the U.S. will soon be hit again by a terrorist attack. Privately, they say, they'd be surprised if it didn't come by the end of the year, reports CBS News correspondent Jim Stewart in a CBS News exclusive.

The first of the domestic incidents, all of which drew little attention at the time, began with the holdup of a string of Torrance, Calif. gas stations last summer. Muslim converts who bonded together in prison planned to use the robberies to finance attacks on 20 Army recruiting stations.

Los Angeles Police Chief William Bratton admits they stumbled on the plot during a search.

"Make no mistake about it," Bratton said. "We dodged a bullet here — perhaps many bullets."

Police in Toledo, Ohio, busted another cell in February. This one consisted of three men training to attack U.S. forces overseas. Once again, luck played a role. When they tried to enlist someone in their mosque to help, he turned them in.

"These individuals are often hiding in plain sight in cities like Torrance and now Toledo," says John Pistole, a FBI deputy director.

Two months ago, a pair of Atlanta men, one a Georgia Tech engineering student, were arrested not long after communicating by e-mail with two of the suspects arrested in Canada over the weekend. The Atlanta men are charged with videotaping domestic targets, including the U.S. Capitol and the World Bank.

Analysts now conclude similarities between all the cases were dramatic: All were self-financed, self-motivated, and in each case the men were seeking out others to join their cell.

In short, Osama bin Laden didn't pay for these plots, recruit for them or even know of them. They were all totally homegrown — even amateurish. But if four, including the one in Canada, have been uncovered in just 11 months, officials fear there are inevitably other plots that have not been and are maturing even now.

The next attack here, officials predict, will bear no resemblance to Sept. 11. The casualty toll will not be that high, the target probably not that big. We may not even recognize it for what it is at first, they say. But it's coming — of that they seem certain.

posted under fair use link

Jun 6, 1:21 PM EDT

Canada Terror Suspect Charges Made Public

By BETH DUFF-BROWN
Associated Press Writer

BRAMPTON, Ontario (AP) -- At least one member of a group of terror suspects plotted to storm Canada's parliament and behead officials, including the prime minister, if Muslim prisoners in Canada and Afghanistan were not released, according to charges made public Tuesday.

Authorities also alleged that Steven Vikash Chand plotted to take over media outlets such as the Canadian Broadcasting Corp.

"There's an allegation apparently that my client personally indicated that he wanted to behead the prime minister of Canada," attorney Gary Batasar said. "It's a very serious allegation. My client has said nothing about that."

Chand is a 25-year-old restaurant worker from Toronto. Charges were expected to be read against at least some of the other suspects Tuesday.

Batasar spoke outside the courthouse, where bail hearings for 10 of the 17 suspects were postponed.

He said the charges were based on fear-mongering by government officials.

Allison Hanes | Toronto | June 6

National Post - The contemptuous tone of United States' admonishments to Iran over its nuclear ambitions is but one source of the humiliation, alienation and rage that propels disaffected Muslim youth to espouse fanaticism, former UN weapons inspector Hans Blix said yesterday.

Speaking to the National Post after his speech to mark the opening of the International Law Association conference in Toronto, the former diplomat and champion of nuclear disarmament, touched briefly on the wave of terrorism arrests that swept Southern Ontario over the weekend.

"To me, as a foreigner passing through here, I would fit it in to the larger picture of the Muslim world -- much of which feels humiliated and infuriated by the non-Muslim world's attitude towards it," Mr. Blix said, speculating about the possible motivations of 17 young men, mostly raised in Canada, to allegedly contemplate launching homegrown terror attacks.

In his view, the majority of Muslims in Canada, abroad or in the Middle East, do not support Iran's drive to enrich uranium, which the international community fears one day could fuel a nuclear weapons program. But he said that the silent majority are often reluctant to raise their voices in opposition when assailed by tough talk that borders on insulting.

For a destructive handful, inflammatory rhetoric becomes a call to arms.

[Comment: I think Hans has this one pretty much dead on. More at link. ~ JPD]

"We declared war on terror, it's not even a noun, so, good luck. After we defeat it, I'm sure we'll take on that bastard ennui." - Jon Stewart.

in an atmosphere of fear:

London raid yields suspects but no bomb

Are UK police now abusing their powers?

What happens, is a formerly very respected and amicable relationship erodes into pockets of adversarial groupings. Gone is the trust relationship that took so long for the police to build between the communities they swore to protect.

I do maintain that Bush, Blair, and Harper by being confrontational and dividing people into us and them creates and contributes to an atmosphere of diverseness. No longer are people homogenous—they become Liberals versus Conservatives, lefties versus righties, radio pundits versus talk radio rational discourse with callers. Once in power it is so easy to change laws that manipulate the electorate. Throw in propaganda and control of the media and the public is persuaded to ramp up the volume to become either an us or a them.

I don’t subscribe to using colourful adjectives or changing the tone of my speech to match because strident opposition is part of the disease and not the cure. Very, very difficult to now be in opposition to loud voices. How will my reasoned opposition be heard above the voices that shout? Mine and other progressives like me are the more difficult challenge of how to respond when all the cards are stacked against reasonable debate. I do have to trust there are others like me that have confidence that law will restore order. The goal is to bring people to power that won’t abuse them and will turn the volume back down.

Harper doesn’t deserve to have a majority government and most Canadians recognize that. Once he’s back in the opposition seats, legislation he has brought into force will be rolled back and individual liberties and controls on the powers police received will be rolled back. Gradually, the trust will rebuild—it will take longer for that to be restored. Easy to build friction, difficult and a long period to restore relationships that existed before the laws were changed.

Blair and Bush have falling numbers in the polls. The longer Harper stays in power, the more likelihood, his will decrease too.

The Star’s depicts the charges that were laid and the connection each defendant has to each charge This is not the time to relax vigilance, but neither is it appropriate to overreact and rob these defendants of their right to represent themselves in court. Five of the defendants don’t have charges relating to bomb-making, but two of them do have charges related to gun offences.

-----

No Dave, I do not think police should stand outside a public building with machine guns and I don't care if they are tactical or ordinary officers. Their guns don't belong in my face to persuade me I need to follow the law. That's a rather deadly persuader wouldn't you say...what choices do I have against a lethal weapon?

foreigners are not anymore considered as persons necessarily deserving of justice and dignity?"

There currently is little oversight over the RCMP

This is the oath police officers take, “I solemnly swear that I will be loyal to Her Majesty the Queen and to Canada, and that I will uphold the Constitution of Canada and that I will, to the best of my ability, discharge my duties as a member of the (insert name of municipality) Police Services Board faithfully, impartially and according to the Police Services Act, any other Act, and any regulation, rule or by-law.

So help me God.”

Police Services Act:

The duties of a police officer include,

(a) preserving the peace;
(b) preventing crimes and other offences and providing assistance and encouragement to other persons in their prevention;
(c) assisting victims of crime;
(d) apprehending criminals and other offenders and others who may lawfully be taken into custody;
(e) laying charges and participating in prosecutions;
(f) executing warrants that are to be executed by police officers and performing related duties;
(g) performing the lawful duties that the chief of police assigns;
(h) in the case of a municipal police force and in the case of an agreement under section 10 (agreement for provision of police services by O.P.P.), enforcing municipal by-laws;
(i) completing the prescribed training. R.S.O. 1990, c. P.15, s. 42 (1); 1997, c. 8, s. 28.

----

Dave, Yes there are times when the police must react with force to protect the laws they swore to defend. At the same time, there is a valid need for oversight to contain abuses of the powers they have. That tactical police officer should not have been outside of that public building carrying his military assault weapon. There was no need for force at the time his picture was taken. The defendants were in leg irons and no longer posed any danger to the public. The show of force was completely unnecessary.

----

You are correct .. I did not offer a flattering portrayal of the other tactical officer who was just doing his job. It is frightening to see police officers so heavily armed I don’t have my head buried in the sand—know they do need arms consistent with the threat. What worries me is the fist picture leads to the second one where there was no threat—just a lady who pulled her hood over her head so the photographer wouldn’t be able to have a picture of her splashed all over the news.

-----

Do you agree the Canadian police have given far too much information to the press about these defendants before their trial? Do you agree the RCMP should not have shared so much information about Maher Arar with foreign countries? Do you agree the RCMP and/or CSIS should be given lattitude to search our computers, e-mail, telephone calls and confiscate our own words to use against us in a court of law without a warrant?

...this: "The defendants were in leg irons and no longer posed any danger to the public" isn't at all germane - that armed officer wasn't there to protect the public from the defendants, he was there, among other things, to protect the defendants from those who might wish them harm. And contrary to your assertions, yes, it was entirely appropriate that he be outside the building, in plain view, so as to provide defence in depth and a visible deterrant.

(As a technical aside, an MP-5 isn't a "military assault weapon" - it's a submachine gun, something that has a highly specialized role and is very infrequently used in the military [and particularly in the Canadian Forces - about the only folks you'll find with them are JTF-2 {and then only sometimes} and naval boarding parties; just about everyone else prefers a C-8 {in the CQB variant with the shorty 10" barrel if they're working in confined spaces and have access to one}]. In fact, the weapon was originally designed for the German Border Police, not the military.)

I agree that there's been far too much speculative information released to the media. My guess is that a lot of the stuff that's leaking is actually from folks that aren't actually directly involved - apparently the officers directly involved have been signed to the Security of Information Act, which as I understand it carries some pretty severe penalties for leaks like this.

As to whether CSIS should be allowed to search without a warrant, I think you're getting very, very far ahead of the available evidence - I've seen no indications that any searches without warrants occurred in this case. I'd guess that there was some collection on these guys by CSE for communications that went outside the country, but as I've mentioned elsewhere in these fora a number of times, that's legal under Canadian law - and yes, speaking even as someone who's doubtless been collected on because of the nature of my personal communications, I think that's entirely appropriate.

"We declared war on terror, it's not even a noun, so, good luck. After we defeat it, I'm sure we'll take on that bastard ennui." - Jon Stewart.

These guys don't miss one opportunity.....

Reuters -
...John Bolton, the US Ambassador to the United Nations, speaking on Fox News, pointed out on Tuesday that the arrests followed two years of police surveillance including wiretaps, observation and tracing of internet usage.

"I hope the American public as a whole understands why these steps are being taken (in the United States), not to invade their privacy, not to find out things about legitimate activities, but to uncover these terrorist networks," he said.

US President George W Bush authorised domestic eavesdropping without a court order shortly after the September 11 attacks.

_{"at some point I'm hopeful I'll figure out something to put here"}

to protect the defendants from those who might wish them harm

It wasn’t and isn’t necessary for a police officer to have a machine gun to protect the defendants from those who might wish them harm. An officer with a handgun in his holster would have served just as well.

This isn’t the first time there have been terrorists in Canada. This is however; the first time there has been a knee-jerk reaction to threats and draconian legal code legislation adopted to combat it. The passage of the Anti-Terrorism Act wasn’t and isn’t needed. Criminal law covers conspiracies, blowing up of buildings, threats to cause physical harm to peoples, and whatever other charge prosecutors would need.

Did you not read Plot began in chat rooms

From the link: “While CSIS and police typically won't talk about their operational methods, the available techniques range from monitoring electronic communications, from cell phones and landlines to emails and computers, to physically following persons of interest as they move about and talk to others.”

getting very, very far ahead of the available evidence

What world are you living in? NSA spying has been in the front pages of the news. International agreements have been signed by Canada, with the EU where information is routinely exchanged using huge databases that are collected and retained for long periods about citizens in a wide variety of countries. Canadians have not escaped from survelliance. It is unfortunately without court sanctioned warrants. Privacy means nothing to governments—they could be watching as I type. "Hi there!!!"

I completely disagree with your conclusion that

speaking even as someone who's doubtless been collected on because of the nature of my personal communications, I think that's entirely appropriate.

It is MHO completely inappropriate to rummage in my computer. I have the right to private thoughts and the government has no business listening or monitoring it. Google Rights to Privacy and Unreasonable Search and Seizure and you’ll find Supreme Court rulings that guarantee those rights. Give away yours if you like, but I’m not surrendering mine unless the court rules that I must.


Militarization of the police is dangerous to the freedom of Canadians.

Ottawa seeks to quash terror suspect's bail
Jun. 6, 2006
JIM BRONSKILL
CANADIAN PRESS

OTTAWA — An Ottawa man accused of terrorist ties "cannot be trusted" to abide by bail conditions and will renew contact with other Muslim radicals if released from jail, the federal government says.

Justice Department lawyers are moving to keep Mohamed Harkat behind bars, arguing he poses a "serious threat to the well-being and security of all Canadians."

The government is asking the Federal Court of Appeal to put his bail — approved last month — on hold until full arguments can be heard.

"Harkat's release would place him in a position to recommence his contacts with members of the Islamic extremist network, allowing them to be involved in planning and execution of terrorist acts," says a federal submission filed with the court.

Harkat, detained on a national security certificate for more than three years, was granted bail, albeit with a raft of strict conditions, by Federal Court Justice Eleanor Dawson.

He is one of five Muslim men facing deportation on certificates — controversial anti-terrorist tools issued under federal immigration law.

The government will contend Friday before the Court of Appeal that releasing Harkat would be a mistake.

The hearing comes just a week after police arrested 17 people in Toronto for allegedly plotting violent acts inspired by Osama bin Laden's Al Qaeda network.

The Canadian Security Intelligence Service says the 37-year-old Harkat is a collaborator with bin Laden's terrorist web.

The spy service, which monitored Harkat for five years prior to his December 2002 arrest, also argues he supports Afghani, Pakistani and Chechen extremists.

Harkat, a refugee who wants to stay in Canada, denies any involvement with terrorism.

Matt Webber, one of his lawyers, was unavailable Tuesday. But Webber has previously expressed confidence the bail decision will withstand a federal appeal.

Harkat has spent most of his incarceration in Ottawa and was recently transferred to a federal facility in Kingston, Ont.

In her May ruling, Dawson said that during testimony Harkat "has been untruthful on a number of significant points."

However, she added that a series of conditions can be imposed that will "contain any threat or danger posed by Mr. Harkat's release."

In its filing, the government disagrees, saying the threat Harkat represents "is in no way either mitigated or diminished" by the court-imposed conditions.

Harkat would be permitted to live in the Ottawa home shared by his wife, Sophie, and her mother. However, he would require constant supervision and must wear an electronic monitoring bracelet.

Under other terms of the arrangement, $35,000 in bail money must be deposited with the court, and another $82,500 in promised funds would have to be committed by Harkat's family and associates.

Harkat would be allowed to leave the house up to three times a week for four hours on each occasion. But he must have approval from federal authorities, wear the electronic bracelet and be accompanied by either his wife or mother-in-law.

Harkat must also surrender travel documents, refrain from using the Internet and agree that his telephone conversations will be monitored.

Toronto Star

-----

The defence
Jun. 6, 2006

Only seven of the 17 accused had found representation as of Saturday. Those lawyers are:

Rocco Galati, who has the highest profile of the lawyers on deck so far. The Toronto barrister made an emotional announcement in 2003 that he was dropping all his high-profile clients in terror-related cases, while accusing U.S. and Canadian security agencies of of making a nasty anonymous phone call (a charge the Canadian Security Intelligence Service denies) and referring to him as "a dead wop."

Galati said later that he had lost his appetite to be a constitutional lawyer because "there is no Constitution left. ... I can calmly and without exaggeration say that, personally, as a constitutional lawyer, I've witnessed the disappearance of the rule of law in our country."

James Silver, currently one of the lawyers representing Torontonian Abdullah Khadr in his fight against extradition to the United States.

The U.S. government alleges that Khadr was involved in supplying ammunition, rocket-propelled grenades and bombs to Al Qaeda forces in Afghanistan.

Silver is a member of the "illegals" — a group of motorcyclists that has travelled to the United States on several occasions to fight for wrongly convicted people.

Anser Farooq, who has a law office in Mississauga, where six of the accused men resided before they were arrested. His calling card indicates that he practices criminal and family law, and that he handles matters such as car accidents, life insurance, slip and fall, defamation, and sexual assault. Anser prides himself on being a trial lawyer who will advocate on your behalf, offering you "a Cadillac defence irrespective of your financial budget."

Toronto Star

=====

Jeez, of that bunch the only one I’d even consider representing me or a member of my family, is Galati. Silver, a former motorcylist and Faroog sounds like an ambulance chaser? :-) They’ll be up against Canada’s very best prosecutors.

-----

Inside the bomb 'plot'
Suspects cited for terrorist training
Six are singled out in explosives plan
Jun. 6, 2006
MICHELLE SHEPHARD AND JESSICA LEEDER
STAFF REPORTERS

Government lawyers will allege 20-year-old Zakaria Amara, a university student and father of an 8-month-old daughter, was the man who purchased three tonnes of ammonium nitrate for bomb attacks on Canadian soil, sources have told the Star.

Court documents released yesterday claim Amara and another five suspects were involved in the bomb plot.

All 17 suspects in what police are alleging is a home-grown terrorist cell are expected to appear in a Brampton court today for the start of their bail hearings.

Amara was close friends at Mississauga's Meadowvale Secondary with Fahim Ahmad and Saad Khalid and all three received religious instruction from 43-year-old accused Qayyum Abdul Jamal at a prayer centre in a Mississauga strip mall. Asad Ansari and Shareef Abdelhaleen also were regulars at the prayer centre.

This is the group, according to court documents, who will stand trial for explosives offences, among other terrorism-related charges. The plot involved using more ammonium nitrate than was employed in 1995 to blow up the federal building in Oklahoma City. That blast killed 168 people.

Investigators who had the group under surveillance for months learned of the alleged purchase and intervened, switching the fertilizer, which can be used to make a bomb, with a benign substance, sources told the Star. Police moved in for the arrests after the bogus substance had been delivered.

Cindy Andrews, a spokeswoman for Agrium Inc., a Calgary-based fertilizer producer, said ammonium nitrate can be bought in bulk for $250 a tonne. The price usually doubles if bought in smaller bags, she said.

In total, 17 suspects, including five under the age of 18 who cannot be identified under Canadian law, were arrested Friday night and Saturday morning in raids conducted by 400 officers and led by the RCMP's anti-terrorism task force.

With the release yesterday of the breakdown of terrorist-related offences each of the 17 accused are facing, more details were added to the complicated web that links the suspects.

The charges also provide a glimpse into the roles police allege each suspect filled, although information on the five youths was not released.

According to the court documents released yesterday:

# Nine of the adults accused, including Steven Vikash Chand, who recently converted to Islam and went by the name Abdul Shakur, are alleged to have attended a "training camp," north of Toronto in Washago. Sources said the group donned fatigues and recorded a video imitating warfare akin to past jihadist battles in Afghanistan, Chechnya or Bosnia.

# Four of the men, including Chand, Ahmad and Amara, are charged with conducting training or recruiting. Amin Mohamed Durrani, who went to the same Scarborough high school where the charged youths attended, is also charged with this offence.

But the eldest suspect, Jamal, who taught some of the group's members about Islam and raised suspicion in the Muslim community for his fiery speeches and association with youths, was not charged with recruiting or training.

# Suspects Ali Dirie and Yasin Abdi Mohamed, already serving a two-year sentence in Kingston after being caught last August bringing loaded guns and ammunition from the U.S. across the Fort Erie Peace Bridge into Canada, now face additional weapons charges for allegedly acquiring the material "at the direction of or in association with a terrorist group."

Ahmad, who sources told the Star rented the white Buick the two men were driving, but who was not charged last August, is now also charged with allegedly helping to acquire the weapons.

It is not clear from the charges if government lawyers will allege there is one discernible leader.

When asked Saturday if additional arrests were expected, RCMP Assistant Commissioner Mike McDonell replied: "I think all of us can say with confidence that we're satisfied this threat has been removed."

But sources familiar with the investigation and who spoke on condition of anonymity, say others are still under investigation and more arrests are expected.

While there is much speculation about international angles to the Canadian case, there are no known examples, with the exception of the arrests this spring of two Georgia men now in U.S. custody, who allegedly were associated with the Canadian group.

However one of the suspects, 23-year-old Jahmaal James, allegedly travelled to Pakistan at some point during the investigation and, said one source, evidence is expected to be entered that claims he was in search of jihadist training.

But those who know him, including Scarborough imam Aly Hindy, say that accusation is preposterous and that James went to Pakistan to get married.

Lawyers representing the accused and relatives say they're eager to hear what police have to support their claims — some already vowing to sue the government for their clients' ruined reputation if evidence doesn't support the sensational claims now being made.

Many are pointing to the 2003 immigration-RCMP investigation known as Project Thread where a group of foreign students from Pakistan and one from India were held on alleged immigration violations and classified at one of their immigration hearings as an "Al Qaeda sleeper cell."

The security allegations were later dropped and the students deported home, where they said they had difficulty shaking the stigma of being identified as terrorist suspects.

Toronto Star

-----

By the way, the reason I site the Globe and Mail so often is because they are the only Canadian national newspaper that has a police reporter, Michelle Shephard, as part of their staff. The Star's editor hired him two years ago and now his articles are reflective of the depth of this news source. Many other papers quote The Star as their primary source for this terrorist story.

(Originally posted in News Queue by Harvey Bushell: 006-06-07 07:29:37 -0500- Editor

Thomas Walkom | June 7

Toronto Star - If these guys are terrorists, they aren't very good ones. At least that seems to be the picture that is slowly emerging of the 17 men and boys charged this week under Canada's anti-terror laws.

Their so-called training camp turns out to have been a swath of bush near Washago, where their activities — shooting off firearms and playing paintball — were so obvious and so irritating that local residents immediately called police.